4 ms·
Headline: "The Farmer Wants a Crop-Spraying Drone" Article reality: CEO starts a drone company and tries to get farmers to want them. > Convincing farmers to
by ryandrake 2y ago
Headline: "The Farmer Wants a Crop-Spraying Drone"
Article reality: CEO starts a drone company and tries to get farmers to want them.
> Convincing farmers to use drones instead of tractors was tough
> Today, selling farmers on the benefits of drones is a big part of Erickson’s job.
- cratermoon 2y agoWouldn't this compete with piloted crop-dusting aircraft, not tractors? Also, what next? Farming - but with AI
- xnx 2y ago> Also, what next? Farming - but with AI Not sure if you're joking, but this is a big area of research/innovation even prior to the latest LLM-fueled hype-cycle From 2016: How a Japanese cucumber farmer is using deep learning and TensorFlow https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/how-a-japanese-cucumber-farmer-is-using-deep-learning-and-tensorflow https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/h...
- a012 2y agoYes.If we could scale the number of robots that work autonomously to pickup/kill weeds then the amount of herbicide could be reduced significantly.
- ysofunny 2y agothe real economic issue is which is cheaper, people or robots? keep in mind that robots are made by people, which strongly suggests using people directly is cheaper the real social issue is you must meddle with the self-development of said people in order to keep it cheap, simply put you must make sure those people stay poor. in modernity this happens across countries (i.e. my theory that countries as a whole are kept poor). I call that practice neocolonialism
- BenjiWiebe 2y agoWhy do you suppose that robots being made by people means that using people directly is cheaper? By that logic, no factories or anything would be automated, as it would be cheaper to use the people directly rather than having people build the automation. Why do farmers even use tractors? Someone had to build that tractor. Wouldn't it be cheaper to hire the people to plant the crop directly?
- ysofunny 2y agobecause a robot costs the cost of the robot plus the cost of the people making the robot whereas people only cost what people cost. the real reason we do have technology is because keeping people poor is terribly evil, and doing that only to have cheap things is somehow even worse. which is the real point I'm making by the way moreover, we're all missing another subtle point I omitted. herbicides are even cheaper than people, robots, or any combination of them. but as it turns out, killing the soil is also a pretty bad thing to do.
- whimsicalism 2y agothis site has really gone downhill
- ajmurmann 2y ago> moreover, we're all missing another subtle point I omitted. herbicides are even cheaper than people, robots, or any combination of them. Is this because herbicides are not made by people?
- ysofunny 2y agoit's because herbicides are easy to "cook" in very large batches
- gwbas1c 2y ago> keep in mind that robots are made by people, which strongly suggests using people directly is cheaper It's much, much cheaper to pay someone to operate an excavator than to hire many people to dig the ditch by hand. This is how modern economies improve everyones' lives: labor-saving devices.
- ysofunny 2y agobut farming already is managing some other actor/agent-like being into doing your bidding and then eating it
- mschuster91 2y ago> Wouldn't this compete with piloted crop-dusting aircraft, not tractors? Yes, and given that flying crop dusters is pretty dangerous (old, shoddily maintained aircraft and "runways", low altitudes over rough terrain) and exposes the fields to lead from the fuel, it's high time to get rid of that. A drone with an automated recharger+resupply base can operate entirely on its own.
- acc_297 2y agoyeah my grandpas brother died crop dusting in Saskatchewan That was a long time ago but I’m not sure the profession has gotten much safer
- cratermoon 2y ago> lead from the fuel Better late than never, I guess, but the FAA has approved unleaded 100 octane. https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2022/september/01/closer-to-an-unleaded-future https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2022/september/...
- mschuster91 2y agoI'm aware - but until the last morons get the message it will be another few decades.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Zambyte 2y ago> Also, what next? Farming - but with AI https://carbonrobotics.com/ https://carbonrobotics.com/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- betimsl 2y agoThis is much more efficient than a diesel tractor that struggles to pull itself.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoTractors famously (its in the name) can pull many times their own weight using a fuel that is cheap and energy dense compared to drone batteries... Farmers don't have enough margin for their most expensive capital outlay to not be extremely good at what they need it for. Tractors can carry many tons of liquid that needs to be sprayed on crops, as well as an implement that can spray a many yards wide swath of crops. A tractor is also something that is needed for the rest of the farming and harvesting operation.
- rrr_oh_man 2y agoThey’re pretty durable, too. My grandfather's tractor has been running on machine oil, curses, and cheap diesel for 40+ years before he sold it off due to age.
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago> Tractors can carry many tons of liquid that needs to be sprayed on crops, You are not trying to flood the field with pesticides And weigh lt us a huge problem, when it’s wet you not allowed to drive in the fields because you will compact the soil, ruining it
- betimsl 2y agoOf course they are powerful and can pull a lot of weight but it struggles doing that. You can hear it in the sound when you let go of the clutch, the stress of the chassis and all that it brings with it. At the end of a day it sprays much more than it is needed, so lose-lose situation. Now if you combine this drone with a targeted spray depositing, you see where I'm getting? P.S. I don't know why my comment was down voted, but ignorance knows no boundaries.
- dghlsakjg 2y ago
- cushychicken 2y agoWhy is this a better idea than a pull behind sprayer that goes behind a tractor and dispenses crop spraying intelligently with AI when it recognizes pests? Seems like a simpler system than using drones, which can fly about 20 mins max on one charge.
- AShyFig 2y agoThe advantage flying sprayers have over a tractor is loss. Driving a tractor through a field will crush a percentage of your crop, and a percentage of that crushed crop will never recover. Depending on the field that percentage can be as high as 10. Depending on the crop, the value you gain by aerial application can be in the 10s of thousands of dollars.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 2y agoBy not having to drive a tractor through it regularly maybe crops can also be planted closer together? Although, there's still the harvesting at the end at which point you'd lose those gains again. > Driving a tractor through a field will crush a percentage of your crop Even if there are "tracks" to account for the tractor's wheels? Nothing would have been planted there in the first place?
- mrguyorama 2y agoLol I was going to say: None of the hundreds of square miles of crops where I grew up have this problem. Maybe corn and soybean fields omit the structure to attempt to get more yield? In which case, crushing some of it is still likely a positive yield compared to not planting ruts.
- AShyFig 2y agoCrush becomes a problem for us in Canola and Lentils during desiccation; which is a chemical application at the end of the season right before havest. As the name implies, desiccation takes a crop which might have variations in "greenness"/maturity and kills it all down to a consistent state for harvest. At this point in the crops life, the canopy is quite filled out, and a large portion of it is already dry. By driving through the feild at this time you knock the seed from the pod onto the ground, where it is impossible to harvest. Thus it is better to do desiccation from the air.
- beefnugs 2y agoThats some hip marketing, i would buy alot of things from someone named "Tractor - The farmer"