4 ms·
Protectionism is expending resources to direct production to areas where you have weaker comparative advantage — it is, in other words consuming value to force
by dragonwriter 2y ago
Protectionism is expending resources to direct production to areas where you have weaker comparative advantage — it is, in other words consuming value to force your people to create less value.
There may be very specific cases where very carefully tailored uses of it are good for certain long-term interests or risk mitigation, but mostly it is waste — and extremely subject to corruption from those invested in inefficient industries.
- avidiax 2y ago> consuming value to force your people to create less value That's the "spherical cow on a frictionless plane in a vacuum" of economics. Protectionism is probably a good idea when the competitor is temporarily subsidizing various industries to build a permanent comparative advantage that can then be abused, either by being an effective monopoly, or by shaping your enemies to be logistically unprepared for war.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoExactly right and love how you phrased it. War is also one of those areas where the concept of economic value falls apart. I do totally agree with dragonwriter that it is vulnerable to corruption
- speleding 2y agoProtectionism does almost nothing to prevent that comparative advantage from being built unless all other consuming countries in the market also add a tariff. And most of them will not. Using the WTO to coordinate a response is a much more fruitful way in such a situation (but the WTO has been neutered by Trump).