4 ms·
There is good reason for that: the US/NATO war plans are not to get into an artillery war in the first place. If there is artillery in the way the US/NATO plan
by bluGill 2y ago
There is good reason for that: the US/NATO war plans are not to get into an artillery war in the first place. If there is artillery in the way the US/NATO plan is send an airplane with a few bombs to take it out. There is still some room for artillery in the army and so we produce some, but that isn't the major way to fight wars.
The Soviet plan - which both Russia and Ukraine are well trained in - was to use lots of artillery. In backing Ukraine NATO suddenly sees a need for some shells that they wouldn't use if it was them. But the Ukrainian generals know them and so that is what they want. (Note too the nobody has provided Ukraine anywhere near the number of airplanes needed to fight a NATO style war - even if all promised F16s arrive today with full training it isn't enough for a NATO war)
- John23832 2y agoRight, I think the idea that America plans to go into an artillery slugsfest misunderstands American military doctrine. One could argue that the reason we weren't prepared to do "artillery war" in Ukraine is because, politically, we're restrained from conducting an air superiority campaign (which would be used to eliminate enemy artillery). The Soviet/Russian land doctrine is totally based on artillery. It makes sense that that is their priority. Now, that doesn't mean that American doctrine would work well in a hypothetical war with China. I personally don't think the current doctrine would work well. But those that watch the military sphere know that brass have taken note of that and are implementing changes. That all you can really ask for.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anikan_vader 2y agoIt’s disingenuous to claim without citation that the US does not anticipate using artillery as one (of many) primary weapons in a land conflict against a near-peer adversary. The fact that thr US hasn’t had such a conflict since at least Vietnam (and arguably Korea) not withstanding. Artillery has proved decisive in every conflict with static lines in the last 100 years. Sure, hopefully air supremacy would overwhelm your opponent and prevent a static conflict, but no air force has ever established supremacy in a conflict with saturated strategic air defenses. Perhaps the US air forces could, but this capability is untested. Sadam and Yugoslavia were limited to tactical air defenses in relatively small numbers compared with modern day Russia or China. In short, artillery remains important, which is why US artillery shell production is up an order of magnitude over the last 3 years, and will continue to rise.
- John23832 2y ago> It’s disingenuous to claim without citation that the US does not anticipate using artillery as one (of many) primary weapons in a land conflict against a near-peer adversary. It's not disingenuous at all. It's pretty apparent if you even take a cursory look at modern American military doctrine/spending. The plan is always to park a carrier close by (maybe two), conduct an air campaign, then send in the troops. Artillery wars just chew up people which the the American public has not had an appetite for since Vietnam. >The fact that thr US hasn’t had such a conflict since at least Vietnam (and arguably Korea) not withstanding. It think that is a caveat as big as the Pacific. Vietnam was literally 60 years ago. You don't think top brass have rethought how wars are fought since then? For context, that's 10 Presidencies since LBJ (36th). > Artillery has proved decisive in every conflict with static lines in the last 100 years. Again, modern American doctrine has focused on the layering of power projection and troop mobility specifically to NOT fight in static positions. > Artillery has proved decisive in every conflict with static lines in the last 100 years. Sure, hopefully air supremacy would overwhelm your opponent and prevent a static conflict, but no air force has ever established supremacy in a conflict with saturated strategic air defenses. Perhaps the US air forces could, but this capability is untested. Sadam and Yugoslavia were limited to tactical air defenses in relatively small numbers compared with modern day Russia or China. Again caveats. Also a war with China will be fought exactly opposite to Ukraine (with missiles not artillery, and with dynamic naval fronts, not trench warfare).
- stanford_labrat 2y agoFighting static positions is what you do when your opponent is literally your neighbor occupying slightly different dirt that touches yours. Which is not the case with China and the US. When you switch from land to water tooling your military doctrine to things like air superiority, missiles, island hoping make much more sense to me at least.
- _xnmw 2y ago> The plan is always to park a carrier close by (maybe two) It's an open secret in military circles that aircraft carriers are useless against a peer adversary like Russia or China, which both have the ability to sink carriers and shoot down planes easily. Carriers are only good against unsophisticated terrorists. But it is pointless to talk about a war with Russia, which would very quickly turn into nuclear Armageddon. [1] https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/us-navys-aircraft-carriers-would-be-useless-china-war-210007 https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/us-navys-aircraft-car...
- _xnmw 2y agoAs a Ukrainian, this sounds like betrayal. We went to war expecting sufficient military support from our superpower partner/ally.
- John23832 2y ago> As a Ukrainian, this sounds like betrayal. We went to war expecting sufficient military support from our superpower partner/ally. You didn't "go to war". A portion of your sovereign territory was invaded, and you did/are attempting to defend it. The fact that the US/NATO are willing to contribute to your defense is just a plus. Ukraine is not a NATO member and has no defense treaties with anyone in Europe.
- berdario 2y ago> A portion of your sovereign territory was invaded, and you did/are attempting to defend it Technically true, but if you get some amount of promised military support, you're going to try to be more ambitious in your defense/counter-attack, and you're going to reject unfavourable peace terms.
- CamperBob2 2y agoGood luck getting any other countries to give up their nukes, with that attitude.
- _xnmw 2y agoThe point is not whether US/NATO would fight an artillery war. The point is about proving your industrial base's manufacturing capacity. Artillery shells should be relatively cheap and easy to produce. It's a really bad sign if America is such a bureaucratic mess right now that production can't be ramped quickly. Doesn't bode well for future war, doesn't demonstrate capability.
- bluGill 2y agoThe US doesn't want an artillery war, so they don't need that, and therefore I disagree. However it is bad that we haven't scaled up patriot production as that is something we would need and should know (in fact we knew that 20 years ago after the gulf war). While asking we should also question how fast we can scale up F35 production along with all the various arms the F35 carries.
- _xnmw 2y agoThe US may not want an artillery war, but the US needs to inspire confidence among partners and allies, and this sort of manufacturing failure really sends a bad signal. No wonder half of Africa is turning away from US/Western partners and looking towards Russia.
- tacocataco 2y agoWith what we spend on the military, it's shameful to not have an entire factory mothballed ready to crank out ammunition. But maybe I'm not a military genius like those in charge of for profit defense contractors.
- bluGill 2y agoIf the factory isn't used you have no idea if it will work. Did mice eat the wires? Machines rust? Did we discover the something is hazardous and we wouldn't use it? Is the thing obsolete and we wouldn't want it anymore? Do we have people who know how to run the factory? This is one reason why the army has thousands of tanks they don't want (the more cynics say is is a jobs program that congress forces on the army - you decide which view you want to take, but both are valid)