3 ms·
Saying that we can either save or consume is a false dichotomy that suggests that a balance of the two isn't possible. The problem with the current system that
by malandrew 14y ago
Saying that we can either save or consume is a false dichotomy that suggests that a balance of the two isn't possible.
The problem with the current system that promotes consumption beyond our income levels is that in the medium to long term it ties up more and more of the money being exchanged as money rent (e.g. interest rates on loans, credit cards, mortgages, etc.) for many people. If you keep spending beyond your income you eventually reach the point where you know longer have disposable income because you're servicing mainly interest. I've been in such a situation myself and know many other people who have also been in a similar situation.
The problem with more and more money being tied up in financial services is that financial services are far less efficient as properly allocating capital than consumers buying what they want. One million consumers spending $1 each will better distribute a million dollars than one investment banker. The only time an investor can better allocate money is when there is demand, but there are structural reasons why a return on investment will not be seen for a long time, due to time spent on "ramp-up" activities such as construction or R&D. However even with these activities, we're now seeing a shift with financing models like kickstarter that turn the debt model on end. Kickstarter permits consumers to allocate capital more efficiently than an investor for goods and services that require up front cash.
The ideal situation for individuals and the economy in the medium to long term is to spend exactly what you earn, no more and no less. This won't produce the best short term results, but also won't result in short-term hangovers later. We waste so much potential and productivity yo-yoing back and forth between periods of under capacity and overcapacity.