5 ms·
Crows "count" the number of self-generated vocalizations
- nine_k 2y agoI wonder why the quotes around "count" are required. > The crows flexibly produced between one and four vocalizations for corresponding cues associated with numerical values. Furthermore, they used different calls for different numbers. Is this because the crows might just remember four separate stimuli, and did not demonstrate an understanding of integers in the Peano arithmetics style? I still think that producing a specific number of vocalizations, well, counts as counting.
- NavinF 2y ago"between one and four vocalizations for corresponding cues associated with numerical values" Counting to 4 seems awfully limited
- fathyb 2y agoNow imagine how limited computers are with their ability to count to only 1.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoMost computers can count to 2^32-1, and many can count even higher! They can also string words together grammatically, which means they are one step away from an artificial general superintelligence explosion. But when non-human animals use AAC systems, or vocalise words directly, to express wants or needs, they aren't really talking, because they don't use tree-like grammars.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- NavinF 2y agoWhat? Even really simple MCUs can output more symbols than 0 and 1 and of course they can count higher.
- yencabulator 2y agoI got paywalled but as a layperson I'd define actual counting as e.g. croaking the same number of times as how many treats are in front of you. So I'd want to see 3 treats -> 3 croaks, not square -> 3 croaks and circle -> 4 croaks, to remove the quotes. At the same time, teaching an animal to repeat a behavior an exact number of times is actually very tricky. For example, a dog will likely over-eagerly repeat the action until rewarded.
- hifromwork 2y agoI think so (not the expert on biology, of course). Depending on the study and setup, crows can count even a bit more, maybe to 6-8. The thing is, humans also can only "intuitively" count only to 7-11 (depending on the person). Counting higher requires some abstract thinking, not just intuition.
- kapitanjakc 2y agoCrows are intelligent, There are some videos out there showing crows playing simple games and stuff... I wonder if crows being intelligent has it linked with them being ominous in many litrature
- tsimionescu 2y agoCrows are ominous in literature and folklore because they are carrion eaters. So, if you see crows, especially in large numbers, that will mean it's likely there some large amount of dead animals or even people around: a very ominous sign almost be definition.
- HenryBemis 2y agoI've seen pigeons eating corpses carcasses of other birds. Those winged rats (I don't like pigeons) will eat anything. As for crows, I live in a country where sometime it snows, and I make sure that when it is very cold (snow, ice, or generally below 5 C)I feed the (3) crows of my building. Every time I am outside, walking, they are always looking after me. Flying near me, standing and looking at me, nodding at me. And I always speak to them when they come close, with calm voice (phrases like "I'm friend, you are good, thank you", etc.). I want to find a way to 'monetize' on this relationship and teach them how to bring me shiny things (I keep thinking but never actually googling on how other people have done this).
- wizzwizz4 2y agoI've thought about teaching them this, but ultimately I decided against. While they may find unclaimed loose change for you, they could just as easily figure out a scheme to distract and rob some poor beggar or busker, and you wouldn't ever know. There's probably some kind of crow-to-crow "these are friends, these are enemies" abstract communication, but I don't think you'd have much luck communicating the concept "to me, humans are friends, so don't rob them on my behalf" across the species barrier.
- deleted 2y ago
- sengifluff 2y agoFive is right out.
- sandworm101 2y agoOf course crows are base-4. A crow doesn't have hands. So if they stand on one foot they have four digits on their other foot for counting. If we had only four digits at the ends of each arm we would be base-8 rather than 10.
- bogtog 2y agoIt's interesting (and cool) how Science has one of their editors write a summary for papers
- TaylorAlexander 2y agoI used to have long conversations with the crows in the back yard at my old house. If you feed them they will trust you a little more than normal, such that when you caw at them they will caw back. They are happy to repeat the number of caws. So if you caw 5 times, they’ll caw back 5 times. Also sometimes I let them go first and I copy them. We did this for sometimes ten minutes straight.
- m463 2y agoI did this once with a noisy jay. the jay would screech, and I would copy it. I did this for enough time for the jay to realize this, and then it went from screech to a pleasant coo type sound.
- localfirst 2y ago[flagged]
- genman 2y agoSure, sure. But we know this story already.
- GrantMoyer 2y agoI find it funny that observations of the cognitive capabilities of animals like in the featured article always induce people to come up with convoluted alternative ways to word the "anthropomorphic" descriptions of the behavior. "Oh that crow isn't counting, it's just basic pattern recognition associating specific quantities with specific sounds", "oh that octopus isn't playing, it's just throwing the bottle around as a stress response to boredom", etc. I get wanting to be careful not to misinterpret the behavior of specices which have evolved different social structures (if any) and under different selective pressures, but sometimes the simplest explanation really is that the animal is doing a "human behavior".
- blowski 2y agoWhat if humans are “playing” because they’re bored?
- sprobertson 2y agoI think that's Grant's point - there's a (potentially) false dichotomy in those descriptions.
- EGreg 2y agoI don’t know if he was he was making that point, but rather he was expressing the desire to avoid anthropmorphosizing by describing the same thing in different words. (Kind of like what I did now, hehe)
- ornornor 2y agoBeing straightforward about it would force us to question a lot of assumptions we have about animals and how we (mis)treat them. We can’t have that!
- mlindner 2y agoBecause straight forward language isn't scientific language and lacks precision.
- Joel_Mckay 2y agoCorvidae are very intelligent, and can readily recognize individual people. Over the winter we tossed out a few peanuts while wearing the same baseball cap, and whistling a specific song. After awhile, the crows changed their dialogues when we walked in the area, and indeed they certainly can communicate with each-other about their environment. We found this rather surprising, and gained a deeper appreciation for their antics. As a consequence, the birds often indicate when someone/something new is in the area. Fascinating little creatures, =)
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoCrows (and other birds, like parrots) are pretty smart. There’s a school of thought/fantasy that the dinosaurs actually had an advanced theropod civilization. Cool idea. Not sure I buy it, but they might have been quite intelligent. I used to like seeing the Japanese crows, in Tokyo. I’ve heard they can be real pests. They are big. Like, raven-sized.
- bena 2y agoRavens are crows, crows are ravens. They exist in the same taxonomic area as frog/toad, bush/tree, etc. The difference between crows and ravens are who found it first
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoThey may be ravens, for all intents and purposes. They have heavy beaks, and about a 4-foot wingspan. They also have a different “accent” from American crows. Wikipedia says they are crows: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large-billed_crow https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large-billed_crow
- spudlyo 2y agoIgnoring size, you can often distinguish between Corvus corax (common raven) and Covus brachyrhynchos (American crow) by the tail feathers; ravens tails in flight have a wider angled cone shape, crows tails have a narrower fan shape. Crows and ravens, taxonomicaly speaking, are of the same genus, whereas frogs and toads are in different families--not exactly the same area perhaps. > Ravens are crows, crows are ravens. I would argue they are distinct.
- bena 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toad https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toad https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raven There’s no real feature that separates frogs from toads or ravens from crows. Taxonomy is more art than science
- 2y ago
- triyambakam 2y agoThere are some Common Myna [1] that live on my land, related to crows in level of intelligence. I have observed them seemingly playing games with betelnut. They pick them, bring them to the top of the roof, release, watch it roll down into the gutter and drain spout, then retrieve it and do it again. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_myna https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_myna
- musha68k 2y agoOnly tangentially related yet quick obligatory shoutout to Cornell Lab's stellar Merlin app if you are interested in deep diving into birds / their communication in general. https://merlin.allaboutbirds.org/ https://merlin.allaboutbirds.org/
- aszantu 2y agothere was this crow in front of the house every morning, training its cawing, I tried to imprint some HarrHo to get it to say hallo, but it just looked like it became self-conscious and flew away, cawing in the distance