4 ms·
US thinking about letting Ukraine use its weapons to strike Russia
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- KorematsuFredt 2y agoThis is not a forum of geopolitics experts but I think this wars is the biggest threat we currently have for tech progress. If Russia takes over Ukraine next step would be proxy wars in Europe, breaking down EU/NATO coupled with US domestic politics turning nativist which will burn our future. This war must end one way or another sooner.
- theGnuMe 2y agoIf Trump wins NATO is sol.
- belter 2y agoDepending who will win the next US presidential elections, the scenarios you highlight can come sooner one would even imagine. In Europe at the moment, there is only one real military power and that is France plus with a little help from the Nordics. The rest is almost non existent, and I am including the current German army. It's calculated they might currently be able to provide ammunition for maybe 15 days... "The state of the Bundeswehr is more dismal than ever" - https://www.economist.com/europe/2023/01/26/the-state-of-the-bundeswehr-is-more-dismal-than-ever https://www.economist.com/europe/2023/01/26/the-state-of-the... A US president hostile to NATO or compromised, would make for very concerning scenario's within months.... On other side, you have a country of 200 million, with a GDP that is almost 20% fully invested on weapons and ammunition production, currently fully on a path of war. Putin could get 2 million soldiers in 3 months in case of a general mobilization.
- avmich 2y ago> On other side, you have a country of 200 million https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependencies_by_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen... Which country are you talking about?
- belter 2y agoOk 146 million...I was off a little bit...
- xenospn 2y ago3 million useless untrained unmotivated soldiers who are not good for much more than dying in droves.
- belter 2y agoUnfortunately the current stalemate has transformed the war into something similar to World War I, and for this type of war those are the type cannon fodder you need to send in waves... "White House Worries Russia’s Momentum Is Changing Trajectory of Ukraine War" - https://archive.is/DchiK https://archive.is/DchiK
- rightbyte 2y agoThreat to tech progress? How is that a priority? If the US and Russia gets into a war with each other, we die. Dunno how many nines of the HN userbase but I guess atleast two? People talk about this in no way like it was reasoned about in the 90s and ... it is a bit concerning.
- belter 2y agoYou can have a few hours warning, if you tag and track Peter Thiel private jet...if you see it heading to New Zealand...
- dragonwriter 2y agoNot for long: https://gizmodo.com/congress-just-made-it-way-harder-to-track-taylor-swift-1851492383 https://gizmodo.com/congress-just-made-it-way-harder-to-trac...
- pylua 2y agoIs this really true? I hope the U.S. would not die. I do guess the fallout could not be contained. However I hope we have planned for and train for these scenarios.
- rightbyte 2y ago> However I hope we have planned for and train for these scenarios. The instruction is to hide under a table. YMMW.
- taskforcegemini 2y ago>However I hope we have planned for and train for these scenarios. if you have enough money you could build a big enough bunker. I don't think there is a plan for the general population? there are many abandoned military bunkers around the world, maybe they become fashionable again.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> if the US and Russia gets into a war with each other, we die America and Russia aren't going to war. Leadership may be nuts, but contrary to popular reporting Putin's war in Ukraine was--at least at its outset--popular among Russia's elite. Those elite are not suicidal. Putin is issuing China's final warnings [1]. Letting American weapons fired by the Ukrainian army hit Russian military targets inside Russia simply isn't a material escalation in proxy war terms. Even the U.S. Navy helping Ukraine with its air defence in respect of missiles and drones wouldn't be a true escalation; the history of proxy wars during the Cold War with the Russian state's predecessor showed that quite clearly. The escalation would be American missiles fired by Americans hitting anything in Russia. That's a hard line we didn't cross in the Cold War. It's a line both sides are excruciatingly respecting today. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China's_final_warning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China's_final_warning
- beardyw 2y ago> This war must end one way or another sooner Sorry, but this is detached from reality. If your country were invaded, would you give up just to make other people's lives a bit more comfortable?
- avmich 2y agoThe war could end in mere months if the West would provide adequate supplies to Ukraine.
- racional 2y agoThis is unfortunately by no means assured.
- avmich 2y agoIt looks at least very reasonable. It's rarely argued that Russia has a severe disadvantage in conventional armaments compared to the West, or even USA alone; even Russian sources periodically admit that openly. It's also rather clear at this point that the war is the war of attrition, so supplies basically determine the results. West doesn't even need to have particular political will - the robust supplies with armaments will do the trick without anything else. No particular sets of sanctions, no diplomatic masterpieces, no boots on the ground are needed - just enough of supplies to Ukrainian army. This may be more problematic, though, than a combination of approaches. Which we see today. The combination, though, doesn't provide results particularly fast - it still is good, though, but not enough for reducing the war in time to some relatively short periods starting from now. Well, we're in the real world. It's not perfect.
- XajniN 2y ago> It looks at least very reasonable. Only if you don’t know much about Russia. The outcome of the war depends almost solely on Russian willingness to fight. We are already two years into the two-week supply of Russian rockets. Edit: formatting
- avmich 2y ago> This is not a forum of geopolitics experts In democracies the ultimate power belongs to people, so it's at least good to know the opinion of them. For this particular war it looks like there's an overwhelming support of Ukraine in the world, including significant portion of people in Russia, especially if corrected for propaganda bias. In case of Ukraine losing - which frankly seems rather theoretical - it's doubtful Russia will have enough resources to immediately continue to other European territories. However, this bad case should be avoided with all seriousness, as it brings only negative results to everybody involved, including Russian people.
- piloto_ciego 2y agoI was an exchange student to Ukraine in high school. Granted that was 20 year ago, but I lived in a predominantly Russian speaking village that is periodically getting bombed by the Russians these days. The news is a menagerie horrors out of UA, and it makes me so unbelievably angry that this has occurred. The Putin regime has done real harm to the world and is a major threat to peace… breaking the long peace in Europe is a major tragedy. I don’t know where this goes, but I think that we have to stop Russia, otherwise it’s Carte Blanche for every shitty dictator and thug to invade their neighbors as soon as they think they can. I wish there was more I could do to help.
- dragonwriter 2y agoThe restriction has, I think, never been ideological, or really about avoiding angering Putin in the way often publicly discussed, but part of a broader strategy of continuously ratcheting up pressure while leaving room for further escalation, with the idea that the if you ratchet up pressure too fast compared to internal Russian exhaustion and regime change, you eliminate room for further escalation short of nuclear war when it might be most productive, whereas if you don’t escalate at all now, you both risk Ukraine losing catastrophically and fail to produce the strain that can lead to collapse of Russian desire to continue the war. With Ukraine already doing deep strikes into Russia with domestically produced weapons and certain NATO members already floating potential deployments of their troops to Ukraine, its not surprising that this step of escalation would be taken now. And, yes, that strategy is a cold calculation, that sacrifices, in the immediate term, Ukrainian lives. The US/NATO trying to blunt conventional aggression by a major nuclear superpower without triggering a nuclear exchange is delicate; and the costs for calculating wrong on either side of the optimum are unthinkably high.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> if you ratchet up pressure too fast compared to internal Russian exhaustion and regime change, you eliminate room for further escalation short of nuclear war How would you differentiate leaving chips on the table from falling for Putin's tough talk? A swift, firm response early on could have given Putin room to propagandise a retreat. That's much harder to do after he's thrown hundreds of thousands of Russians into the meat grinder.
- dragonwriter 2y ago> How would you differentiate leaving chips on the table from falling for Putin’s tough talk? You’d differentiate them by whether escalation keeps happening. If it was just fear of Putin, there wouldn't be continuous escalation in the areas previously seen as concerns. > A swift, firm response early on could have given Putin room to propagandise a retreat. As someone whose position well before the 2022 invasion was that Ukraine should get expedited NATO membership with a (probably time-limited) exception added to the territorial application of Article 5 commitments for then-currently Russian-occupied parts of the country, I don’t disagree, but I will acknowledge that the people making policy decisions on this also, as well as probably being just plain better at this area than I am, also have vastly better intelligence on both the material and the human factors involved, and while its not clear just how wide the policy space is between the catastrophic failure zones on either side, it’s pretty clear those exist. My instinct is that the Administration has been less aggressive than ideal, but I’d sure be sweating bullets about whether I was going to accidentally trigger a major direct superpower conflict if I was, without further information or support, suddenly magically made the decider of policy in this area.
- ajuc 2y agoThe sooner the better.
- exabrial 2y agoSlava Ukraine! Bombs Away!
- hsyehbeidhh 2y agoToo bad nobody is almost left to throw those bombs. Your boys are all dead or drowned in a river. But hey, freedom and democracy Yankees ;)