6 ms·
Discord links! As citations for major results in foundational computer science!
by immibis 2y ago
Discord links! As citations for major results in foundational computer science!
- Analemma_ 2y agoI understand the complaint here, but a lot of recent impressive progress in mathematics has been by rapid collaboration + iteration (e.g. the project to improve Zhang's prime gap bound), and it may be the case that different communication tools are not easily fungible with Discord in this regard. You have to go where the people actually are.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoBut Discord isn't citable. Somebody needs to archive the Discord and make that available through the proper channels (e.g. a website, a book, the Internet Archive).
- univerz 2y agothat post was just an (work in progress) update. Shawn's blog post is a proper announcement - much better than i would have written :)
- lambdaxyzw 2y agoWell it was cited so by definition it's citable. I don't like discord but... The people doing research have chosen this method of collaboration. I like their research. Let's not be choosing beggars and tell them how to conduct their research.
- Almondsetat 2y agoBut papers aren't citable. Somebody needs to archive the paper and make it available through the proper channels (e.g. a website, library, journal, the Internet Archive).
- kryptiskt 2y agoThere are a ton of "personal communication" cites out there that are dead ends. The point of the cite isn't to provide a handy link, though it's nice if it is one, but to hand the credit where the credit is due.
- LegionMammal978 2y agoFWIW, it's a public Discord server, you can find the invite link at the top-right of https://bbchallenge.org https://bbchallenge.org. Also, I'd consider these more as attributions than citations. All the major arguments supporting the results have been replicated in the blog post (in a more rigorous form), so it can stand on its own: the Discord links just provide historical context for those interested.
- j2kun 2y agoFinding bigger busy beaver numbers is not exactly foundational. More like recreational. If it were foundational it would be peer reviewed in a journal article, not posted on a blog.
- mcherm 2y ago> If it were foundational it would be peer reviewed in a journal article, not posted on a blog. What I think you are doing here is to DEFINE "foundational work" as something that gets published in a journal. I don't mind if you use that definition, but if you do then the fact that all foundational work is published in journals is not insightful or informative, it is merely the definition. If, on the other hand, you intended for the statement to say something meaningful about how important scientific and mathematical work is communicated, then you need a different definition of "foundational". And you would have to look to that definition to decide whether this work was foundational, because if it was then it disproves your hypothesis: it would be a counter example that illustrates that some foundational work is shared in places other than journals.
- im3w1l 2y agoTo me, figuring out the halting behavior of small turing machines is similar in spirit going over all short logical propositions and trying to determine if they are true or not. Like it sounds like it could end up being useful somehow.
- j2kun 2y agoIn typical mathematical style, a good definition comes from the properties you observe and desire to hold true in your axiomatic system.
- lisper 2y agoWhy not? The idea that the only valid way to publish a scientific result is in a (so-called) peer-reviewed journal is a relic from 200 years ago when the scientific community was small enough to fit within the monkeysphere [1]. It is being clung to only because it is profitable for a small group of powerful academics and publishing houses, not because it has any actual merit in terms of the advancement of science. In fact, it's probably in no small measure responsible for contemporary replication crises. I'm as staunch an advocate of the scientific method as you will hope to find (I'm writing a book about it!) but IMHO traditional peer review is long past its sell-by date. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar%27s_number
- TeMPOraL 2y agoBecause Discord is a proprietary glorified IRC SaaS; its contents are, by nature, ephemeral and under control of the vendor. I'd expect such links to rot very quickly. Collaborating on Discord is fine. Important results, including citations backing them, should really be published or at least replicated in more durable medium that's less susceptible to link rot, and easier to archive. Today, that's PDFs in paper repositories, or even regular blog posts.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pollyturples 2y agoMySpace: 16 years (2003–2019) Friendster: 12 years (2002–2013) Google+: 8 years (2011–2019) Vine: 4 years (2013–2017) Orkut: 10 years (2004–2014) Path: 8 years (2010–2018) Yik Yak: 4 years (2013–2017) Meerkat: 2 years (2015–2017) Windows Live Messenger (MSN Messenger): 15 years (1999–2014) AIM (AOL Instant Messenger): 20 years (1997–2017) ICQ: Ongoing (since 1996) but significantly declined after the early 2000s Yahoo Messenger: 20 years (1998–2018) Bebo: 14 years (2005–2019, relaunched in 2021) Google Wave: 2 years (2009–2011) Ping (Apple): 2 years (2010–2012) Discord: 8 years (2015-) so clearly discord is inherently different and here to stay forever! /s feels like time is a circle sometimes ha
- UncombedCoconut 2y agoAs a member of these chats: it's often like hitting on an idea on a break-room blackboard and working it out, except the interaction can be cited. That's a positive change, if we can follow through and add to the literature in due time. Here's hoping.
- calfuris 2y agoThat's fine, but the citation shouldn't be in the form of a Discord link, or at least not exclusively in that form. Make a copy of the relevant messages, host them elsewhere, and include that copy in the citation. Discord has been pretty good so far but being a durable archive has never been their core selling point so I don't trust that to continue indefinitely.
- dailykoder 2y agoBetter than math proofs on 4chan[1], huh? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superpermutation#Lower_bounds,_or_the_Haruhi_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superpermutation#Lower_bounds,...
- idlewords 2y agoI thought that was great, too. They should also stream themselves solving this stuff on Twitch.