5 ms·
If you had watched me use this over my shoulder for a minute, this is what you would see: I went to the page, scanned the list to find something that has comme
by williamstein 2y ago
If you had watched me use this over my shoulder for a minute, this is what you would see:
I went to the page, scanned the list to find something that has comments, but everything is listed as "0 Comments". I clicked on "Comments" for the AGI paper, but nothing happens -- it's not a link. There's no "Discuss" link. On HN clicking on the paper title opens the upstream link, not comments, but on your site I discovered that it opens the discussion page. Once there at https://www.papertalk.xyz/papers/2404.10731v1 https://www.papertalk.xyz/papers/2404.10731v1, I noticed that there are in fact 3 comments, but the comments counter at the top still says "0". The comments are also just random gibberish.
I hope you iterate on this project and that it gets massive traction!
- sleno 2y agoReally appreciate the feedback! I'm gonna ship this up, yes there are some gibberish comments i left from testing. Thanks for letting me know about the bugs, and other UI issues, will fix ASAP.
- arrowsmith 2y agoFyi: the UI is completely broken on mobile. I cant read anything at the above link because it extends off the edge of the page in both directions and I can't horizontally scroll.
- sleno 2y agofixed some of the major issues
- redbell 2y ago> but everything is listed as "0 Comments" Also, everything is listed as "0 points" which I found it weird, how would then the ranking work? HN gives 1 point to every story submitted.