4 ms·
What's the typical turn time for a case like this from the time it is filed to the time it is actually in front of a judge/jury? This particular administration
by dylan604 2y ago
What's the typical turn time for a case like this from the time it is filed to the time it is actually in front of a judge/jury? This particular administration only has a guaranteed relevance of about 7 months. It could get extended, or it could get replaced and then cases like this would most likely get dropped.
So, why bring it now?
- cbsmith 2y agoI'm theory, prosecutions are a civil service function, not a political function. Changes in administration might change the leadership and what areas are prioritized, but once you have a case, it really shouldn't matter who is in office. In theory.
- nickff 2y agoWhat theory is this from, some sort of administrative state theory? This has never been the case in any executive branch that I'm aware of.
- dylan604 2y agoExactly this. The first few days in office, a new POTUS will typically use executive orders specifically to reverse policies the previous administration put in place.
- cbsmith 2y agoYes, the administration can change policies, but dropping cases is another matter. Certainly policy changes can have an effect on cases, but it's not like cases get dropped at some dramatic rate when a new administration comes in.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoEO cannot be used to drop pending litigation. It would require a different mechanism
- dylan604 2y ago> different mechanism POTUS: Mr Attorney General, it is this administrations agenda to no longer pursue these specific cases: anything with me as the defendant. AG: Understood Mr POTUS, we'll back burner everything that cannot just be stopped or dropped. <end scene>
- Retric 2y agoThe vast majority of cases aren’t dropped when you move from one administration to another. However, there’s a great deal of correlation between cases people care about and politics so you’re more likely to hear about the kinds of cases that get dropped.
- nickff 2y agoI agree that most political factions actually agree on most policies, but that doesn’t mean the decision as to whether to proceed is ‘civil service’ rather than ‘political’.
- Retric 2y agoPolitical sure, but I don’t think you can call something politics without there being some debate. Should we build a road is a classic political choice because people disagree even if it’s generally a net positive. Should we prosecute a murderer may qualify if there’s some twist (ex stand your ground) but not in the general case.
- cbsmith 2y ago> Should we build a road is a classic political choice because people disagree even if it’s generally a net positive. Should we prosecute a murderer may qualify if there’s some twist (ex stand your ground) but not in the general case. What laws get passed/repealed are decided on by people elected to office. Policies and priorities for departments are decided upon by political appointees. Decisions on cases though? Those are generally delegated to the civil service. Now, from a practical standpoint, there's obviously ways you can muck with policies and priorities that can impact a particular case, just like there are ways that you can change the laws to muck with a particular case (you may recall when Florida went after Disney, they had to bend over backwards to draw up the law such that they could claim they weren't explicitly going after one company), but that's exactly the kind of stuff that draws criticism (and there are rules against it). There is absolutely a principle of independence & impartiality of the DOJ that's been the norm, even if recently that norm has been eroded.
- 2y ago
- ldoughty 2y ago"I want you to make sure this case goes nowhere, can you do that?" "No!" Fires leadership "I want you to make sure this case goes nowhere, can you do that?" "You got it!" Hires There certainly is some of this every administrative change over.
- cbsmith 2y agoThe political leadership generally can't fire civil servants for that reason. When Trump was in office, he complained about it a lot, and key part of Project 2025's policy plans are to get the rules on that changed: https://www.project2025.org/ https://www.project2025.org/.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoHow well did that work out for Nixon?
- cbsmith 2y agoThe independence of the DOJ has always been perceived as important. A lot of ink was spilt about this during the Trump administration, as they attempted to undermine these norms (e.g.: https://www.americanprogress.org/article/restoring-integrity-independence-u-s-justice-department/ https://www.americanprogress.org/article/restoring-integrity...), with some degree of success. You may recall Trump's various battles to get the DOJ to do things that the DOJ didn't want to do (and unfortunately, in some cases, he did get his way, but a lot of the time, he did not). One of the key objectives of Project 2025 is to claim control of the operations of the DOJ from the "unaccountable bureaucratic managerial class and radical Left ideologues who have embedded themselves throughout its offices and components": https://static.project2025.org/2025_MandateForLeadership_CHAPTER-17.pdf https://static.project2025.org/2025_MandateForLeadership_CHA...
- LordKeren 2y agoI would assume that like most of these kinds of very public cases, they spent a significant amount of time building their case internally before committing to filing suit. Trying to guess at the internal machinations for how a bureaucracy sets priorities and budgets is a bit of a fools errand though
- light_hue_1 2y agoOne of the signature policies Biden is running on is his fight against junk fees. That's why this is will overlap the election. And why no one would be surprised if nothing happened if Biden lost.
- gotoeleven 2y agoHe's against junk fees, malarkey, and airing Matlock later than 7pm so he has my vote.
- cmilton 2y agoIn the article, they mention both the Trump and Biden administrations initiating investigations. Only since Obama, has this been “approved”. What leads you to believe it would most likely be dropped?
- dylan604 2y agoBecause the next admin has already declared their policy will be of reversing anything and everything the current admin has done. Out of spite for the most part, but this one also happens to be something that hurts business so it'll be ripe for them to want to remove limiting a corp.
- akira2501 2y ago> This particular administration only has a guaranteed relevance of about 7 months. That is a deeply cynical view on the nature of politics. > So, why bring it now? Why help anyone else if you can't score political points off the back of it? Possibly because it's the right thing to do and ideologically motivated people actually do successfully exist in government.
- dylan604 2y ago> That is a deeply cynical view on the nature of politics. How? If the bid for re-election is lost, they leave office Jan 20th. That's not cynical. That's being able to read a calendar. If you think a new administration, specifically the one that would be coming in, will not immediately reverse a lot of things, then you just have not been paying attention.
- akira2501 2y agoThen they just handed them that victory without extracting any sort of price. The incoming challenger is riding on a "populist" base. These polices are legitimate "populist" policies. The strategy here is obvious.
- dclowd9901 2y ago> relevance of about 7 months Okay, buddy. Regardless of your political leanings, Biden himself extended a deeply reviled policy on handling border refugees. I think the “cooler” view is that they’re just figureheads.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoTheory of the median voter and all that