7 ms·
Congress Just Made It Basically Impossible to Track Taylor Swift's Private Jet
- DerCommodore 2y ago[flagged]
- ImAnAmateur 2y agoAt least curate your AI's output. This needs better punctuation and could use some editing.
- mikece 2y agoThis looks like an idea for a Show HN: an article summary bot which posts a three to five bullet point summary of articles submitted to HN...
- mikece 2y ago"Celebrities and billionaires have long complained that it’s just way too easy for random people on the internet to monitor how much fuel exhaust they waste as they flit through the skies via their private jets." I suspect it's the second part -- and the very powerful, rich people who fly their private jets to global climate conferences -- who had more to do with this legislation than the blond cover-girl with which it's being associated. Wake me up when the FCC is required to anonymize personally identifying information in the amateur radio registration database as well... I never give out my callsign because it would be too easy for people to figure out where I live. But then I'm just a private, normal, tax payer and not a celebrity or billionaire who is already a public figure.
- nullserver 2y agoYou’re forgetting all the billionaires that were flying places like Epstein Island. Bill Gates had something like 23 or more visits there.
- mikece 2y agoRight. Or the celebrities who are photographed landing with a date which isn't their spouse? There have been some high-profile divorces that started from evidence like that. The larger point is that this is for the benefit of "The League of the Very Special" and not out of an actual interest in privacy of PII.
- wannacboatmovie 2y agoNever underestimate the power that the Swifties wield.
- Arrath 2y agoFlight plans still have to be filed, right? And are any of those details public, as in would a flight tracker show the destination of a plane in flight? If so, time for some traditional intelligence work: someone at the airport with a telephoto lens to document just who disembarked from the plane.
- mikece 2y agoThe flight plan might include the registration number of a plane but if the ownership database is anonymized then it would require a fleet of "aviation enthusiasts" to determine on their own who owns which planes and then cross-reference filed flight plans with such a private database in order to dox the movements of celebrities. Would probably be an interesting business opportunity if it wasn't a giant "sue me!" target for people who have lots of money and are willing to drop $100k in lawfare on someone to make them go away.
- gregors 2y agoWealthy people have enough sway to get the laws written they want. It's nothing new. Our politicians are legally bought and paid servants.
- consp 2y ago> Our politicians are legally bought and paid servants. Isn't that illegal? (... withdraws into ignorance cave)
- gregors 2y agoBribery is illegal, but lobbying is completely legal https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0912/the-differences-between-bribery-and-lobbying.aspx https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0912/the-differe... That being said, off the books "I really want this" probably carries some weight when it comes from large donors I'd imagine. Is that bribery?
- malfist 2y agoCurrently, with the latest SCOTUS decisions, only explicit quip pro quo (i.e., I give you money, you vote for a law) is illegal. If I give you money, and then complain publicly that we need a law about something and you vote for it, that's not illegal.
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoDig up and ask John McCain how successful campaign finance reform was. I'll wait. ;@) Or: Bob "gold bars" Menendez, Rudy Giuliani selling pardons for $2M USD, or almost every form of paid lobbying and campaign fundraising. (Cooome baaack. Thhhhe caaaave issss tooo darrrk.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_federal_officials_convicted_of_corruption_offenses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_federal_...
- theturtletalks 2y agoMost laws bind the weak and protect the strong
- paulpauper 2y ago
- tivert 2y ago> I suspect it's the second part -- and the very powerful, rich people who fly their private jets to global climate conferences -- who had more to do with this legislation than the blond cover-girl with which it's being associated. Yeah, I mean I doubt this would do a damn bit of good for a celebrity like Swift, because some fan is probably paying attention enough to figure out the tail numbers of the jets she's flying in. It's the billionaires who aren't celebrities who will benefit from this.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- underseacables 2y agoWell, you give it out on the radio. What's the difference?
- koolba 2y ago> Of course, it’s worth pointing out that, unlike someone like Musk, Swift actually had a pretty good reason to travel a lot last year: she was on tour. Yes, because the richest man on the planet, heading up multiple billion dollar companies, couldn’t possibly have any legit reason to travel anywhere.
- baryphonic 2y agoI laughed out loud when I read that. Would expect nothing more from Gizmodo.
- ImAnAmateur 2y agoIts frustrating because it buries better points under mud. The effective way to reduce jet emissions is not to publicly rag on the people who have the money to use the service. I would go so far as to say that the author does not actually care about the subject at all, only perhaps being able to deride others to prop themselves up as not as bad as them. The subject as presented like this leaves little room for talk about alternatives or ways to reduce jet emissions. It poisons the conversation by starting down the wrong direction.
- dan_atem17 2y ago[dead]
- snapplebobapple 2y agoMore than that, it ignores the fundamental principle that America is founded on: I paid for it STFU. If there is actual market failure due to externalities then get the votes to raise the cost to cover the externalities (i.e though a carbon tax), but don't think your judgement calls on who should be able to do what should have any bearing on reality. Raise the price until your externality is properly priced or until you lose the political will to implement and then let everyone decide if they are buying or not at the new price. What made America great was recognizing everyone is too stupid to make any of these calls and letting individuals exercise their own judgement (and experience the costs of that judgement). It was a great system that worked wonders and was self regulating and we have drifted far too far from it.
- lbwtaylor 2y agoTaylor Swift doesn't care that "it’s just way too easy for random people on the internet to monitor how much fuel exhaust they waste" She wants privacy, as is amply demonstrated by her actions on this topic. There is zero evidence that she cares about people monitoring her fuel use. The article goes even further off the deep end, suggesting Swift is trying to game search engines to bury jet fuel stories, with zero evidence. Tabloid nonsense.
- elevatedastalt 2y agoDunno why you were downvoted. This is exactly it. Taylor and Musk would be okay if there was just an annual report saying "Taylor's jetsetting caused X tons of CO2 emissions". What is NOT OK is someone effectively able to put a tracker on her movements.
- zellyn 2y agoAm I wrong in thinking that if the same person uses the same plane for multiple, documentable trips, or if they are spotted entering or exiting their plane, it should be possible to de-anonymize their flight data?
- Ekaros 2y agoIn case of some celebrity wouldn't it be pretty simple to analyse flights and compare them to known appearances. Like say concerts. If same plane appears to visit a city where same person make appearances very close, it seems pretty reasonable they are one using it.
- sparker72678 2y agoUnless they have a way to roll the ADS-B info, it should be pretty easy to work all this out. Hard to imagine this will actually make jet tracking sites/accounts/etc disappear.
- gorkish 2y agoNo you are entirely correct; the registration data is already effectively anonymous for any entity that has chosen to care about it. To be honest with you, anyone I know who is wealthy enough to own a plane is already set up with a mountain of LLCs to own shit anonymously. This legislation is a NoOp
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- system2 2y agoA few hundred years from now these private jet flying douche bags will be remembered as the most evil creatures of our time.
- ImAnAmateur 2y agoNo they won't. If you care so much, why do you not care more about the laws that give them full permission to do this? Edit: I'm being too harsh. To rephrase: No, I don't think they will. I think that history will sooner put the blame on society and government as a whole. The people flying private jets do not do so in a vaccuum.
- paulpauper 2y agolots of ppl fly private. not just super-rich people. many flights are chartered
- pennomi 2y agoNot the world leaders who started massive wars?
- IvyMike 2y agoI'm curious exactly what this means. I mean, the plane will still be broadcasting ADS-B info of some sort, right? If it's an empty registration number, well, to quote The Simpsons, "We'll look for the house with no numbers."
- kotaKat 2y agoIt just means when you go to look up the registration via https://registry.faa.gov/aircraftinquiry/search/nnumberinquiry https://registry.faa.gov/aircraftinquiry/search/nnumberinqui... instead of getting registrant data you just get "yes this plane exists" or something similar. Unlike cars, you could just see who owned a plane based on its tail number without any sort of special access. People DO try to hide that by using shell companies, but you can still track those shell companies. AKA... people will just have to spread the word what people use what planes with what N-numbers. It's not like we don't already know the tail number of these people's jets or their transponder codes in the sky, no matter what they do.
- matchagaucho 2y agoSame question... ADS-B transponder surely remains on to prevent in flight collisions / maintain vertical sep. Guessing FAA is just committing to anonymize their public part 135 operators list.
- NovemberWhiskey 2y agoThe point is that you could change the particular privacy identifier used each flight, in principle.
- highwayman47 2y agoCO2 for me and not for thee
- khazhoux 2y agoIs someone tracking your CO2 emissions when you drive or travel by commercial jet? There's no database I'm aware of where I can search for your name and see all your vehicular movement.
- mrob 2y agoThe correct way to solve the market failure of externalities is taxation, not social shaming.
- readthenotes1 2y agoBecause taxation works for fairly? Social shaming is completely valid, and powerful. Just ask Ghandi if you don't believe me
- throwaway51081 2y agoThere is a direct relationship between fuel usage and carbon dioxide. It's very simple to tax fairly.
- readthenotes1 2y agoLike carbon credits? Pretty sure that's been gamed ...
- throwaway51081 2y agoNo, like consumption tax. Pretty sure that can't be gamed.
- havblue 2y agoThis isn't directed at swift as much as at the wealthy in general. What you might call social shaming, many people simply call transparency. Or, if you're going to tax my SUV more I'd like to find out if it impacts your corporate jet proportionally.
- jacobsenscott 2y agoThat jet fuel wasn't going to stay in the ground or anything if these people don't fly. Sure - they contribute to to burning it up slightly faster than if there were no private planes, but rest assured people are going to burn everything that burns, until there are no more people.
- IG_Semmelweiss 2y agoMark it for a W for privacy. A win for privacy should be celebrated even if the avg person wont (yet) benefit.
- baseballdork 2y agoIndeed, now I know that when I get my private plane (I'm temporarily not a billionaire) I will also benefit. Privacy isn't some monolithic good. There are, frequently, very good reasons to restrict privacy. Things like the finances of politicians, court proceedings, and the ultra-wealthy flying around in private jets disproportionally dumping C02 into the atmosphere all seem to be worth sacrificing a little privacy.
- IG_Semmelweiss 2y agoFull privacy for private individuals. Full transparency for public officials, all types. If you are on the public dole, you forego your right to privacy. Its not that difficult. I don't consider a jet, of any ownership, to be fair game. If you want to go after pollution, then do it. Removing privacy is not an acceptable substitute.
- zzo38computer 2y agoI also think so. Hiding who owns or operates the airplanes isn't what causes fuel exhaust, I think.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sharpshadow 2y agoP. Diddy getting jealous.
- khazhoux 2y agoI enjoy the tone of this article, which thinks we are entitled to track the movement of private citizens if it involves too much jet fuel.
- krapp 2y agoWhy not? The rich, the police and government track our every movement, word and deed through our technology. Why shouldn't we be able to track them back? If we can't dismantle the pantopticon let's at least make it equitable. Everyone suffers.
- gorkish 2y agoAnonymizing aircraft registration was, for the most part, already possible. I first figured this out when I started playing with ADSB reception many years ago before it became the trivial effort it is today. The first plane that I happened to receive just happened to be a learjet registered to "Bank of Utah" or something similarly obtuse. It took all of about 30 seconds to figure out this was Steve Jobs' plane; it had already been removed from all public tracking databases. (aircraft owners can request their aircraft be removed from datasets like flightaware, etc.) I don't think this new legislation has any practical effect on the ability to track a specific aircraft. Once you figure out which one you want to track and have sufficient ADSB coverage, you will be able to track it. It's not as if the tail numbers are changing between flights.
- NovemberWhiskey 2y agoThis isn't to do with aircraft registration: it's to do with the fixed airframe identifier in the Mode-S data. By default, a single airframe (plane) will also squawk the same identifier on Mode-S, which can be picked up by passive receivers owned by the general public.
- gorkish 2y agoYes; I know. But similar to tracking a wireless client by MAC address, it could be possible to enhance the system to assign single-use identifiers to flight plans such that it would be radically more difficult to casually associate tracking data to specific aircraft in realtime. I'm not advocating for any change necessarily; just pointing out that RF emissions of a modern aircraft do nothing to belie its identity. The registration information itself is irrelevant to tracking the aircraft movements.
- JohnMakin 2y agobillionaires love tracking our every move and whim for profit, but when it’s turned around on them, they don’t like it so much, and congress immediately goes to action. Should probably tell even an uninformed observer a few things about the state of affairs.
- underseacables 2y agoI wonder if this will make it easier for politicians to fly around on private jets...
- belter 2y agoIt's amazing how Congress can be quick and effective when it wants.
- NovemberWhiskey 2y agoI have to ask: if we think privacy is a right, then why does flying in a private jet mean you give up that right?
- pc86 2y agoA couple spring to mind, none of which is specific to private jets. Airspace above the US is nationalized. It's managed by the government, which is funded by taxpayers. So they have a right to know who is doing what using that airspace. Flying secretly (or at all) is not a Constitutionally protected activity so there's nothing inherently wrong with regulating it and denying something like this. Either one of these is a good enough reason not to allow this type of thing in my opinion.
- giantg2 2y ago"Flying secretly (or at all) is not a Constitutionally protected activity so there's nothing inherently wrong with regulating it and denying something like this." You can use this reasoning to disclose almost anything, including online real-id schemes, public license plate info, etc.
- NovemberWhiskey 2y ago>Airspace above the US is nationalized. It's managed by the government, which is funded by taxpayers. So they have a right to know who is doing what using that airspace. Flying secretly (or at all) is not a Constitutionally protected activity so there's nothing inherently wrong with regulating it and denying something like this. That seems like an absolute argument against any kind of right to privacy. So you'd equally have no concern at all if there was a publicly searchable registry of every flight that every passenger was taking on a commercial carrier? The roads are managed by government and funded by taxpayers: should there be a publicly searchable record of every vehicle movement on the roads as well?
- pc86 2y agoI was arguing against the right to fly a plane secretly or obscure its transponder code from public consumption, yes. > So you'd equally have no concern at all if there was a publicly searchable registry of every flight that every passenger was taking on a commercial carrier? There is a searchable registry of every flight already. The passenger thing is something you added that I never brought up. > The roads are managed by government and funded by taxpayers: should there be a publicly searchable record of every vehicle movement on the roads as well? Well the closest thing to an aircraft transponder is a license plate, and it's pretty well established case law that you have no right to obscure your license plate and that you have no right to privacy with regard to that license plate being recorded, being run by the police without cause or suspicion, etc. The fact that there isn't a publicly searchable record of automobile movements is simply because automobile movement isn't as strictly controlled as aircraft movement. If cars needed transponders in them and you needed a controller to give you permission to take an exit we'd have basically the same system for cars.