4 ms·
I always wondered: Since Alarm Fatigue is well known, why do UX designers and/or product owners keep insisting on adding new alarms for things? Surely we know t
by ryandrake 2y ago
I always wondered: Since Alarm Fatigue is well known, why do UX designers and/or product owners keep insisting on adding new alarms for things? Surely we know they increasingly don't work, the more you have.
- thephyber 2y agoAlarms are easy for a single person to add. The better solution is to redesign / engineer systems which automatically solve the alarm condition so no person needs to know about the alarm. That usually requires many people to work together and requires far more complexity to solve, both initially and in ongoing upkeep.
- bombcar 2y agoBecause if someone dies because you didn't alarm an alarm, you get yelled at. If someone dies because they ignored an alarm you did alarm, that's on them.
- nucleardog 2y agoThere’s some small fraction where someone believes it would be helpful but was mistaken. What you’re describing is definitely the vast majority. When something unexpected or out of the ordinary happens, what do you do about it? - Nothing? Why did you do nothing? This was clearly a problem. This is your fault. - Figure out appropriate error handling? That’s hard work. - Just throw up an alert on everything and make it someone else’s job to sort through it all? Perfect, job done.
- mrguyorama 2y agoBecause modern design philosophy has, as a rule, thrown everything we learned before 2010 out the window because that's not what google does. "But the A/B tests show consumers prefer it!". Oh? So you have a degree in stats and experience running scientific tests? No? You're just a programmer who only knows how to enable the A/B test feature of your favorite javascript library? Your A/B tests aren't testing what you think they are testing.
- BobaFloutist 2y agoThe expected marginal benefit of any given individual alarm is positive. it's extremely hard to find the point where it becomes negative. Think of it like emails, or texts, or calls: What's the exact number per day where you stop paying attention to them?