4 ms·
This was fascinating to me. Also, I was apparently using my own personal definition of "engine" that was somewhat different than the other modern usage. To me
by JohnFen 2y ago
This was fascinating to me.
Also, I was apparently using my own personal definition of "engine" that was somewhat different than the other modern usage.
To me, a "motor" is something that translates energy into motion. An "engine" is something that translates energy into work. So a motor is a kind of engine, and uses of "engine" in knowledge work is an analogy.
- dylan604 2y agoYour engine definition is interesting as we have phrases like database engine and other software based uses of the word.
- Tagbert 2y agoI think, once you get past mechanics, the definitions are going to diverge pretty quickly.
- nemo44x 2y agoYou used the word "translates" instead of "transforms" or "transfers". Is there a particular reason for that?
- foolswisdom 2y agoThat actually fits well with the origin of the words (as described in the article). And it makes sense because engine is sometimes used metaphorically (?) (as you note), while motor is not.
- LinAGKar 2y agoWhat would count as "work" under that definition (that's not motion)?
- JohnFen 2y agoYeah, the distinction is a bit fuzzy. I can come up with some examples, such as certain kinds of pumps that don't involve moving parts. But when I think of things I call "motors" and "engines", I admit the distinction appears arbitrary (but clear nonetheless in my mind). For instance, if there's a device that moves things as a component of a larger machine, I'd call that device a "motor", but am likely to call the larger machine an "engine". And to go back to the pump, I'd call the device that moves to push the liquid a "motor", not an "engine", for no good reason. As with much of English, this "rule" has enough exceptions as to question whether or not it should be called a "rule". I put "rule" is scare quotes because what I was originally describing is decidedly not a rule at all, just a description of how I tend to use those words.
- msravi 2y agoMy personal definition of "engine" had to have something combustible inside it that caused motion. So fossil fueled cars and buses and rockets had steam engines and internal combustion engines and rocket engines, but electric cars like tesla have motors!
- hypertele-Xii 2y agoSteam isn't combustible? What about the Stirling engine, powered by heat gradient and air?
- jabl 2y agoSteam engines and Stirling engines are both examples of "External Combustion Engines", whereas piston engines and gas turbines are examples of "Internal Combustion Engines" (ICE).
- cm2187 2y agoBut you don't say "jet motor". I think it's probably like pork vs pig. They are technically the same but the language has come to use one vs the other in a different context (food vs animal).
- vlachen 2y agoI think that's just a matter of jargon. As an aircraft mechanic, I heard and spoke the phrase "Pull the motor on aircraft..." Many times. We used engine and motor interchangebly on an engine thrust powered aircraft.