3 ms·
Yes, it absolutely does count. You might indeed consider it non-obvious and surprising -- I certainly did when I first learned of it growing up here. Another c
by crazygringo 2y ago
Yes, it absolutely does count.
You might indeed consider it non-obvious and surprising -- I certainly did when I first learned of it growing up here. Another classic example is that a thief can sue you if they fall through rotting floorboards on your porch and break their legs.
But we've collectively decided, as a society, that property owners are not just prohibited from booby trapping their properties, but are required to actively maintain them in a safe condition according to reasonable standards.
If there's something a reasonable person would know was a safety risk on their property, they'll be held liable if they didn't fix it and somebody injured themselves because of it.
The thinking is basically -- kids will run around onto other people's property, people get lost, etc. We know kids go where they're not supposed to. Nobody should be risking injury or death just because of that, if and when reasonable safety precautions by the property owner could have prevented that.
In other words, we live in a society, and we have a certain minimal level of active duty of care towards others. Owning a piece of property comes with rights but also responsibilities.
- stragies 2y agoDon't at least the parents of the kid that drowned in your pool while trespassing on your land get at least a charge of "criminal negligence" against them? IANAL, but aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult? And 14+ years old that drowns in a pool for inability to swim is also something that should be blamable on the parents, not the pool owner. Edit with clarifications after comments: I meant, parent's should be supervising their young kids, or take the risk/blame, if something happens to the kids while they aren't. (I roamed 'unsupervised' in fields and forest at young age with friends, and enjoyed it. But I was also taught to look where I step, and how to swim)
- tylermw 2y ago> but aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult No. The age which supervision is required varies by jurisdiction. > And 14+ years old that drowns in a pool for inability to swim is also something that should be blamable on the parents, not the pool owner. There's no law stating you need to teach your kids to swim.
- gampleman 2y ago> IANAL, but aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult? Not in most jurisdictions (thanks God). That's a terrible idea for raising kids.
- chrisBob 2y agoBeing a parent is hard. I would say that half of the US thinks parents are the problem with kids these days and that a good kid should "spend time outside in the neighborhood like we used to", and then the other half will call the police if your child is out of sight because "aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult?"
- vundercind 2y ago> aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult Hell no. A world where a nine or ten year old can’t go roam the neighborhood on bikes with some friends unless adults accompany them would be a dystopia. I know there are occasionally news stories about very-stupid harassment of parents for parenting correctly, but thank god it’s still not the norm.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoNo, the negligent parents get rewarded with your house and assets. Kids should not be supervised at all times, but parents should also assume the risk for what happens when they aren't supervising their kids. Managing risk-reward is a natural part of life and being an adult. Attempts to completely eliminate risk leads to miserable lives and societies.
- gottorf 2y ago> Attempts to completely eliminate risk leads to miserable lives and societies. Covid response in certain jurisdictions was a great example of this. "If it saves even one more life, it's worth it!"
- sidewndr46 2y agoIn the US a criminal charge against someone is not relevant for a civil liability lawsuit. Civil suits are between citizens. Criminal suits generally have the plaintiff as the state government, albeit with rare exceptions such as RICO.
- mindslight 2y agoBut apparently there's no duty of care towards oneself to not trespass into unknown conditions, to watch where you're going, or to supervise one's kids? Following it to its logical conclusion, I guess I'm supposed to put up a construction fence every time I dig a hole? Or stack a pile of wood? But an orange plastic fence can be jumped over or cut, so I guess I need a high chain link fence? But then how do I make the fence posts safe so someone doesn't hurt themselves by running into those? And what about the hazard of digging the holes for the fence posts? Etc etc etc. This whole topic is essentially a backwards precedent that reeks of the common US anti-pattern of unfunded policy mandates merely pitting individuals against one another and considering the matter solved. If we want fewer people to drown, then make unfenced swimming pools (or perhaps even ponds) straight up illegal, with stiff penalties (I believe they're just generally town ordinance violations with a few hundred dollar fine right now). If we want to take care of people who get injured in such ways, then create a general fund for that. Tying the two together is like some moralizing version of "thoughts and prayers" that really just sets up a perverse reverse lottery where everything is fine until you get unlucky. (see also: all the harm that law enforcement causes and then just walks away from) (Also FWIW I don't think there's anything "collectively decided" about the current legal landscape. From what I understand these liabilities basically arise from courts having created these theories of liabilities, and the unknown unknown risk comes from not knowing what theories the courts might create next (ex post facto!). If these liabilities had been created by statutory law through the nominal democratic process they could at least be enumerated and thus definitely addressed. But alas)
- crazygringo 2y ago> But apparently there's no duty of care towards oneself to not trespass into unknown conditions, to watch where you're going, or to supervise one's kids? No, there absolutely is. The key word is "reasonable", which I used intentionally and multiple times in my comment. Every time you dig a deep hole that might be hard to see, yes you're supposed to put up some kind of cones or warning tape or something. You're rightly not allowed to turn your yard into a booby trap, even if it's part of a construction process. (Of course you don't need to put something up while you're working and supervising -- but you sure do overnight while you're away from it.) We're supposed to watch where we're going, but we also expect to be able to walk across a yard without breaking our ankle because of a hard-to-see hole. Just like there's a big difference between a hole filled with water where a child could drown (that requires an actual physical barrier), versus a hole where they might fall in but break an ankle at best (cones are fine). And I don't know why you think a pile of wood is unsafe, that's fine. Why would you need a fence? Unless it's stacked so high you can easily push it over to topple it, but you shouldn't be doing that in the first place. You're trying to push examples to unreasonable extremes, when the whole point is the concept of reasonable safety. (FWIW, I happen to agree with you in thinking that tort law is not always the best way to implement this, that there should often be legal enforcement regardless of whether someone suffers an injury, and that injuries should often be compensated out of a general fund. It's tricky though because this would require a level of constant, regular government safety inspections of private property that not everyone is OK with. However, I think the general standard of reasonable safety is nevertheless absolutely correct.)