3 ms·
Basically just think of it as a continuum from things you're obviously responsible for (a child drowns in your pool because you didn't put up a fence), to thing
by crazygringo 2y ago
Basically just think of it as a continuum from things you're obviously responsible for (a child drowns in your pool because you didn't put up a fence), to things you're obviously not (somebody fell and broke a bone because they tripped over a tree root in your acres of backyard forest).
That there's a big gray area in the middle, and that somebody can sue you if they're injured in that gray area, and even if they lose it's still expense and stress and a time suck for you.
- lambdaxyzw 2y ago>obviously responsible for (a child drowns in your pool because you didn't put up a fence) Does this also count if you didn't invite the child and the terrain was clearly marked as your property? If yes, this is pretty surprising and non-obvious to me. Do i misunderstand something? For me, the obvious example is bobby trapping your property and hurting a fireman who came to put out a fire.
- cratermoon 2y agoIn most of the US, the attractive nuisance doctrine applies, unfortunately. And nearly anything can be considered an attractive nuisance, or at least there's probably a lawyer out there willing to take the case and cost the landowner money.
- b112 2y agoQuite so. I get doubly annoyed when people have heated pools by lakes, the lake is clearly not fenced, but that fence had better be on your pool. And many pools have a shallow end, and many homeowners have long docks, which are in deep water. Yet docks aren't required to be fenced here.
- crazygringo 2y agoYes, it absolutely does count. You might indeed consider it non-obvious and surprising -- I certainly did when I first learned of it growing up here. Another classic example is that a thief can sue you if they fall through rotting floorboards on your porch and break their legs. But we've collectively decided, as a society, that property owners are not just prohibited from booby trapping their properties, but are required to actively maintain them in a safe condition according to reasonable standards. If there's something a reasonable person would know was a safety risk on their property, they'll be held liable if they didn't fix it and somebody injured themselves because of it. The thinking is basically -- kids will run around onto other people's property, people get lost, etc. We know kids go where they're not supposed to. Nobody should be risking injury or death just because of that, if and when reasonable safety precautions by the property owner could have prevented that. In other words, we live in a society, and we have a certain minimal level of active duty of care towards others. Owning a piece of property comes with rights but also responsibilities.
- stragies 2y agoDon't at least the parents of the kid that drowned in your pool while trespassing on your land get at least a charge of "criminal negligence" against them? IANAL, but aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult? And 14+ years old that drowns in a pool for inability to swim is also something that should be blamable on the parents, not the pool owner. Edit with clarifications after comments: I meant, parent's should be supervising their young kids, or take the risk/blame, if something happens to the kids while they aren't. (I roamed 'unsupervised' in fields and forest at young age with friends, and enjoyed it. But I was also taught to look where I step, and how to swim)
- tylermw 2y ago> but aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult No. The age which supervision is required varies by jurisdiction. > And 14+ years old that drowns in a pool for inability to swim is also something that should be blamable on the parents, not the pool owner. There's no law stating you need to teach your kids to swim.
- gampleman 2y ago> IANAL, but aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult? Not in most jurisdictions (thanks God). That's a terrible idea for raising kids.
- chrisBob 2y agoBeing a parent is hard. I would say that half of the US thinks parents are the problem with kids these days and that a good kid should "spend time outside in the neighborhood like we used to", and then the other half will call the police if your child is out of sight because "aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult?"
- vundercind 2y ago> aren't kid's <14 supposed to be supervised at all times by an adult Hell no. A world where a nine or ten year old can’t go roam the neighborhood on bikes with some friends unless adults accompany them would be a dystopia. I know there are occasionally news stories about very-stupid harassment of parents for parenting correctly, but thank god it’s still not the norm.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoI would say that a child falling in your pool is something you're obviously not responsible for. The fact that case law in the US says otherwise is a shameful commentary on how broken the US legal system is.
- nness 2y agoIf you are required by law to put a fence around your pool and include a child-safe door, and you fail to do so, and a child drowns — why shouldn't you be liable? (Although I think many from the US may interpret a "fence around a pool" to be an overreach of government regulation. But in Australia, "barrier laws" exist in every state/territory to avoid accidental drownings.)
- madeofpalk 2y agoAustralia solved this differently - it's illegal to have an unfenced pool precisely because young children wander and fall into pools and drown. We understand that kids shouldn't die. If your fence is neglected or the kid was otherwise somehow able to get in, you're liable. Have a fence up to code, and you're not liable.
- arethuza 2y agoDid a lot of kids die in pools before that law was introduced? NB I'm in Scotland so outside pools aren't a big risk but I also grew up in a small fishing village on a very wild and rocky coast with high cliffs and the idea of anyone trying to "protect" kids in that kind of environment seems very odd to me.
- madeofpalk 2y agoThere's considerably less unsupervised kids running around rocky coasts with high cliffs than around neighbourhoods and backyards. Note that Australia also has plenty of coasts and does not mandate a fence around them all.
- crazygringo 2y agoOf course. These laws don't just come out of nowhere. Kids drowning in pools is a real thing.
- RRWagner 2y ago"can sue you" is a very very important detail here. As I understand it, in the UK, the losing party in a suit pays legal expenses on both sides, which discourages "let's just shake them down" lawsuits. in the U.S. it's way too easy to get a contingency lawyer who knows anyone can sue someone else for anything and they'll have to settle for $$ just because it's cheaper than going to court to "win" against a weak complaint. I did some financial modeling on this years ago that gave a good prediction of when cases will settle in the U.S. tl;dr when the money given to the defense lawyer approaches the probable expectation of the loss you're trying to avoid.
- bluGill 2y agoThe downside of loser pays is coorts will sometimes find against you in an obvious case and so only the rich can dare risk court.
- arethuza 2y agoThe other major downside of loser pays is that it makes litigation very difficult to stop once it starts - and lawyers, funnily enough, will always say that you have an excellent case encouraging people to start litigation....
- SoftTalker 2y agoA good lawyer will not take a case that you are very likely to lose, and he will advise you that you have no case. I believe a judge can also admonish or censure a lawyer who brings a frivilous claim into court? Not sure how often that happens.
- anticensor 2y agoIn most implementations of loser pays, both parties pay upfront and then the winner gets refunded the fees.
- bluGill 2y agolast case I heard numbers on the lawers fees were $500000. This for a case where it was clear they would lose (3 different parties were sued and the nobody could figure out how to split the $100000 loss- that is one party spent 5x the total judgement)