6 ms·
Sam Altman's Inconsistent Candor Is Showing
- SuperHeavy256 2y agoWhat about your inconsistent candor Gizmodo? This site hasn't always been truthful, trust me. I've been reading Gizmodo for years.
- realce 2y agoSo this article isn't truthful then, or you'd just like us to have a vague distrust of Gizmodo and the article is true?
- atoav 2y agoWhat about whataboutism? Isn't what you did here a perfect example of how – if we were to take it seriously – any discussion could be "stopped" merely by whatabouting about the messenger? I think Sam Altman can defend himself.
- mateus1 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism Edit: Atoav’s comment is more accurate.
- lupusreal 2y agoDoes Gizmodos sketchy past discredit the evident discrepancy between Sam's words and deeds? Or do you mean that one excuses the other? I really don't see your point.
- xyzwave 2y agoThis is an example of the “tu quoque” fallacy [0], and has no bearing on the claim they’re making about Sam. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- freedomben 2y agoIf it's true that they used a different actress for The voice, then this should be very easy to put to rest. Just let us hear from the voice actress.
- realce 2y agoIt's already easy to put to rest - They asked her twice - They tweeted many references to Her - She declined - Everyone on Earth heard the voice and thought it was Her - OAI doesn't give a fuck even tho they could have just picked any other voice that could possibly exist, because they should be able to do anything they please without consideration of humans I thought the amount of "Weirdo defending Musk on Twitter' energy for Elon was amazing, but the amount of reality-denial that the OAI defenders have is quite a different beast. They wanted SJ's identity, she declined, they effectively cloned her against her will instead. That's about as sick as you can get. Future really looks bright!
- giraffe_lady 2y agoI really like the way rusty foster described this in today in tabs, it shows the correct amount of contempt for the exercise itself and derision for how stupid they're expecting people to be to believe it. > The Torment Nexus announces it has retained counsel in OpenAI dispute. > On Sunday OpenAI announced it was removing its new horny robot girlfriend voice, explaining in a blog post that the voice was “not an imitation of Scarlett Johansson” at all (and frankly it’s weird of you even to think that???) but was actually the real human meat voice of a completely different actress who goes to another school, you wouldn’t know her. Also she’s from Canada. > Recapping the imbroglio, Casey Newton wrote that Sam Altman is full of shit [measured, respectful] and Ed Zitron wrote that Sam Altman is full of shit [angry diatribe]. But with the final departure of co-founder and actual technologist Ilya Sutskever, whose last-ditch effort to oust Altman failed last fall, OpenAI is now firmly under the control of Paul Graham / Marc Andreessen style technofascist incompetents, and this kind of clown show will increasingly be the norm. There's about a dozen links in there I don't feel like copying but it's easy to find.
- freedomben 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bell-cot 2y agoIs anyone reading HN naive enough to believe that major tech executives even attempt consistent candor?
- mateus1 2y agoThe article is not implying he was ever truly honest. It just saying we have more evidence of his “inconsistent candor” mentioned in his firing letter.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoRight. "Inconsistent candor" is a euphemism for "liar, liar, pants on fire!" that won't get one sued for libel or slander.
- realce 2y agoAt fault: The reader's naivete Excusable: Billionaire with unfathomable power It's all user error I suppose?
- bell-cot 2y agoThere ain't no naivete, here on HN, for "fault" to be applicable. If you think ill-behaved billionaires are excusable, then we disagree. Though we seem to be stuck in a dystopian world run by them - so I guess you "win", in a sense.
- happytoexplain 2y agoThis trope is very near the top of my list of things that I wish we could get rid of in conversation. It's a kind of reversal that I suppose is born of frustration rather than being a genuine holistic opinion, but using words like "naive" creates the impression that you would rather criticize people for wanting better behavior from executives than criticize executives for misbehaving. That's a pretty hideous position, and I don't think it's the position you're actually trying to take.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated: Sam Altman is showing us who he really is https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40434800 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40434800
- ryandvm 2y agoSo... just to summarize the state of things: The guy running the leading AI company was previously fired by the board because they didn't think he was showing proper restraint with regard to A LOT of areas. That decision was quickly overturned. And now we have OpenAI showing that they have no qualms about deep-faking a voice actor if they don't get the proper rights. And we're supposed to believe that OpenAI has the proper protections in place to safely bring into fruition the AI of tomorrow?
- Mountain_Skies 2y agoThe Board of Directors firing him would have had a better chance of sticking if they had been open and clear from the beginning instead of playing some weird Cloak and Dagger game that made them look suspicious. It's quite possible that both Sam and the Board are in over their heads.
- freedomben 2y agoYep agreed, the secrecy is making this all a whole lot worse. I'm looking for to the point when we find out what really happened, assuming that comes out in my life time.
- gmerc 2y agoWhen you handle a sociopath who was already trying to dismantle the board, no, you don’t deal with him in the open by broadcasting your every move. You also try to handle it internally. We will wish in the future they had succeeded. He’s on the Elon fast track.
- scintill76 2y agoIn what ways is/will he be like Elon?
- freedomben 2y ago> And now we have OpenAI showing that they have no qualms about deep-faking a voice actor if they don't get the proper rights. No, that isn't established. They are claiming they used a different actress, so no deep-faking involved. If the actress turns out to not be real, then yes Sam A is guilty of lying and some pretty gross behavior. If it turns out to be true though, what they did is a bit scummy, but not dishonest ~and not illegal~, unless you believe that people who sound similar to Scarlett Johansson don't have the same rights to their voice as Johansson does to hers. Edit: It may actually be illegal given the intent. There is court precedent on this
- Mountain_Skies 2y agoWhile I somewhat doubt it was done by design, this is getting far more attention than the GPT-4o announcement did and in the end will likely benefit OpenAI even if they have to make some kind of settlement for misuse of Scarlett Johansson's voice. Wouldn't surprise me though if they knew there would be attention getting blowback and went this way after seeing the GPT-4o announcement mostly get "that's kind of neat" and shrugs.
- RoyalHenOil 2y agoAttention isn't necessarily always a good thing. Negative attention can cause people to decide to actively avoid that company and switch to a competitor. Just ask Firestone.
- gmerc 2y ago“Inconsistent Candor” Just calls him a manipulative sociopath already.
- drcongo 2y agoIs "Inconsistent Candor" an American euphemism for sleazy bullshit?