5 ms·
Autonomous AI Robot Creates a Shock-Absorbing Shape No Human Ever Could
- dzogchen 2y agoBetter title: Researchers Build AI Robot to Assist with Creating a new Shock-Absorbing Shape
- tleilaxu 2y agoIndeed. Humans still created the shape, they just used a tool of their choosing to do so…
- RUnconcerned 2y ago"and then crushes it with a pressure equivalent to an adult Arabian horse standing on a quarter", what a bizarre comparison, this seems like an incomprehensible reference point for most people (myself included)
- guax 2y agoI have no clue what It means and I am an Arabian horse.
- entropygiggles 2y agoGo stand on a quarter, and it's about like that.
- tom_ 2y agoYou just need to find out how much an Arabian horse weighs, and divide the area of the thing they're standing on by 4, and the calculations are pretty straightforward.
- incompatible 2y agoI'll look it up. The horse weighs 360 to 450 kg, the quarter in this context is an American coin with diameter 24.26 mm .. I think it's pretty clear now.
- mf2hd 2y agoDepends on the heart girth apparently: https://thehorse.com/tools/adult-horse-weight-calculator/ https://thehorse.com/tools/adult-horse-weight-calculator/
- voidUpdate 2y agoSomewhere between 7.6 and 9.5 MPa (1100-1400 freedom pressures) if I've done my maths right
- suoduandao3 2y agoMaybe it's a function of my work, but that sounds like a lot of Pa.
- taneq 2y agoCross checking with units : A coin of diameter 25.4mm=0.0254m has an area of pi(0.0254m/2)^2=0.00016129m^2, and 9.81N/kg450kg/4=1103N, so that gives 1103N/(0.00016m^2)=6.819MPa. Sounds right, pascals are quite small. :)
- mirekrusin 2y agoThey could just say “average US person”.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoAmericans will measure with anything but the metric system.... (reference: https://old.reddit.com/r/Metric/comments/cpbi2g/americans_will_measure_with_anything_but_the/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Metric/comments/cpbi2g/americans_wi... )
- henriquecm8 2y ago"a large boulder the size of a small boulder"
- xattt 2y ago> The mystical two-headed dog… born with only one head!
- knodi123 2y agoas the meme goes, "Americans will do anything to avoid the metric system!"
- PopAlongKid 2y ago>“Slowly but surely we kept inching up, and broke through.” What is the metric equivalent of this statement? (from TFA)
- throwup238 2y agoBetter imagery?
- CodeMage 2y agoIn this context, "inch" is a verb, not a noun. It represents slow movement, not a precise measurement. There are many words like that in English. To answer your question, "moving" would have been a perfectly acceptable substitute. You could also use "crawling", "creeping", "worming", or "wriggling".
- PopAlongKid 2y agoBut that doesn't answer my question, as it appears there is no metric equivalent. I'm just highlighting how ridiculous the GP comment is, to conclude that using an analogy of a horse and a 25-cent coin has anything to do with metric measurement.
- entropygiggles 2y agoClearly it would be "we kept 2.54-centimetering up".
- knodi123 2y ago> I'm just highlighting how ridiculous the GP comment is, The one that I specifically described as a meme comment? You're saying it's technically inaccurate? Thanks, criticism noted.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoUsing Einstein’s mass energy equivalence, that’s about 10 to the power of 16 BTUs standing on that quarter. If we had a machine to convert that horse into energy we could power Britain for about 20 years. (Britain uses a few quadrillion BTUs annually).
- fnordpiglet 2y agoThis is a human watermark to ensure readers an LLM didn’t author the article. There’s no reasonable prompt that could create this comparison without hallucinating the rest of the article.
- ahazred8ta 2y agoThe venerable 'Half A Giraffe' subreddit covers the frequent use of nonstandard journalistic measurement units -- https://old.reddit.com/r/HalfAGiraffe/ https://old.reddit.com/r/HalfAGiraffe/
- wahoo324 2y agoso it's not really AI, right?
- gbin 2y agoIf you squint hard enough any trial and error converging along a function is AI.
- Shorel 2y agoFor a long time, evolutionary and genetic algorithms were part of AI. It is not a language model, and it doesn't run on a GPU, but it is definitely a mechanical implementation of searching a solution in a space.
- jerrygenser 2y agoAI used to be autonomously controlled systems. Now AI is re-brand of machine learning by marketing departments, etc. This seems more like AI than the very recent rebrand of ML. Machine learning can be a sub-system of AI systems but in itself was not thought of as AI for a long time.
- suoduandao3 2y agoisn't it? I think it might be. It's definitely artificial so it depends on your definition of intelligence. And that's a rather confused subject. I favor a model of intelligence where one measures problem-solving capability along multiple axes and defines an N-dimensional shape that describes a hypervolume of 'general' intelligence. One could certainly argue that because this program solves problems that can only meaningfully be measured along one axis that it has too few dimensions to be called intelligence. The trouble with that is software generally works best when specialized for problems with a single axis, so by that definition 'general intelligence' is either unlikely to happen in that space at all or won't be energy efficient if it does. What would likely have a higher intelligence is a 'cyborg' - which could just be a human accessing this program via conventional means - who adds this program's problem solving capability along one axis to their existing hypervolume of intelligence. So maybe not artificial intelligence, but definitely an artificial intelligence expander.
- entropygiggles 2y ago
- bartlettD 2y agoLink to the actual paper for those interested. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-48534-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-48534-4 (Open-Access) I had wondered why they weren't doing this in simulation but didn't realise that Finite Element Analysis gets weird in the regions they're exploring. Reminds me a lot of the "Chemputer" concept for automated chemical synthesis expriments. https://www.chem.gla.ac.uk/cronin/ https://www.chem.gla.ac.uk/cronin/
- SoullessSilent 2y agoObligatory xkcd reference. https://xkcd.com/526/ https://xkcd.com/526/
- iLoveOncall 2y ago> The robot creates a small plastic structure with a 3D printer, records its shape and size, moves it to a flat metal surface—and then crushes it with a pressure equivalent to an adult Arabian horse standing on a quarter. The robot then measures how much energy the structure absorbed, how its shape changed after being squashed, and records every detail in a vast database. So, something that humans absolutely could do.
- voidUpdate 2y agoYes, but the robot is presumably also ranking them and doing some clever "ai" thing to actually generate the model, like a genetic algorithm or something. It's also working 24/7, and I think if you make humans work 24/7 they get angry and ask to go to the bathroom and such
- iLoveOncall 2y agoYes, but the article doesn't say "done much more efficiently than by humans", it says "impossible for humans to do".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- voidUpdate 2y agoI mean you're welcome to manually do all the calculations for the gradient descent stuff, redo the mesh yourself and carve it out of a block of plastic with a chisel, I'll stick to getting a computer to do it for me
- ModernMech 2y agoWhy did you say "I'll stick to getting a computer to do it for me" as opposed to "I will use a computer to do it"?
- iLoveOncall 2y ago
- nuz 2y agoI'm curious what the difference between this and an "automated scientist" like sama/openai says they want to build would be. This is what I imagine when they mention that goal.
- ModernMech 2y agoI don’t get these headlines, it’s like saying a hammer sinks a nail into a board that no human ever could. People invent tools to increase our abilities. That doesn’t mean when a human uses a tool, the tool does the work. A human made this thing. The AI was part of the process but a human did it.
- robertlagrant 2y agoAI gets attention clicks, I think.
- sgift 2y agoYeah. Just the last iteration in a long list of hype terms. Big data. Cloud ready. AI. Whatever ...
- ben_w 2y ago"Look at what our new tool can do" is the news. In a very literal sense, tools are "doing the work" to precisely the degree to which it's not food calories that empower them.
- robertlagrant 2y ago> MAMA BEAR—short for its lengthy full title, Mechanics of Additively Manufactured Architectures Bayesian Experimental Autonomous Researcher Good job.
- potench 2y agoI’m interested in the structure it created - is that it in the hero image? The article needs to highlight it more! There should be at least a paragraph with a figure of this 75% structure petal looking thing that an Arabian horse could crush.