9 ms·
What the front page of the internet looks like today: * Image with overlayed snarky text * Another image * Another image... * The Daily Show clip * A
by peterwwillis 14y ago
What the front page of the internet looks like today:
* Image with overlayed snarky text
* Another image
* Another image...
* The Daily Show clip
* Another image
* Another image
* News article about Julian Assange
* Another image
* News article about guy doing something strange (which is actually really old)
* Reddit question thread about Tarantino films
* Youtube clip
* "Ask Me Anything" request thread
* Story on mobile technology
* Reddit question thread about 'fan theories'
* Article about astronomy
* Youtube clip
* Reddit 'arbitrary gift day' thread
* Another image
* Another image
* Another image
* Another image
* Story about finding genetic defects
* News article about political race
* Another image
* Another image
Personally, I think there's something wrong with you if you don't find that list at least a little depressing.
- tylermenezes 14y agoYou can log in and customize it. The default set of subreddits is bound to be low-quality.
- peterwwillis 14y agoThe idea that the default is supposed to be low-quality is depressing.
- sneak 14y agoWell, at least know its name if you're going to be depressed by it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeons_Law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeons_Law
- wonderyak 14y agoThere is a reason that empty content (Reality TV anyone?) is very popular. People seem to really like it. There are a great many subreddits with fantastic discussions and information; most people don't seem to want to be bothered to learn anything though.
- dalore 14y agoThe idea is that you can make it "your" front page of the internet with just the topics that interest you. If you go by the default it's got the most mass market appeal because of popularity but if you're someone who reads hackers news that is not what you want. So customize it. The internet has become popular and just like pop music it will appeal to the lowest common denominator.
- beambot 14y agoReddit isn't required to make "your" front page. Personally... I just go into my browser settings and change it to whatever website I want. More seriously, iGoogle is pretty good after being customized. I personally have email, calendar, and reader placed prominently (among others). I'd really like a hackernews synopsis too, perhaps something like hckrnews: http://hckrnews.com/ http://hckrnews.com/
- planetguy 14y agoIf you go by the default it's got the most mass market appeal Well, not really "mass market" appeal, just appeal to the incredibly narrow and apparently homogeneous subslice of the world's population that fits into the reddit demographic. If you're not aged 15-25, college-educated (or college-bound), left-wing, atheist, obsessively interested in every one of the typical geeky pursuits, and already intimately familiar with every one of several hundred reddit memes and running jokes, you're gonna have a bad time. I'm not sure how many people there are among the world's seven billion people who fit into all those categories, but they all already have reddit accounts.
- TillE 14y agoDon't forget overwhelmingly male. Also, I've noticed anecdotally that the average age on Reddit seems to have dropped over the past couple years. It used to be early 20s, but now I'm seeing tons of comments from high school kids and younger whenever I dare step out of the few subreddits I still bother to read. I won't even get into Reddit's more serious developing issues like the explosion of casual racism.
- runevault 14y agoI wouldn't so much say the default is supposed to be low quality so much as the less interesting/technically savvy people don't change the defaults so those are the reddits they read/post to, leading to clutter.
- baddox 14y agoThe idea that any single default can possibly be considered high quality for tens of millions of users is unrealistic. That's like going to a grocery store, asking for a "default shopping cart," and hoping its contents will be suitable for you.
- planetguy 14y agoThe default shopping cart is probably much closer to my taste than default reading material would be. Although, now I come to think of it, for years we did have default reading material, it was called a mass-market newspaper, and it wasn't all that bad. Newspapers are very readable and fairly sensible, content-wise, compared to something like reddit, because they're carefully designed by a small group of people to appeal to a broad cross-section, whereas the dynamics of social news sites tend to push shiny junk to the top. A newspaper is like a default shopping cart which contains meat, vegetables, eggs, milk, bread, and rice. Not all of it is to everyone's taste, but if it arrived at my door every week I wouldn't die of malnutrition. Reddit is like a default shopping cart constructed by polling a thousand teenagers on their favourite foods; it contains twinkies, cognac, Junior Mints, bacon, Twizzlers and beer.
- baddox 14y ago> it was called a mass-market newspaper, and it wasn't all that bad. I actually doubt that. Sure, there were social advantages to having a smaller body of reading material that most literate people had read. But the Internet allows us to do two different but important things: truly democratize editorship (like reddit), and enable niche editors to easily distribute their content (like slashdot, slashfilm, or techcrunch).
- planetguy 14y agoDoesn't stop the fact that I'd get more satisfaction out of reading the New York Times (or even the New York Post) than browsing the front page of reddit. Oh look, a picture of a velociraptor with a caption. And someone's cat. A terribly-drawn cartoon about why console gaming is better than PC gaming. Someone else's cat. Another cat. I'VE SEEN CATS BEFORE, PEOPLE!
- lmkg 14y agoCausation is the other way around. The default(s) will become lower quality, as a direct result of the additional, unfiltered attention. They will get firehosed with a larger audience, and the number of participants will grow in a way not compatible with maintaining a consistent community or personality. Additionally, the switch in community growth from a "pull" model (I'm interested enough in X to actively search for communities about X on the internet) to a "push" model (X was pushed in my face, and I care enough to respond) will tend to dilute the focus and quality of the community.
- rpicard 14y agoI was getting fed-up with Reddit but my front page (and Reddit experience in general) improved vastly after taking some suggestions from a user a few weeks ago [1]. It's actually a good source for interesting news now. [1] http://reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/tezal/this_is_the_reddit_front_page_from_exactly_half_a/c4m261f http://reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/tezal/this_is_the_red...
- kn0thing 14y agoI cannot upvote this enough. Thanks. edit, with bonus explanation! We need to do a better job helping new(and old) redditors realize the thousands of communities they could be joining for a diverse blend of content that interests them. When Steve and I started reddit, we had no categories because it was simple -- and Steve loves simple. Now that we've got scores of vibrant communities discussing links about things ranging from cute animal photos (/r/aww) to philosophy (/r/philosophy) and many things in between, it's up to us to build a more intuitive UX that guides users to them and helps them assemble a personalized front page.
- cdh 14y agoIt's funny, because your "Announce your vote to the world" comment (ostensibly) wouldn't be welcome on Reddit: http://code.reddit.com/wiki/help/reddiquette http://code.reddit.com/wiki/help/reddiquette (No offense intended, I just thought it was hilarious in the context of this conversation. Maybe you meant it as a joke...)
- kn0thing 14y agoTongue firmly in cheek :) btw, I'd love to see a HN etiquette guide. edit: touche! thanks, agscala http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- agscala 14y agohttp://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- michael_fine 14y agoNor would it be welcome on HN. It's courtesy not to post about your votes, rather letting them speak for themselves.
- kn0thing 14y agoI've since added a bonus explanation for just why I concurred with the parent.
- roshangry 14y agoThis.
- fribblerz 14y agoUse RES and filter all these subs: fffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu, pics, gaming, funny, gifs, wtf, AdviceAnimals, trees, aww, atheism, skyrim, starcraft, Minecraft, pokemon, doctorwho, circlejerk, nba, lolcats, gameofthrones, reactiongifs, humor, community, gonewild, shittyaskscience, TheLastAirbender, cats, dogs, StarWars, PrettyGirls, diablo3, mylittlepony, leagueoflegends, dota2, Boobies, Diablo, 4chan, gentlemanboners, realgirls . You'd be surprised by the change.
- jcurbo 14y agoThe real strength of Reddit is joining the subreddits that pertain to your interests, but I agree that maybe cleaning up the 'default' subreddits is a good idea. There are plenty of people that just lurk with no account or never change the defaults.
- pnathan 14y agoagreed - while I occasionally enjoy /r/funny, I default to technical subreddits, and it's a very high-quality newsfeed.
- silentscope 14y agoAn old reporter adage: news is something someone doesn't want to hear. In that regard, I don't think reddit is really news in a hardcore sense. It has cool shit, fun articles, hilarious threads, party facts for days. But news? News, and obviously this is a big generalization, is inherently uncomfortable to read. Reddit is a feature factory, not a newsfeed. You can learn a lot from it, but I'll politely disagree about the usage of news--not that your opinion is wrong, mine's just different.
- jcurbo 14y agoThe subreddits I read have plenty of news, about fields I am interested in - both serious technical fields and leisure related activities. Sure, r/pics is full of memes and funny stuff, but I get real information and commentary from the subreddits I follow. I certainly consider it news, even in the sense you present.
- dreadsword 14y agoSay what you will about the state of Reddit today, Alexis, Steve, and Paul Graham had some inspired insights: "We knew our business was in our user base, that that was the most important part."
- dageshi 14y agoI find it depressing when holier than thou hipsters pop up to whine about how depressing popular things are... which seems to occur with increasing frequency on HN nowadays.
- jcitme 14y agoYou know what? YOU are the problem. The reddit type who feeds off drivel. A website might be popular because it is good, but do not ever conflate that something is good because it is popular. HN still has not fallen into the pit of content for content's sake. The people here complain not because they are hipsters, but because we do not want to be fed drivel, meaningless content that rots the mind rather than feeds it. I want to put it as harshly as possible, so I have one thing to say: Fuck off. We do not need content that lacks content here.
- muhfuhkuh 14y agoWow, you are so "The WELL" circa 1997. Communities grow (and thrive, even) as the swell of users come and, ultimately, go. Besides, there are more than enough subreddits to subscribe to that are almost completely devoid of any "drivel" you refer to (r/science and r/TrueReddit being just two; and I contend that r/programming and r/coding are even more useful to hackers than HN).
- dageshi 14y agoOh sure, a bit like the endless "PHP is terrible", "No PHP is great" cycle of link bait that pops up every two months. Or "All developers are sexist", "No programmers aren't sexist!" which slips into the gap when we're not talking about php. And last week there was the fan favourite about "Everyone should be a programmer!", "No everyone shouldn't be a programmer!". There's the endless cycle of "No I won't be your technical co-founder, here's why" which I have read on this site at least 10 times by different authors. Now, I am not knocking any of that, that is the nature of user submitted content, what I find irritating however is people who believe that just because they are talking about their particular speciality (programming, marketing, startup, e.t.c) on this site it gives them the right to look down their nose at people who enjoy reddit.
- imgabe 14y agoInstall RES and filter out links to imgur. Reddit immediately becomes about 5x better. There is still a lot of good content, it's just swamped by people using pictures of popular things to get karma.
- mibbitier 14y agoNot to mention the massive bias. If it's anti-rich people, pro-gay, pro-drugs, anti-corporation, anti-government, anti-religion, anti-foxnews, socialist etc etc then it'll get upvoted endlessly. The worrying thing is that people who constantly moan about how misinformed and biased fox news viewers are, are on a website with a ridiculous bias, which also often carries untrue stories because they fit the agenda. There's a reason why news sites are still very very popular. We need editors. If you allow people to upvote what they want, you end up with complete rubbish and endless circlejerking. The front page is often (When you remove the funny pictures) lots of "We all obviously agree with this. Who agrees with me?!!"
- drivebyacct2 14y agoThere are regular posts and plenty of white knights that defend opposing views. The problem is that most people, as I find with many anti-gay, anti-drug, pro-government people in my day-to-day life, lack the ability to articulate a mature thought supporting their view. On the weird case that there is a good discussion, the opposing view is upvoted. There were several discussions yesterday stemming from gay marriage and there were several posts that basically said "I'm disgusted purely by the thought of homosexual acts, thus I'm opposed to gay rights" in a more eloquent tone and they were upvoted to foster the discussion. The frontpage yesterday had a very balanced discussion regarding how MJ does not affect MS in some of the ways that people had hoped. The comments were full of discussion back and forth and first hand accounts from MS sufferers.
- ceol 14y agoIt's only pro-gay when it's trying to be anti-religion/anti-government. Any other time, the site is hostile to the LGBT community (and women, and people of color, and ...).
- zf1234 14y agoI find it amusing that so much anti-Fox News stuff gets posted, because they are the secondary target market, and they're just doing exactly what Fox wants them to do. Fox trolls, Reddit gets offended, posts links. It's not like any of the Fox hosts believe what they're saying - They just say more and more absurd things until they get a reaction. It's on the same level as those "Alien woman gives birth to Werebaby" tabloids. The crazy people who watch it only feel legitimised if someone engages them in a serious argument about whether Werebabies even exist.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoThe worst part is, there's an easy correlation, not just between volume of users but age of users to the site, and the quality of content. The subreddits that have exploded in popularity recently, and the ones that were only more recently added to the homepage, have some of the lowest quality content ever. Even when compared to subreddits that have been around longer, or were formerly on the homepage.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- baddox 14y agoI think there's something wrong with you if you are emotionally invested enough in a website you don't even like to experience anything even close to sadness or depression.
- ctl 14y agoTo me it seemed like the front page got a lot worse when the mods got rid of the reddit.com subreddit. Did anybody else observe this?
- intended 14y agoreddit.com/r/subredditdrama reddit.com/r/theoryofreddit In depth discussions on the causes and effects of good and bad subreddit growth go on here. Most likely will find the same observation, with data or ideas as to why it happened.
- yaz 14y agoI discovered reddit 10 months ago and was amazed at the community. Then I quickly grew tired of the boring submissions and comments. Then I discovered reddit's secret - the lesser known subreddits. The front page of my internet looks pretty interesting to me. It has a Tolkien article, a documentary about rainforest birds, some black-hole-milky-way-gamma-ray article, a usability article (Video captioning techniques and best practices), and a ton of history and grammar discussions.
- duaneb 14y agoDepressing, maybe, but it's definitely accurate being "the front page of the internet"
- samstave 14y agoPersonally, I use RES and block a ton of /r/ and keywords and content. I think the best test is to put all these blocks in place, then add a block to imgur - then you get a lot of good content. Also, stay off the main page.
- graeme 14y agoThe subreddits are the real story. Took me a while to realize that, but now I'm hooked. I've learned so much the past few weeks from various communities. Reddit allows subreddits a lot of freedom in creating local cultures. There is so much potential. I may be over-excited about this because I just became the moderator of the subreddit in my niche. Previously I was building up a blog on my own, with some traffic, but little engagement or feedback. Now www.reddit.com/r/LSAT instantly has 125 readers, and tons of engagement and trust. I'm so excited to think about what I can build it into.
- borism 14y agoI thought you were talking about your Facebook feed. reddit is frontpage of the internet? for who?
- iskander 14y agoThe raw quantity of quality content on reddit is staggering. It just requires a little effort on your part to actually make an account and subscribe to good subreddits.
- fghh45sdfhr3 14y agoIt is only depressing if you don't know how to drop and add sub-reddits. Or maybe if you don't know math, and have no idea what the greatest common denominator is, or why people most often say lowest when they mean greatest. The front page of reddit is a humanity GCD which means it is pretty darn low or shallow if you will. Unsubscribe from it. I also recommend unsubscribing from pics, politics, wtf, and yes even funny. Then add sub-reddits you are interested in, askscience is a good one.
- dchest 14y agoYou're looking at r/all. For comparison, here's what my reddit front page looks like: * Ketamine Improves Bipolar Depression Within Minutes * -2000 Lines of Code * Fedora 17 Boot Optimization (from 15 to 2.5 seconds) * Awesome cut away showing the inner working of a Sauber * lcamtuf: Yes, you can have fun with downloads * Favorite CS related quotes from professors (or coworkers)? * Scrivener and Building a Better Book * ECMAScript 5.1 Specification Now Officially Available in HTML * Want to help make Linux Tycoon and Illumination Software Creator (and more) go GPL? Now's your chance. * org-mode and exporting to html * Calligra 2.4.2 Released * With your help, we're hoping to revive /r/promptoftheday - show your support! * New release of fortune_vimtips plugin. * Why GNU/Linux for Android is the most important Linux project today * Installing Postgresql for use with Rails 3.x using Homebrew on Mac OS X Lion * Best way to learn Scheme? * 10 Reasons You Should Skip the Traditional Publishers and Self-Publish Ebooks Instead * What's new in Fedora 17 * Simple example: Haskell vs. Go * centos 6.2 stuck on boot with gray bar at bottom of screen. * System Programming: CreateRemoteThread. Bypass Windows 7 Session Separation * [Access]Query does not update all rows * Astronomers have found the best evidence yet that gamma-ray jets recently streamed from the supermassive black hole at the heart of the Milky Way. * Can we talk about editors?
- randall 14y agoI want this. This is awesome. Reddit always seems gross from my perspective as an outsider. I want good quality stuff like that. I have to be logged in to get that?
- 14y ago
- SnydenBitchy 14y agoYou left out: * “Equal rights, equal lefts” * DAE think Black History Month is racist against whites? * Rage comic about “females” spurning nice-guy redditors * Image of fat black woman in a motorized scooter - LOLOLOLOL * “La-dash-a” LOLOLOLOL * DAE hate females for not letting us rape them? * etc. * etc. * etc.
- tuxidomasx 14y agoOver the past few years I've visited reddit comment threads less and less precisely because of the increase in racial insensitivity. The rise of vanity accounts doesnt help either, and shows that its not just tolerated by a pretty big percent of the community, but is readily accepted and seen as entertaining. I do find sanctuary in a few subreddits where its much rarer. But I cringe everytime i see a post title that makes an explicit mention to someones ethnicity because i know there will be misinformation given and jokes made that further validate particular kinds of racial bias.