3 ms·
The internet is overflowing with bad content. Users are fighting back
- lostemptations5 2y agoIsn't it more users are giving up? I'd love to find a way to inspire people to participate again like the old internet.
- southernplaces7 2y agoNumerically, more people than ever are indeed participating on the internet in all kinds of ways. Some of them crappy and shallow, but many much more creative. Many people who complain about this not being the case, particularly people on HN with a history of using the old internet, are actually complaining about not having the same limited, much more insularly participative internet they used to. Mainly, you just don't like that much of the far broader internet participation of today doesn't fit your preferences because it comes with all the usual foibles of wider humanity, so you either pretend parts of it don't exist in the first place, or apparently claim they're shallow, spammy garbage.
- b3ing 2y agoEventually the SEO spam will move to Reddit under fake profiles and fake questions to be answered by the same party under another profile. The information age gave us information overload, something I don't think anyone predicted. I wonder how things will be in 10yrs as people use more and more AI to generate low quality stuff and fluff. Will people tire of all this and seek out real human ideas and thoughts?
- h0l0cube 2y ago> something I don't think anyone predicted It was definitely predicted. Marshall McLuhan basically coined the term ‘information overload’ in the 60s. The sci-fi novel ‘Stand on Zanzibar’ also published in and 60s has chapters that are akin to a Twitter feed that give a sense of the wider world
- fzzzy 2y agoAlso the book Future Shock.
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoReddit no longer has communities, it has groupings of posts on a specific topic. Reddit is no longer filled with 30 something, educated, fairly well off professionals (or people who could well off but have chosen different priorities) accessing it from their computers as part of a creative cycle on their PCs. It is now filled with less well off, younger, and lesser educated/experienced people accessing it as a distraction from their phone. Except for kind of in the recent travertine/hominid fossil thread (which was nothing compared to historic domain expertise) you no longer have domain experts pop up on most every thread with interesting responses. Even the humorous responses are algorithmic at this point. Reddit is, in fact, dead. Long live Digg 4.0 reinvented as Reddit.
- Lammy 2y ago> The information age gave us information overload, something I don't think anyone predicted. Have you ever played Metal Gear Solid 2 (2001)? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eKl6WjfDqYA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eKl6WjfDqYA
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoThe old internet was interesting people sharing their interests that happened to all have computer knowledge/PCs/internet access at a specific point in time. The new internet is shallow boring people on their smart phones looking to be entertained or be provided with answers without having to RTFM or put in the work to master something, and definitely not looking to give back by posting something of value online themselves. Just look at the attitude on HN when it comes to z-library. Everyone here is entitled to take what whey want 'because of their circumstances'. An environment where everyone takes but don't give back, look out only for themselves, and strip the financial rewards for creation isn't going to lead to an environment like the old internet, or even like the old creative environment.
- b3ing 2y agoI think its just modern culture. * Many want to be landlords and leech off others, not providing any real value other than buying up a house and renting it out that someone else could of bought. * The ladder is being pulled up from older generations that benefited from low cost college (that was financed by higher state taxes - which no longer exists) and now dont want to pay taxes to fund the younger generation. * No one links to other sites, because we see everyone as competition. * We don't trust each other or even like each other for the most part in the US. * Hell even the pandemic proved that really one's freedom comes before the idea of even giving a damn if someone else got sick that might of had preexisting conditions. I'm not sure if its hyper-capitalism or hyper-individualism. Maybe its all related to knowing that our government isn't going to help you and is working on ways to make things harder unless you are one of the elites. That being said, many people on youtube create channels full of information, sure many end up promoting garbage and some are loaded with worthless filter or clickbait titles/images, but the amount of things you can learn today for free is quite amazing, topics that just weren't covered before.
- musicale 2y ago> the amount of things you can learn today for free is quite amazing It really is - including practical, creative, technical, and academic topics. My favorite thing about youtube is that you don't have to be a "youtuber" to upload videos. There is also no requirement for minimum audience size. The long tail of niche channels (at least the ones made by humans) seems a bit like the old web that people are nostalgic for, even if is within Google's ad-fueled kingdom. It's also an amazing repository of popular (and unpopular) music. My least favorite thing about youtube is how advertisements seem to have greatly increased over time.