6 ms·
25GBit/S on macOS and iOS
- sponaugle 2y agoThose Mellanox cards are great and surprisingly inexpensive. I just put 4 of the dual QSFP+ cards in servers in my homelab and now have 80gb/s from each server. The Mellanox and Arista QSFP+ switches are also super cheap, and you can get QSFP+ DAC cables to do 40G. In no way is 25G or 40G extreme. It is commodity low end in the real datacenter market.
- justinclift 2y agoHow noisy are the Mellanox and Arista switches you're using? Asking because I'm looking for something suitable for a homelab (using Mellanox 40GbE cards) that's in the same room I tend to occupy during the day. When I used very early Mellanox switches (years ago), they were only suitable only for datacenters. aka permanent super noisy jet engine mode Their 1U 10Gb/s Infiniband switch is still the noisiest piece of equipment I ever made the mistake of buying! (!!!)
- edward28 2y agoThe arista switch's have an option to limit their max fan speeds, so they go from data centre deafening to as loud as a 1u server.
- justinclift 2y ago> as loud as a 1u server. Depending on the 1u server, that's still super noisy. :(
- edward28 2y agoExactly lol.
- sponaugle 2y agoYea, it is impressive when they first turn on. You really start to think there is an aircraft overhead!
- sponaugle 2y agoIndeed - They are loud. ;) You can slow the fan speed down some and that makes a difference, but they still produce a lot of fan noise: If you listen in this video of my homelab: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-b3t37SIyBs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-b3t37SIyBs I would say that more than half of the total 'volume' is attributed to the three Arista switches. They are quite a bit louder than the Ciscos, and of course much louder than the Ubiquiti. I certainly would not have one of these next to me in a work area. On the other hand, they are the cheapest way to get 40G! With DAC cables it can be really inexpensive.
- justinclift 2y agoThanks, that rules out the Arista option then. :) I'm currently looking into the HP 5900AF-48XG-4QSFP+ (JC772A) switches, as they seem to be a good price/performance mix on Ebay. :) My homelab is currently just a small setup with 4 boxes using 40GbE and a few others with 10GbE. Only one of them really needs the 40GbE though, the other's could be made 10GbE and not care. ;) Random example of this switch: https://www.networktigers.com/products/jc772a-hpe-5900af-48xg-4qsfp-switch https://www.networktigers.com/products/jc772a-hpe-5900af-48x... Can't seem to find any info about noise levels though. :(
- justinclift 2y agoFound a data sheet with the acoustic info (https://s4u.com.ua/assets/files/hp%205900.pdf https://s4u.com.ua/assets/files/hp%205900.pdf). 65.7-70.6 dB. That's clearly not going to be workable. Damn.
- gorkish 2y agoThis comment is an offtopic rant about the bane of 2.5gbit nics. A discussion about how awesome and cheap 25gbit nics are (on iOS devices no less!) seems as good a place as any to bring it up. 2.5gbit nics are a boondoggle. They must contain the same 10gbit capable transceivers as any other n-base-t transceiver (because that's how they work) yet they are sold with the 5gbit and 10gbit rates disabled. Ostensably this is to limit power draw (and heat) but in most applications they are used those things aren't actually much of an issue. What will it take to get non-nerfed 10gbit nics as standard offerings on consumer hardware? 2.5Gbit is simply not fast enough to move data in and out of modern systems with modern storage. It's a twisted joke that network connectivity is so shit on systems that otherwise bend over backwards to advertise how many thunderbolt and 10gbit usb ports they have.
- crest 2y agoThe advantage to 2.5Gb/s is that you can run it over reasonable lengths of existing crappy cable jobs about as well as 1Gb/s Ethernet without angry customers yelling blaming you because it doesn't work. sigh
- justsomehnguy 2y ago> to limit power draw (and heat) Yes. Did you ever been in an actual DC and handled 10G-T cables and ports? They are hot, even in the DC with HVAC running below 20°C. And there is only one type of the systems which can easily accept that amount amount of heat - the desktop *ATX systems, for which you can just go and buy a 10G PCI-E card. For everything else the amount of heat is too much.
- justinclift 2y agoDACs don't seem to have that problem.
- justsomehnguy 2y agoDAC definitely has that problem too. One cable in an ideal condition probably wouldn't be that hot, but as soon as something is not ideal it would get hot. Also you are just throwing everything here now, DAC is totally not "we can have 10G for free". As others has said, the main benefit of 1G/2.5G is what it uses the same twisted pair => 8p8c connector. 10G DAC is SFP+. This alone prevents the mass adoption in the consumer sector - too much friction for Regular Joe.
- elintknower 2y agoI just want to plug an nVidia GPU into my macbook pro.
- jmrm 2y agoGood luck with drivers!
- jamesfmilne 2y agoI had always wanted to port Mellanox drivers to macOS to get away from paying through the nose for ATTO cards. Great news that Apple have already done it! Mellanox ConnectX 6 Lx is pretty cheap in comparison to ATTO.
- justinclift 2y agoThere are reasonably priced ConnectX-4's on Ebay these days too. :) Random example (I don't know the seller): https://www.ebay.com/itm/166609931874 https://www.ebay.com/itm/166609931874 That's $39.99 for a dual port 25GbE card, and that generation are still on the official supported list for lots of things.
- fragmede 2y agoI wonder if this ability is used anywhere professionally, specifically DPX (professional non-video compressed "codec") video color grading with Davinci Resolve. It doesn't make sense for Apple to include drivers otherwise, other than not bothering to shrink down the base install. That or some custom apps via TestFlight for other high bandwidth use cases.
- ganoushoreilly 2y agoI'm wondering if it may actually be more related to the rumored M* Series servers they've been building for internal use. Would make sense they would want the connectivity / backbone for their AI farm.
- justinclift 2y agoThe cards seem like they'd physically plug in to the 2023 Mac Pro, without the extra external chassis setup. So, maybe Apple added those drivers for people using ConnectX adapters with Mac Pros?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- oceanplexian 2y agoI’ve upgraded to a mostly 10Gbit network at an unreasonable expense and think it’s wild that we consider 25G to be “extreme”. Personal computers came standard with 1Gb interfaces in the early 00’s. What other I/O standard has made zero progress in 20 years?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tracker1 2y ago2.5G is pretty common on new hardware, 10G is relatively common on high-end prosumer hardware. So not exactly zero progress. I think a lot of it is down to the realities that most people are only really interacting with the internet at home, and for the most part, speeds over 1gb outside data centers was pretty rare. So very little need to upgrade. No mass movement to upgrade, means fewer component sales, lower production means economies of scale don't apply. Meaning you're stuck in relatively early adopter territory for a while. I upgraded my home lan as well last year, my main switch is now 10gb copper, my desktop and nas are the only devices with 10g nics, a few others are 2.5, and my secondary switches are all 2.5g to save money.
- gorkish 2y ago2.5G nics are 10gbit capable nbaseT transceivers that ship with 5gb and 10gb rates disabled to create lower end skus. It's a sick joke. The standard should have not permitted disabling the faster rates. Your average consumer cant really do much with networked data at home because the vendors are not shipping network interfaces that are useful for anything. I can have a laptop with 10/20/40gb USB ports but they can only be bothered to put a 1gbe port on it? Get real.
- Rinzler89 2y ago>Personal computers came standard with 1Gb interfaces in the early 00’s. Standard? Definitely not. Only high end prosumer gear came with gigabit as standard in the early 00's. The vast majority of affordable consumer gear still had 10/100 Fast Ethernet well into late 00's and I even saw new laptops with it even early 2010's(!).