4 ms·
'Millionaires tax' has already generated $1.8B this year for Massachusetts
- mrangle 2y agoThese type of articles are a riot: praising new taxes like they are a boon instead of primarily a political class grift with rare additional benefit to the citizenry. And especially not any that overcomes the economic drag.
- alistairSH 2y agoAre you contending trickle-down works and were too far to the right on the Laffer Curve? If so, I’d live to see the science.
- tivert 2y ago> If so, I’d live to see the science. Ok, here's the science: [insert libertarian propaganda here]
- mrangle 2y agoOnly bested by communist propaganda. I'm not a libertarian. I'm also not one to be berated into professing that the opposite of disapproving of ever more taxes is libertarianism nor anything else. The justification for ever more taxes can be intellectually contested on its face.
- tivert 2y agoWhoever said anything about communism? The idea of trickle-down economics is something that only seems to appeal to the rich and people who eat up the libertarian propaganda they produce or patronize.
- mrangle 2y ago>Whoever said anything about communism? Whoever said anything about Libertarianism? Only "rich people" and "dupes for libertarianism" "seem to" prefer low taxes? This is seriously how you think you are going to participate in a discussion, and this is your premise that you think needs to be debated? In citing communism, I was only matching your hyper-defensive snark and substance avoidance by throwing around a roughly opposite term that is meant to have a negative connotation. Just as you have repeatedly done by introducing a negative connotation for "libertarian", which again I absolutely am not. Libertarian ideology is not the opposite of pro-tax policy advocacy. What else?
- tivert 2y ago> Only "rich people" and "dupes for libertarianism" "seem to" prefer low taxes? I think your problem is you're treating "trickle-down economics" as a synonym for "low taxes," when it isn't. > In citing communism, I was only matching your hyper-defensive snark and substance avoidance by throwing around a roughly opposite term that is meant to have a negative connotation. Communism is a dead boogeyman, while libertarianism is a thing that still has some life in it.
- mrangle 2y agoHold on: I have to calm my shivering nerves after the intimidating meaningless jargon and threat to evaluate "the science", whether or not you actually have the ability to do so. I'm contending that you putting words in my mouth is garbage rhetoric and that you should know better. That higher tax revenue is not an absolute good; primarily because those who impose taxes are incentivized to do so via variously legal and unethical pay that diverts tax funds from their supposed intent back to these people. To the point that the supposed intent should be assumed to be often false until otherwise proven not only by funding but by results. And that the economic system in general is inherently flawed to the point that there is no solution that will satisfy most people either via trickle-down economics nor via heavy taxation. A slave system is not fixable by free markets, socialism-communism (old school if militant feudalism hidden so that low-wits can get behind it), nor by anything else. I'm not saying that I have a better solution as far as maintenance of civilization is concerned, but only that the system of money is fundamentally a people-ownership system that inherently cannot offer solutions, either, and out of which no ethical nor practical justification for high taxation is possible. Unless the goal is explicitly to create wealthier feudal lords that do absolutely nothing but to extract taxes to support themselves. Everyone should pay their taxes. No one has to accept the lie that more taxation is good taxation.
- skeeter2020 2y agotax the rich - the segment that has the flexibility and resources to avoid and mitigate - into a "reserve" account where politicians can fund "one-time" projects... this is a recipe for politically-motivated pet projects that deliver little value, and will eventually be downloaded to the middle and lower classes.
- ragnot 2y agoMy favorite part about this tax is that it was passed in the same year that the state had a budget surplus and actually cut checks to residents because of it.
- jncfhnb 2y agoMA has a flat income tax. Despite the name, this tax is not on millionaires, but people with incomes over $1M, which is hugely different. As someone who is within the top 5% of household incomes, feels very wealthy for any practical needs, and is not even at half the threshold required to pay this tax, I am a huge supporter. I’m a bit confused how they failed to accurately predict the amount of revenue this would generate though. Why isn’t this an easy task given they already have income numbers for regular flat taxes?
- HWR_14 2y agoIt's difficult to predict because taxes are somewhat manipulatable. Will more compensation be deferred to avoid the tax? Will some people retire or move?
- skeeter2020 2y agoexactly - they're going after a segment that has the freedom, resources and will to respond effectively, with an entire industry supporting them. Now watch the state budget on these new revenue numbers and see the shortfall in coming years.
- jncfhnb 2y agoThe article is suggesting the opposite has happened and that the tax revenues are a bit higher than expected
- jncfhnb 2y agoRereading the article, which throws out a lot of misleading numbers, it sounds like their estimate was actually pretty close. So yeah I guess that seems reasonable
- toast0 2y agoA large amount of income above $1m/year is going to be capital gains, which is difficult to predict, even under an unchanging tax system. Also, if people are going to move to avoid higher taxes, they may not move all at once, and predicting that is likely hard, too. Better to underpromise and over deliver with tax revenues, anyway.
- hedora 2y agoI’m not familiar with Massachusetts tax law. Does this also hit people with large amounts of accumulated wealth, or is it mostly aimed at the middle class? I ask because, in California, when people cash out after an IPO, they often find that they pay over 50% marginal tax. This happens even though their average earnings over the time period where they earned the stock were nowhere near the top tax bracket. On the other hand, ultra wealthy people involved in the same IPO have all sorts of mechanisms at their disposal that make it easy to avoid the big tax hit. (Most of the strategies involve taking on positive expectation risks with $100K’s of downside, which you should not do unless you’re a multi-millionaire) Anyway, the people in the former group are sometimes called HENRYs (high earner not rich yet), and I get the impression that one group pays a much higher percentage of their earnings in tax than any other group. When these millionaire taxes are proposed, they usually target Henry’s, but not people that are wealthier than that.
- jncfhnb 2y ago37% of the marginal tax rate for a high income is going to be federal. In MA you tack on 5%; and now an additional 4% for income over $1M
- Ajay-p 2y agoAre you thinking perhaps of something like Harvard's endowment which was valued at $49.444 billion as of June 30, 2022. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvard_University_endowment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harvard_University_endowment
- hedora 2y agoThat’s a non-profit, so no. Consider a billionaire that doesn’t work but has passive investments that pull in about $100M per year. They can borrow against the assets for close to 0%, or they could donate the gains to their own charities, keep the assets in shell companies that own hotels they live in, etc, etc. This 4% millionaire’s income tax won’t touch any of that.
- Workaccount2 2y agoThe fundamental problem is that wealthy people have their wealth in assets and their cash comes in loans. The best I can come up with is a tax on loans larger than X with assets that meet the points ABC used as collateral. On the other hand though, I can make a case that they shouldn't be taxed anymore as it is. The assets they hold generate the majority of the taxes collected anyway. Bezos might not pay a lot in taxes, but amazon does and the amount it generates in sales taxes and income taxes is enormous. It's a difficult problem and it's why progress has been stagnant in this area for decades.