7 ms·
Soviet Moon Lander Discovered Water on The Moon in 1976
- ig1 14y agoSurely the cross-contamination arguments apply to the Soviet sample as well ?
- toemetoch 14y agoMy thought exactly. Couldn't they settle this with an isotope analysis?
- glesica 14y agoNot if their container sealed properly.
- ktizo 14y agoIn the article it states that the cross contamination arguments applied to the nasa rocks because the astronauts couldn't get the lid back on the sample containers. There could be contamination of the Russian samples, but the same argument about containers being improperly sealed doesn't apply unless there is some sort of evidence that it should.
- rbanffy 14y agoHow many container designs were tested? Between 11 and 17 there were 6 landings. Did they notice the problem on 11? It's an interesting problem. The sample container will have to hold the external pressure out and, depending on the container temperature, deal with condensation around the seal.
- Jun8 14y agoAnother example of just what a huge goldmine Russian technical journals can be for researchers, if you can read them.
- Create 14y agoThey were being read, even at the time. Although an NLP disaster at the time, it was a boon for programming languages. Old story in new package: http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20120529-a-cold-war-google-translate http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20120529-a-cold-war-google-t... (Chomsky and all the compiler people got their funding from there)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 14y agothe F-117 was built based on a Russian paper http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_F-117_Nighthawk#Background_and_Have_Blue http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_F-117_Nighthawk#Backgr...
- redthrowaway 14y agoMakes you wonder why the Russians are only just investing in stealth technology. The US has been doing it for more than three decades.
- themstheones 14y agoThe soviet space program sure is standing the test of time.
- unreal37 14y agoHow easy it is to forget the cold war. In 2012, we cannot look back at scientists of 1976 and say "you should have read and believed this obscure Russian science journal and the argument would have been put to permanent rest". 1976 was a different time in Russian-American relations especially when it came to space. The article ends by saying our belief of water on the moon has improved from "one part per billion" in 2006, to "one part per million" today, like it's a huge revolutionary improvement. I know it's 1000x, but its still just one part per million. So it takes a million gallons of moon rocks to extract one gallon of water? Which makes me wonder what the water ppm of Earth is.
- rbanffy 14y agoFor the surface, at least, it's about 750K ppm, but most of it is around 1M ppm.
- noselasd 14y agoAs we're on the topic of the Soviet space program, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunokhod_1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunokhod_1 is worth a read - they were driving rovers around on the moon in 1970
- endlessvoid94 14y agoIs that still on the moon?
- mongolinux 14y agoOf course it is still on the moon )) It was lost and forgotten in 71, but rediscovered recently: http://www.space.com/8295-lost-soviet-reflecting-device-rediscovered-moon.html http://www.space.com/8295-lost-soviet-reflecting-device-redi...
- ck2 14y agoI wonder what kind of war moon-water will start. The first country to start using it is going to cause an uproar.
- run4yourlives 14y agoYou're going to start moon wars when Canada has 10% of all the freshwater on the planet?
- SudarshanP 14y agoWhat he probably means is that, the small quantities of ice on moon is precious. If some country say US manages to extract it all for itself, other countries like China could be pissed off... But I kinda like such a race ;-) minus the war though...
- lotharbot 14y ago> "If some country say US manages to extract it all for itself" They found a bit of water essentially just by drilling down. If it's like that all over the moon, or even over an appreciable fraction of the moon, then getting it all for yourself is an unmanageably huge task. Remember, the moon, while considerably smaller than the Earth, is still a very big place.
- scarmig 14y ago"Water on the moon" and "water on the earth" have very different values: the cost of transport dwarfs the cost of the water. A barrel of water on the moon is worth millions because of those costs. Beyond that, "water on the moon" is relatively cheaply converted into "water in space." I still doubt that a war would end up happening over it, if only because it appears relatively cheap enough to extract that it's not worth the effort and risk to build a war-making apparatus to prevent other people from extracting it.
- mukaiji 14y agoYet another sad example of how ideology got the best of science.