3 ms·
Okay, imagine your computer downloads an update to, say, official MS Weather app. You launch it, and suddenly, there it is, a goatse, right on the main screen,
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
Okay, imagine your computer downloads an update to, say, official MS Weather app. You launch it, and suddenly, there it is, a goatse, right on the main screen, as backdrop to the current weather. A quick search on-line tells you that you were not hacked, but this is, in fact, an official UI change from the last update.
Who do you think should be shamed for this? The developers who put it there? The UI experts who said where to put it? The UX experts that came up with this particular image as a way to maximize engagement? The product owners who told the team to add some extremely gross visual shock image to the app to boost engagement, and who approved that particular choice? The QA team that let it through? I'd say: yes, all of them.
You definitely can't put blame on a single individual here. There's lot of blame to be put on many individuals across the organizational structure. I picked an extreme hypothetical example to work like a contrast agent, to make it easier to see that there are parts of the org that are directly involved with some wrongdoing (vs. indirectly involved by e.g. setting incentives), and it's not absurd to want to put blame on all of them.
- badsectoracula 2y agoI think you should read the entirety of my message because what you wrote is basically what i wrote. You can't blame a single individual - or even a few people - you can only blame some amorphous blob of humans, like the entire company. But by doing that the blame is so diffused that unless it is something as egregious as the extreme example you gave, it wont mean anything (and in practice the only reason it might mean something is because it might become news and affect some shares value or whatever - i.e. things wont change because the people that make up the organization you blamed are all convinced it is bad to put goatse in MS Weather but because of the indirect effect your blame had - and the people in there can always go and add goatse-like stuff in other products, perhaps in other companies).