5 ms·
I keep hearing that Elon Musk is a "fraud". He's about as far from a fraud as one could get.
by WalterBright 2y ago
I keep hearing that Elon Musk is a "fraud". He's about as far from a fraud as one could get.
- iknowstuff 2y agoyea getting tired of people confidently asserting their ignorant opinions about spacex and tesla based on ragebait headlines.
- blackhawkC17 2y agoMusk has his faults, but most of his critics have nothing close to his risk-taking ability and grit. It’s usually people who have hardly ever risked anything to start a business, nonetheless in a cutthroat industry. If you gave most people $180 million, they’ll happily retire into the sunset, not invest it in very risky electric car and aerospace companies like Musk.
- kibwen 2y agoOnce you have enough money for you and your children to live comfortably for the rest of your lives without lifting a finger, there is no risk whatsoever to spending whatever money you have left over. At no point was Elon Musk ever risking his comfort or the future of his family's financial well-being, unlike actual rags-to-riches entrepreneurs with skin in the game and actual consequences for failure.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThis applies to every billionaire and millionaire, he risked a larger percentage of his wealth than 99% of them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 2y agoIf you read his biography, he was at one point within 4 hours of being reduced to a net worth of about $100,000. He risked everything he had. He also came to this country with nothing but a suitcase, slept in youth hostels, and took sanitation jobs to support himself. He's exactly the classic American self-made zillionaire industrialist.
- lupusreal 2y agoIt seems to correlate with reddit usage. Reddit is easily astroturfed to manufacture consensus, and there are plenty of people out there with an interest in turning people against SpaceX. Notably the CCP. If you chart tonnage to orbit by year, you'll see that China briefly overtook America before being absolutely eclipsed by SpaceX. Not much they can do about it either, but stoking domestic opposition to SpaceX is one thing they could do.
- hartator 2y agoUS politics propaganda.
- underseacables 2y agoI think a lot of the criticism is political. When you separate from that, Elon has had a profound impact on space and automotive. He isn't perfect and has certainly made many mistakes, but there isn't really anyone like him pushing technology forward like this.
- parthianshotgun 2y agoIf you do the right thing for the wrong reasons the work becomes corrupted, impure, and ultimately self destructive.
- option 2y agoand if you do nothing or fail to execute for good reasons you do not matter
- parthianshotgun 2y agoI don't think you understood what I was trying to express
- electriclove 2y agoHe is doing the right thing, for the right reasons. He wants to preserve humanity’s existence into the future. EVERYTHING he does is driven by this
- parthianshotgun 2y agoI have a bridge to sell you then
- lesuorac 2y agoIt's pretty funny, there was so much pent up demand for EVs that the one guy that actually did it not as a political stunt became a billionaire. It's not like they didn't have a chance to either, they all developed EVs as side projects [1]. Some of which were incredibly loved by their leasers (?) [2]. [1]: https://avt.inl.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/fsev/HistoryOfElectricCars.pdf https://avt.inl.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/fsev/HistoryOfEl... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_Killed_the_Electric_Car%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_Killed_the_Electric_Car%3F
- mrtksn 2y agoI think they say it for some other stuff that don't work as well, like Hyperloop or self driving cars.
- bufferoverflow 2y agoI just used FSD yesterday. It works pretty damn well.
- adamnemecek 2y agoThe marketing still over promises.
- spiderice 2y agoShow me a company that doesn’t over promise on their marketing.
- Retric 2y agoMost of them don’t, go to a local pub some time. Some people misunderstand that companies use puffery like “The Best” specifically because it doesn’t mean anything. But you will rarely find someone make material statements that aren’t true, if an advert mentions the EPA rated gas’s mileage it’s going to be close. Musk on the other hand has this odd issue of trying to overstate his accomplishments such as calling himself a founder of Tesla for some bizarre reason. I don’t know if imposter syndrome or what, but it’s been very detrimental for stockholders when he had Tesla rescue Solar City rather than letting it fail etc. Making material statements about self driving was just dumb from a legal perspective compared to puffery, but hey it sold some cars and he’s not in prison so ehh it worked out.
- bufferoverflow 2y agoYour argument has nothing to do with what we're discussing, you're just piling unrelated talking points. That's a classic red herring fallacy.
- LeoPanthera 2y agoThere's a mountain of assumptions in this tiny little comment, so let's try to separate them out. 1. Elon is 100% successful. ("As far as one could get") 2. "Fraud" means the opposite of success. 3. Elon is successful because SpaceX is successful. 4. SpaceX is successful because of the sheer tonnage of stuff they have thrown into space. 5. More stuff in space is better than less stuff in space. Are any of these assumptions true? I wouldn't like to speculate, but I would at least claim that it's worth the debate.
- BluSyn 2y agoReputation damage through faux media is the cheapest form of information warfare. Many industries, and now days many world governments, have a deeply vested interest in Elon failing.
- kibwen 2y agoPlease point to the portion of the rocket that was designed or manufactured by Elon Musk. Testimonies from SpaceX's own employees show that Musk is a capricious and immature meddler whose presence is to be managed and deflected rather than welcomed. His documented cronyism and looting of Tesla with his ridiculous and petulant demands for tens of billions in bonus compensation while threatening to leave the company if he doesn't get his way show that he treats Tesla as his personal piggybank rather than offering anything tangible, other than alienating Tesla's core demographic via his ill-considered tweets. Meanwhile, here on this site, every programmer knew he was a fraud of a manager the moment he ordered Twitter employees to print out their most recent code so that he could determine who to fire. If Elon Musk didn't want to be called a liar, maybe he should try telling fewer lies?
- ozr 2y agoTwitter is running fine post-firings, and he saved a ton of money. If Elon is so horrific at SpaceX, why is it the only space organization (including NASA) able to innovate and ship anymore? You can dislike his personality, but criticizing his performance is silly.
- PartiallyTyped 2y agoTwitter dropped in value to just 25% of what it was. Racism and naziism are rampant, endless stream of bots pushing propaganda or porn, and has any advertiser actually come back?
- ozr 2y agoThis is more rhetoric driven by a personal dislike of someone vs. reality. > Twitter dropped in value to just 25% of what it was. It's a private company. You don't know the value. > Racism and naziism are rampant, endless stream of bots pushing propaganda or porn Maybe on your feed? Statistically, no. > and has any advertiser actually come back? Who knows. It's still running after firing anyone: that's the point. Tesla was the first and still the only electric car player that matters. Same with SpaceX and space. Again: you can dislike Elon's personality or politics, but trying to attack his results is ridiculous.
- jiggawatts 2y agoI like to listen to the opinions of people that worked directly for him. Ilya Sutskever and Andrej Karpathy both have very positive things to say.
- CSMastermind 2y agoAs I've gotten older I've realized the stunning difference between people's public personas and the experience of actually knowing them. They are, at best, loosely correlated. As a rule most people, especially successful ones, are generally pleasant to interact with. They wouldn't be successful if they weren't. There are some notable exceptions of course but as a rule: don't believe what you read about people and assume they're probably pretty pleasant to be around or work with.
- afavour 2y agoThere is no need to turn people into absolutes. He can be a genius in one industry and a fraud in another.
- rockemsockem 2y agoWhich industry is he a fraud in though? You're implying it's tech I assume?
- trust_bt_verify 2y agoThe self driving car industry.
- rockemsockem 2y agoAgreed on this. The "full self driving" moniker is absolutely over hyped and ridiculous. "We don't need lidar" also sounds quite silly.
- afavour 2y agoWell, “fraud” was the OP’s word, not mine. In my mind it connotes something criminal and I’m not sure Musk has reached that bar. But I do think he’s some kind of a confidence man, trading on SpaceX’s reputation to project competence elsewhere where he simply doesn’t have it. Tech in particular, yes.
- rockemsockem 2y agoI think the tech criticism is kinda weird since he founded successful software companies before SpaceX. One of which gets used all the time to this day, although obviously PayPal has changed a bunch since then. Like is it ridiculous to print code out to "review"? Obviously, yes, but a few stupid ideas doesn't make someone an outright fraud. I'll note that here I'm using fraud as I believe OP was using it, to indicate that someone is pretending to be something or have some talent that they do not. IDK, I find "fraud" to be a weird criticism in general for Elon. Like he seems like he's kinda a huge asshole and he's really bad at estimates. People in general seem to want to criticize people they don't like on multiple angles and often don't care if the other angles are true at all as long as one is. That kind of thing really irks me.
- narrator 2y agoYou're failing to account for the most common cognitive bias on the entire internet which is : "People I agree with are smart. People I disagree with are stupid."
- WalterBright 2y agoFor most people, it is indeed a bias. For myself, however, it's the truth.
- JimBright 2y agoI reject your truth and replace it with my own.
- electriclove 2y agoYup! People (even seemingly intelligent folks here) want to hate on the guy. Yeah, he can be a jerk sometimes.. but if you are denying the tremendous positive impact he is making with Tesla, SpaceX, Neuralink, Twitter, Boring, etc.. please take a moment to consider that you may be suffering from Elon Derangement Syndrome
- ProfMeowsworth 2y agoAgreed on SpaceX and partly on Tesla. What is his “tremendous positive impact” with Twitter and Boring? Not trying to argue, just curious if there’s something I don’t see.
- electriclove 2y agoTwitter - free speech Boring - no big impact yet but there is a possibility it could Neuralink - incredible potential to have a big impact
- WalterBright 2y agoI like Musk's reincarnation of twitter. I didn't care much for the "sanitized for my protection" earlier version. I wish I could buy some stock in X, though I understand keeping it private to keep the scourge of activist investors out of it.
- danlugo92 2y agoBut the tv said I should hate him!
- bagels 2y agoSome things he does seem to be fraud. Some things are not. What fraction is needed for one to be "a fraud"? To clarify some of those things: Self driving car, Flying Tesla Roadster, "Funding secured"
- shirro 2y agoIt is hard to define what value Musk brought to his enterprises apart from capital and hype. I do not like or respect Musk but SpaceX are undeniably a world leading aerospace engineering company and very likely would still be if he wasn't associated with them in my opinion.
- delichon 2y agoHe is the main decision maker after all, and hires the other major ones, and exercises veto power. Is the success of the company really independent of those choices?
- shirro 2y agoHe certainly had an impact on Tesla's supercharger team. I know it goes against the prevailing mythology in the US of great men and visionary leaders but sometimes success or failure have more to do with the market and time. He did recruit a spectacular team for early SpaceX. For all I know he may have had some extraordinary talent for hiring or it might have been luck and a target rich environment. Either way the success of SpaceX was very real and greatly contributed to the mythos surrounding Musk.
- WalterBright 2y ago> and very likely would still be if he wasn't associated with them Not a chance. It would be worthwhile to read a biography of Musk.
- lupusreal 2y ago> SpaceX are undeniably a world leading aerospace engineering company and very likely would still be if he wasn't associated with them in my opinion. How much has Blue Origin put into orbit? They've had as much money and more time than SpaceX, but aren't lead by Elon Musk, and how do they compare today?
- shirro 2y agoBlue Origin have been consistently disappointing. The leadership of Bezos and Bob Smith had a lot to do with their lack of achievement but that might change with Smith gone though they are still persisting with the stupid sub-orbital joy rides which will never be wildly profitable or lead to other things. BE-4 production still seems very slow which hasn't been good for ULA but there is at least signs of movement with New Glenn with a launch scheduled this year. I do read books and I acknowledge Musk was a bit more than just the money man in early SpaceX. Perhaps I am too cynical but I think many people are prone to cults of personality and over-estimating the impact of individuals. SpaceX is well beyond being a founder's plaything. If they were truly dependent on Musk's micro-management they would have a very serious bus problem for an organization of their size and importance.