4 ms·
Yes, absolutely illegal. You don't need to copyright anything, you simply own the rights your own likeness -- your visual appearance and your voice. A company
by crazygringo 2y ago
Yes, absolutely illegal. You don't need to copyright anything, you simply own the rights your own likeness -- your visual appearance and your voice.
A company can't take a photo from your Facebook and plaster it across an advertisement for their product without you giving them the rights to do that.
And if you're a known public figure, this includes lookalikes and soundalikes as well. You can't hire a ScarJo impersonator that people will think is ScarJo.
This is clearly a ScarJo soundalike. It doesn't matter whether it's an AI voice or clone or if they hired someone to sound just like her. Because she's a known public figure, that's illegal if she hasn't given them the rights.
(However, if you generate a synthetic voice that just happens to sound exactly like a random Joe Schmo, it's allowed because Joe Schmo isn't a public figure, so there's no value in the association.)
- zooq_ai 2y agoBut is that Scarlett Jo or Producers of Her that own the copyright? If you imitate Darth Vader, I don't think James Earl Jones has as much case for likeliness as Star Wars franchise
- ceruleanseas 2y agoJames Earl Jones sold his voice rights to Disney a couple of years ago, so they can continue to use an AI likeness of his voice for future movies. https://ambadar.com/insights/james-earl-jones-signs-off-his-voice-what-are-image-rights/# https://ambadar.com/insights/james-earl-jones-signs-off-his-...
- crazygringo 2y agoIt's both. If you just want ScarJo's (or James Earl Jones') voice, you need the rights from them. Period. If you want to reuse the character of her AI bot from the movie (her name, overall personality, tone, rhythm, catchphrases, etc.), or the character of Darth Vader, you also need to license that from the producers. And also from ScarJo/Jones if you want the same voice to accompany the character. (Unless they've sold all rights for future re-use to the producers, which won't usually be the case, because they want to be paid for sequels.)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nickthegreek 2y agoIf they didn’t use her actual voice for the training, didn’t hire voice talent to imitate her, didnt pursue her for a voice contract, didn’t make a reference to the movie in which she voices an AI, I feel OpenAI would have been on more stable legal footing. But they aren’t playing with a strong hand now and folded fast.
- rockemsockem 2y agoYou're 100% correct and there's precedent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midler_v._Ford_Motor_Co https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midler_v._Ford_Motor_Co.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- GuB-42 2y agoNot only that but they didn't credit the voice actress who sounds like her. If she was semi-famous and just naturally sounded like Scarlett Johansson, maybe they could have an argument: "it is not Scarlett, it is the famous [C-list actress] who worked in [production some people may know]".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- howbadisthat 2y agoScarlet owns the voice of a stranger that happens to sound like her? That seems absurd. Just find someone who sounds like her, then hire them for the rights to their voice.
- callalex 2y agoIt’s really hard to assume in good faith that you are unfamiliar with the concept of impersonation. Just in case: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impersonator https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impersonator There is no doubt that the hired actor was an impersonator, this was explicitly stated by scama himself.
- howbadisthat 2y agoThe variance in voice is not that great. Just find someone who is very close to her voice naturally.
- airstrike 2y agoDoesn't matter if the intent is to make the listener think they're hearing ScarJo
- sneak 2y agoI missed that; where did he say that?
- warcher 2y agoIt’s just that her voice by itself is relatively unremarkable. Someone like say, Morgan freeman, or Barack Obama, someone with a distinctive vocal delivery, that’s one thing. Scarlett Johansson, I couldn’t place her voice out of a lineup. I’m sure it’s pleasant I just can’t think of it.
- llamaimperative 2y agoScarlett Johansson does absolutely have a distinctive and very famous voice. I wouldn’t take your own ignorance (not meant disparagingly) as evidence otherwise. That’s why she was the voice actor for the AI voice in Her.