4 ms·
> The challenge is this approach flies in the face of so many of the messages parents are getting about admissions to selective colleges. At a recent event host
by ryandrake 2y ago
> The challenge is this approach flies in the face of so many of the messages parents are getting about admissions to selective colleges. At a recent event hosted by her 17-year-old daughter’s high school, “the college counselor was talking about kids’ essays, saying that teens should tie their passions and interests to what they want to major in,” she says. “To be pre-med, these teens are expected to already have volunteered in a hospital or a lab.
This is the root cause of the madness. Colleges insist on weighing these activities heavily in admissions decisions, so parents have no choice but to force their kids to jump through the hoops. It's a Prisoner's Dilemma problem: If parents all at once decided cooperatively that enough was enough, it would end. But any single parent who chooses "defect" and pushes their kid towards "activities" will be rewarded with an edge in admissions, so everyone else must choose "defect" and we're all worse-off because of it.
Colleges need to get their heads out of their asses. Is my kid really going to be a better student because she volunteered at a hospital or played high school softball?
- ravenstine 2y ago> Is my kid really going to be a better student because she volunteered at a hospital or played high school softball? Not if it's a mere exercise in box-ticking.
- ryandrake 2y agoHow do college admissions departments figure out who is box-ticking, to know whether the person they are looking at is a better student?
- fargle 2y agoof course they don't. but that doesn't mean you shouldn't do extra-curriculars to benefit yourself or your kids, just because other people are dishonest.
- vundercind 2y agoOpen question how much they care, I’d say. Willingness and ability to optimize ladder-climbing game-playing might be just fine by them.
- kelipso 2y agoPretty sure the whole extracurricular thing is to look for upper class markers than success in the field they major in... Probably just SAT would be enough for that lol.
- elevatedastalt 2y agoDespite people wanting to pretend otherwise, the SAT correlates pretty well with general intelligence.
- ceejayoz 2y agoThat expensive test prep can bump up the score significantly clearly indicates that isn’t the only component, though.
- twoodfin 2y agoMy understanding is that inexpensive test prep boosts scores comparably. That it’s possible to prepare for the SAT to score better doesn’t seem intrinsically opposed to its purpose.
- steveBK123 2y agoYes, simple $50 Kaplan CDs back in the day and a pack of practice tests..
- elevatedastalt 2y agoPreparation helps for any test, simply because tests have a specific structure, format, expectations for how answers are to be given etc. That doesn't mean that test scores are indicators only of preparation. Even a native speaker of English might not get a full score on the TOEFL or the IELTS if they are unaware of the format etc. That doesn't mean the TOEFL isn't fundamentally a strong test of the knowledge of English. Another way of looking at it: Athletes need training and coaching, but that doesn't mean any random guy paired with a coach will become a top athlete.
- 2y ago
- morkalork 2y agoI can't say anything about sports but volunteering at a hospital or long term care home is a good way to find out if they've got the stomach for it. Nursing programs suffer huge drop out rates when they put kids in a clinical setting so they move that up as early as possible the program. An applicant who has already done some volunteering and still applied isn't the one whose going to bail out after seeing blood and poop their first clinical day.
- Swizec 2y ago> It's a Prisoner's Dilemma problem I think it's a Red Queen's Race problem. If everyone is running, you have to be running just to stay put (relatively). To out-compete, you gotta run faster. But there's only so hard anyone can run. The real game is in finding or creating leverage. What can you (or your kids) do that nobody else can do? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen%27s_race https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen%27s_race
- Retric 2y agoThe vast majority of colleges accept students just fine without any particular extracurricular activities. So this isn’t about collage, just the artificial hoops that some colleges use to maintain their elite status. Elite schools offer a few real advantages, but far less than most people assume.
- diob 2y agoThe advantage is the network / badge that comes with it. That and you tend to have great funding / access to more opportunities. So, I'd argue there's a great advantage. But it's more accessible to those who already have advantages, since they look for these "early life" markers which many normal folk have little to no control over.
- csa 2y ago> The advantage is the network / badge that comes with it. Vastly overrated except for a very small number of people who didn’t already have a network and do the right kind of hustle to develop it. It happens, but it’s rare. Most of the folks at these schools already have a decent or good network. The badge rarely makes a difference for most people.
- steveBK123 2y agoElite schools still offer far greater advantages than they should, let's not fool ourselves. A lot of hiring companies use elite college as a screen to run simple recruiting pipelines. GOOG was notorious for only recruiting from a handful of elite tech schools with very high GPA requirements to filter out resumes. In finance just about every single person I have met in a risk taking role came out of an Ivy program. If you went to top engineering school the best you could do is work for the Ivy guy writing algos for him. If you didn't go to a top engineering school, you probably got recruited for desktop support. I'm sure every industry has a version of this, given the 2 I am familiar with most both do.
- whimsicalism 2y ago> In finance just about every single person I have met in a risk taking role came out of an Ivy program Front-office finance has very strong incentives to recruit from Ivy and other elite institutions beyond mere competence. I don't think it should be assumed to be the same effect at play at Google, etc
- rileymat2 2y ago> Is my kid really going to be a better student because she volunteered at a hospital or played high school softball? Is the goal the best student or creating well rounded enlightened contributions? If that’s the goal, probably. If they are thrown in them to check boxes, probably not.
- jameshart 2y agoIt’s a peacock tail. Diverting effort and energy into external signals of intellectual health to impress potential collegiate mates.
- zeteo 2y ago> Is my kid really going to be a better student because she volunteered at a hospital or played high school softball? Unfortunately, kids from disadvantaged socio-economic backgrounds have fewer opportunities to volunteer and to pursue expensive sports. These colleges are, in effect, selecting for what Thorstein Veblen would have called "conspicuous leisure" and "conspicuous consumption", i.e. for an upper middle-class background (or above). A long time ago I applied to one of the top business schools in the US and was told quite directly, during the interview process, that the MBA program was mostly about networking and not so much about academics. It looks like this attitude has now expanded to many four-year colleges as well. In business terms, it's all about "culture fit" these days.
- diob 2y agoYep. It's a cycle where they select based on this, and those folks go on to do well due to network / opportunity. Not saying they don't have talent, but there isn't a lack of talent in the lower class either.
- csa 2y ago> kids from disadvantaged socio-economic backgrounds have fewer opportunities to volunteer and to pursue expensive sports This is very much factored in during admissions at elite schools.
- csa 2y ago> This is the root cause of the madness. Colleges insist on weighing these activities heavily in admissions decisions, so parents have no choice but to force their kids to jump through the hoops. This matters pretty much only at elite schools. These schools are looking for ambition and the ability to get shit done. This is not a bad way to do it. Maybe not the most optimal, but it’s not bad. Some folks think this is not fair or reasonable. The reality is that elite schools can’t just admit based on scores and grades (easy to inflate) due to that system not being selective enough for the number of available slots. > Is my kid really going to be a better student because she volunteered at a hospital… Hmmm… 1. Probably doesn’t matter for most schools. 2. Less likely to wash out of a pre-med major if s/he has done this. There is a very high percentage of pre-med washouts (that’s totally ok), but an applicant with a good why is more likely to stick to it, and that’s probably good for the school. 3. Elite schools, which are the pretty much the only ones where this is relevant, will want more than “volunteered at a hospital”. They want to see significant contributions and/or leadership. > or played high school softball? Probably not, but regarding elite schools (probably doesn’t matter elsewhere)… There is a culture around sports and upper middle class / elite culture in the US. This is especially true for varsity athletics (I call it a totally-not-a-club-club). Some folks may not like that this is true, but that doesn’t make it any less true.
- brigade 2y agoIt's very much "figure out what AOs want and fake it" rather than "show ambition and ability to get shit done", and kids are acutely aware of the fakeness of it all. Like, it's a meme among the "applying to Ivies" crowd just how many nonprofits high schoolers start that are total shams, designed for the sole purpose of being able to say they "founded a nonprofit dedicated to giving ukulele lessons for historically underserved neighborhoods" on their application without technically lying. It is an important lesson that the biggest controllable factor in success is figuring out how to play the game, rather than actual passion in doing something.
- fargle 2y agodisagree. extra-curriculars can be faked, gamed, etc. you can take this to a crazy extreme and end up with burned-out kids. but, colleges weighing these activities for admissions? 100% the right thing to do. > Is my kid really going to be a better student because she volunteered at a hospital[?] as a sibling comment pointed out, certainly. because you'll know what your getting into vs. a romanticized fantasy or some salary-based-major selection. > Is my kid really going to be a better student because she [...] played high school softball? yes, 100% yes. of course it doesn't have to be sports, but it has to be something other than sitting on the couch. sports teaches teamwork and leadership skills. music does the same and more. other hobbies promote exploration and independent learning, and could be tied to developing interests. kids that have done stuff are going to be way better at college and life than those who never did anything outside of the limitations of public school. - just don't take it to extremes (if one extra-curricular activity is good, 5-10 should be great!) - just don't get focused on sports only. not everyone is an outdoor sportsman. anything should be fair game.
- itronitron 2y agoAll of my 'extracurricular' activities that turned out to be useful/productive/important were not organized in any way by adults. I think many people are arguing that students should have more free time available to develop their own interests.
- fargle 2y agosure, many of mine were the same. and i bet you could have tied that to what you wanted to do in an essay. so to me, that isn't a problem, certainly not a good example of why colleges have their "heads up their asses" (oh and i certainly think they do). and yes, in fact, volunteering at a hospital should be viewed favorably for pre-med. and yes, you will be a better student if you play some kind of team sport like softball than if you did nothing. so perhaps the comment i was replying to made bad arguments? for example, if a school only liked mainstream athletics and ignored anything else (which is probably not a stretch), that would be a better example of "having their heads up their asses". but the specific examples given were the opposite - they actually make sense.
- toss1 2y ago>>Is my kid really going to be a better student because she volunteered at a hospital or played high school softball? Yes, IFF the activity was pursued seriously, as in a serious sustained effort seeking mastery. There are lesson learned in serious endeavors that simply will not be learned in any class, yet apply to every part of life. My example: I was very serious about alpine ski racing in my teens+; it was not really affordable, but I found support, put in sometimes crazy effort and got to international levels. The small role it played in getting me into college was the least benefit - the lessons learned played a huge role in my being able to succeed in college and in life. For example, I completely leaned to control test anxiety and knew how to reliably put down my best performance (pretty easy to do it sitting in a chair vs launching out of the starting gate on an iced trail where the test is at 85mph). Applying oneself to study vs physical training, again the training improved the study. On and on. Also, pursuing activities usually entail travel, and if it is international, it's far better. Going to other countries as something other than a tourist gives a far broader perspective to life, which lasts a lifetime And I can tell you similar stories from every athlete, musician, and other person I met at my college and others. Being 'well-rounded' is a real and valuable characteristic. Of course, as others mentioned, this must be a serious effort, not merely an exercise in box-ticking. But even having said so, even just getting experiences as an exercise in box-ticking can provide more experience than sitting home. The key thing is to have kids try enough different things so they find the thing THEY are passionate about. Then, organize their studies and activities around that. I just read one very interesting story about a girl doing just that -- fun read [0]. She got interested in mycology, made a boat from mushrooms, and would up with a full-ride scholarship. THAT is how it should work. [0] https://theheartysoul.com/this-community-college-student-made-a-boat-out-of-mushrooms-and-sailed-it-down-a-river/ https://theheartysoul.com/this-community-college-student-mad...