3 ms·
On a touchscreen, every use case is equally painful compared to more precise input methods. That's only an advantage if your users spend a significant fraction
by lxgr 2y ago
On a touchscreen, every use case is equally painful compared to more precise input methods. That's only an advantage if your users spend a significant fraction of time in unexpected input situations.
Personally, while I am able to do most everything I do on my computer on my smartphone, I almost never enjoy doing so – one big exception being content consumption. And even then, not being able to quickly make a note or comment on what I'm reading feels constraining.
> I also think there's a big advantage to the vertical form factor for many applications - just look at how we've settled on a vertical format for almost all reading material.
One seems to be strictly a consequence of the other.
> most phones can switch between vertical and horizontal modes as necessary.
Horizontal mode is usually horrible, both in terms of being able to hold the phone with one hand, and in terms of UI. On iOS for example, Safari's UI becomes extremely wasteful in horizontal mode.
> And it's not like it's just the first thing that we tried that stuck - there are a myriad of failed smartphone concepts that have been tried out but just aren't as convenient.
I think it has at least as much to do with industry momentum. Even if I'd personally prefer another form factor, I won't have many apps optimized for it if it's not in line with mainstream phone usage.
- zozbot234 2y ago> On a touchscreen, every use case is equally painful compared to more precise input methods. Touchscreen input could actually be quite precise if it was based on specialized gestures such as swiping and pie menus. Extensions of Fitt's law (that mouse-based interfaces are heavily based upon) have been developed that are applicable to swiping tasks, viz. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steering_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steering_law
- wonger_ 2y agoI'm curious about alternative inputs like swiping and pie menus, or two-finger inputs, or inputs relying on corners and edges. Do you know any apps that use specialized gestures?
- dredmorbius 2y agoEither PocketBook or FBReader for Android used pie menus in at least some versions. I'd used it on an old Android 5 device where the pie menus were present for some functions. They don't appear on my e-ink Android 10 device. Not sure if that's the device / Android version or an app update. <https://pocketbook.ch/en-ch/app https://pocketbook.ch/en-ch/app> <https://fbreader.org/android https://fbreader.org/android> (Not positive which it was, though I think it was PocketBook. Device is not presently accessible.) As for the pie menus: they were useful in some cases, but aren't a universal panacea for all touch UI problems.