8 ms·
Talent shortage in Indian IT
- nhebb 14y ago> Sturgeon’s law applies here. 95% of all startups will fail. There’s no escaping it. I don't know about India or software startups in particular, but according to Dun and Bradstreet the 4-year survival rate of new businesses is 37%. Edit: I can't confirm the 37% figure. It's a number that stuck in my head from a few years ago. They're latest report [1] doesn't include survival rates. [1] http://www.dnbgov.com/pdf/US_Business_Trends_Jan11.pdf http://www.dnbgov.com/pdf/US_Business_Trends_Jan11.pdf
- mseebach 14y agoNew business != startup. Small and/or lifestyle businesses are great, but there are many properties they don't share with startups (mainly scalability leading to growth). In many cases a "new business" simply mean an independent contractor who in this statistic might as well be a regular salaried employee. Also someone spending time building a prototype, validating the market, looking for funding etc. but not bothering to register the business while there's no revenue could fail before ever making it into the "new business" statistic. Therefore it's perfectly plausible that 95% of startups fail while only 63% of all new businesses do. Then of course there's the fact that the 95% number is rhetoric, not a statistic.
- gnufied 14y agoRather old article and mostly true, except : "We’re in a booming economy now. This is an employee’s market." I believe this is true almost always for people who are good at what they do.
- akarambir 14y agoIf the company declares it confidential, leave. They don’t have a plan. This can't be true for all startups. Some ideas are worth being confidential. Yeah I know execution matters most, but still idea can be what they are excited about.
- drunkpotato 14y agoYou are technically correct, but in this case it's not the best kind of correct. Of course it's not 100% for sure they don't have a viable plan, but it's likely they don't and more importantly it's not worth your time to find out. The OP is right: leave.
- rdl 14y agoEven if there is secret sauce, they should be able to explain their overall business model to the level of a business plan.
- mseebach 14y agoIf their business plan is so simple that they will compromise it by telling you, they don't have a business plan. If they can't identify the small bit of secret sauce (algorithm or research, unique understanding of/access to the market, unique set of competences etc) that will make them successful and thus needs protection, they either don't have it, or they don't understand it. Either case is bad.
- mqzaidi 14y agoAs someone who has worked at many startups in India, here are my 2 cents. You chose to work at a startup not in the hope of a glorious exit via some acquisition or an IPO. You work at a startup because you want to surround yourself by really smart people. When making generalizations, while it is certain that most startups will fail, it is also quite likely that most of your startup coworkers will eventually succeed and go to great places, and when they do, they will take you along if you were any good in the first place. Because one thing that almost guarantees failure is not trying, and you would find a lot of 'not trying, complacent with my good job' people not at the startups, but at the large or middle sized companies past their prime, running on the momentum they picked earlier. This is what I tell people when I hire them, and believe me, a lot more people are getting this now than a decade ago, when startups were associated with unexpected riches and easy money. That's a lot of hope.
- mjwalshe 14y agoRealy if you want to work for realy smart peopel you go and work at some where like CERN, NASA JPL and other tier 1 RnD organisations - of course for a devloper the pay sucks
- truncate 14y agoHaven't done any kind of proper survey but from what I see many startups here don't like to pay even decent. They would hire with low salary. However the point is if you want good developers, you need to pay them well! Even if you manage to find some good developer at low salary, he will probably not perform his best. Finally, they would lag behind schedule, resources get scarse and they are officially failed.
- andyjohnson0 14y ago"Look at the HR policies most companies have. The big shops all treat their “fresher” recruits as bonded labour. (The contracts are worded to pass the bond off as training fees.)" Am I understanding this right. People have to pay a 'bond' to a new employer? Is this common in India? Other countries?
- kranner 14y agoYes, this is common in India.
- FlyingSnake 14y agoMany outsourcing giants have 1 year bond. (E.g. TCS and Wipro) and if you break it you've to pay the company some amount. Also if you resign and don't want to serve the notice period, you can 'buy' your way out.
- edandersen 14y agoI hope the rest of the world doesn't get any ideas.
- mseebach 14y agoLike having your stock options to vest over a five year period? Also, in many many fields less meritocratic than software, you typically gain privileges as you accrue seniority with little regard to experience or actual contribution.
- edandersen 14y agoI meant having bonds on employment - imagine having to pay your employer when you quit because they had no idea what they were doing or flat out lied about what the job would entail? The thought is horrific.
- mseebach 14y ago
- FlyingSnake 14y agoI think the issue is three-fold 1. Baniya style businesses. Though the startup founders are young and fresh, the overall business environment still reeks age old business patterns. I know few startups who offer no equity, treat employees like 2nd class citizens and want to get rich quick without spending much. 2. A lot of talent is ignored. Everyone knows that the education system is inadequate for training engineers, but startups seldom train/intern students and bring them on par. There is a lot of latent talent apart from the Engineering graduates. Millions of students graduate as B.Sc.(Science/Maths) but I haven't heard any startup training/hiring them. Outsourcing giants like Cognizant/Infosys however are an exception but they hire, train and turn these non-engineering graduates into maintenance drones. 3. General apathy of students towards startups. Most of the students just want to earn money to be self sufficient. The easiest way? Follow the patterns of someone successful, mostly a person selected in outsourcing giants. These companies are a modern version of dusty Government offices and many people just log their time and get a paycheck. Art of computer programming is forgotten and everyone wants to be a Manager/Director is 5 years. This sets a wrong example for new guys and hurts the hacker culture. P.S. Many startups are doing good work (e.g. Infinitely Beta) and many will succeed, but these factors show why hiring is difficult for startups.
- vignesh_vs_in 14y agocouldnt agree more on point 1, on point 2: people with bsc degrees are treated as second class citizens of these BigCos, they even have separate policies for these employees.(Beleive me i was one of them).
- asto 14y ago1. Many founders in India found a "startup" just because they have money to capitalise it and nothing better to do. They have 0 tech skills and 0 management ability. The few startups that are doing well here are those founded by technical guys or people who've worked in a certain industry for a while and start a related venture. 2. Startups can't afford to train. They need programmers who'll hit the ground running. 3. Mostly because the startup scene here sucks; it's fucking comical I tell you. Join any indian startup forum and you'll know the story of how poor the quality of startups and their employees is. I leave you with an email I received recently from "OCC Bangalore" (google group for bangalore startups). Also, no offence intended to the few who really are running businesses worth running. ======================================================== Dear All, I need some tech help. We need to call these php functions in our jsp files. We can use javascript I hope. I searched alot on google and I found this: -- <script type="text/javascript"> function test(){ document.getElementById("php_code").innerHTML="<?php for($i=0; $i<10; $i++) echo $i; //maybe a function ?>"; } </script> <a href="#" style="display:block; color:#000033; font-family:Tahoma; font-size:12px;" onclick="test(); return false;"> test </a> <span id="php_code"> </span> -- But doesnot seem to be working. Some guys have suggested using this: jqSajax Background: We are trying to use an existing opensource solution which provides APIs and the same can be used through java and php. We want to use the same through our jsp files. Now part of it we have been able to use through the java webservices they provide, but since they are opensource platform they have missed implementing some of the code in java which is available in php services. Any ideas? Stuck now :( Thanks a lot
- ashishgandhi 14y agoI've worked at a couple of Indian "consultancy" firms and my experiences have been far from good. At the first one I automated some testing for them what would free up 3 people they were having to hire for that job. They didn't like it. Thats because they don't have to bear the cost associated with hiring them. It's the client who has to pay. By the person, by the hour and the company gets a (mega) huge cut from it. I'm not sure how such consultancy firms handle this conflict of interest else where but for Indian firms, I know anecdotally, this is very common. So there is no incentive to hire good programmers. Or do good programming because the server costs, etc. again are going to be borne by the client. And the second one, I was working at another such Indian consultancy firm bit out of Singapore this time. The company was run by the sales force. My manager's manager said in one of his speeches that "as the iPad becomes dual core it will replace servers." I looked at him as my dual core iPad 2 lay in my lap and clapped because that's what you have to do. And I'm pretty sure he didn't mean a P2P future of the web. My manger on the other hand wanted a "function" done that could take in an "iDevice program" and output a BlackBerry app. He wanted it done in 3 hours. My team could have been an isolated incident and I want to believe that but it wasn't so. The only thing my team was doing different than the rest of the organization was the rest of the organization used some form of source control I had never heard of. Probably Microsoft based as that was the decision criteria in all cases. Out team was using none. Files were shared using USB flash drives. There were instances where old employees had left and we didn't have the source of their work - only the binaries. They only hiring a particular ethic group of Indians by the time I left. Majority of jobs in India are consultancy jobs. They may not be as terrible as my last one but I would think they are half way there. Things may be changing but that's how most of "IT life" is.
- gaius 14y agoDominic Connor says the same thing http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2012/05/28/channel_techy/ http://www.channelregister.co.uk/2012/05/28/channel_techy/ A good employee wants to drive down costs and drive up revenue at his company. A consultant can only drive up revenue for his company by driving up costs at his clients. This is seems very obvious, but the existence of the consulting industry versus in-house employees suggests that it actually is not...
- jace 14y agoI'm the OP and I'm frankly humbled to see a 5 year old post trending today. What's changed in five years? For one, Bangalore has a real startup ecosystem now, with funded startups that pay market-level salaries and offer stock. This was rare in 2006.
- free 14y agoYes, I am in the startup ecosystem in Bangalore and I can definitely say that there are pockets of real talent here. In fact I feel lucky to be in a place where I am enjoying work, learning a ton and surrounded by some of the most talented people I have ever seen.
- kang 14y agoCare to name those 'pockets' please?
- free 14y agoThis link gives a better answer http://www.quora.com/What-are-the-hottest-startups-in-India http://www.quora.com/What-are-the-hottest-startups-in-India Amongst the ones I personally know Flipkart, Myntra and Cleartrip have some really good people. And then there are freelancers who work remotely for the bay area startups. Edit : If you are in Bangalore, then do attend the tech conferences here to get a better idea of the ecosystem.
- kamaal 14y agoWell as a note regarding outsourcing and Indian IT Bellwethers. I can tell you that you are likely to hear extreme management bashing in this case. But after personally working in a very famous IT bellwether here in India for 5 years, and now in another famous global web company. I can tell you half the people who crib, complain and whine are basically people who expect to get rich by 'getting lucky'. The most common complain is They didn't give me good stuff to work on, yet when you ask the same people what exactly stops them from downloading <insert their favorite programming language compiler/tool>, or why they didn't work on their favorite database while all of it is freely available on the internet- The answer is generally a blank stare. Tons of automation opportunities exist in almost all projects that these big companies take, yet most people you are likely to meet still expect work to be given to them. I have seen this attitude among all freshers and even among some very experienced people. The fact is most of these people arrive at a software industry after having the heard 'Get rich quick' stories from the 90's while somebody joined a IT services company, went to an foriegn onsite location for 5-6 years, became a manager in 4 years and made tons of money in the IPO. In fact most complaints of 'Indian IT sucks' generally smells of 'I could not get rich quick'. With no real desire to make a career in software, and waiting to jump to a management role at the earliest is the hallmark of Indian IT. Getting promotions and holding fancy designations is considered extremely honorable. Let alone most technical leads who managed to win corporate politics race, I know- Can't write a 100 line program. Not getting promoted to managerial role by 27 is considered a sign of incompetence, Not being able to go to a foriegn onsite location is considered a sign of incompetence. Its almost like a blind rush for money, money and only money. I know of many so called Technical leads who boast that they don't write code anymore, trying to imply that people who write code or who are good at tech stuff are generally incompetent people not deserving of progress. How do you expect to make progress or do anything big, with this kind of people stacked from top to down? After doing a lot of analysis, I have finally realized these people never wanted to be programmers ever. They have 0 interest in learning, building and making stuff. They don't have what it takes to make a career in software. These people just arrive at software companies thinking they will get rich very quickly, when they don't, they find every reason under the sun to justify how worse career options in software are. Those who do get rich by usual promotion->onsite cycles, generally go on to become managers and then ulitimately glorified supervisors, who seem to hold very high opinions about tech without knowing a jack about it. Regional and liguistic politics is too common, being the managers best man and bootlicking helps to get better appraisal ratings, promotions and onsite chances. Having said all this, I still meet some very good technical people from whom I learned a lot(In the same big companies). I continue to meet such people. As a last note, the rewards vs efforts system is all messed up and needs immediate fixing. These companies need to bring back meritocracy.
- jim_kaiser 14y agoI agree.. it's not easy to find good developers in India. I have come to understand the social circumstances which make them treat software development as just a job and not something to care about. The good developers cannot stand writing bad code and letting bad code go into production. The good developers look at code as an art form. But the crux is just to know how to attract the right talent.. referrals are a common way of getting good developers. But, there are many other ways to do that too, if the companies are willing to make the effort. I currently work for a cool norwegian offshore company which has a open and flexible work environment as do many of the international companies doing business here. They know how to hire. Most companies here in India have a notice period as part of the employment contract.. but it is ALWAYS both ways i.e. employer and employee both have to serve notice or payout. Some of the comments here suggest otherwise.. but that is purely hearsay or ignorance.