4 ms·
> Taxing the super-rich might be admirable from a jealousy point of view. It has nothing to do with jealousy and everything to do with fairness and limiting th
by JohnFen 2y ago
> Taxing the super-rich might be admirable from a jealousy point of view.
It has nothing to do with jealousy and everything to do with fairness and limiting the concentration of power.
- omnimike 2y agoMoney only gets you things when you spend it. Real power is how much money you have to spend, not the market cap of the companies you own. There’s a tired meme that billionaires are somehow more powerful than the politicians in charge of all the money.
- spacemadness 2y agoWhy did I expect anything other than HN defending billionaires when reading the comments. In the most naive way at that. As if billionaires aren’t influencing policy directly.
- omnimike 2y agoSorry, you misunderstand. I’m not defending billionaires, I’m condemning politicians. Politicians and policy should not be for sale in the first place. The fact that they are means, yes, rich people have more power to control policy, but the solution isn’t to ban rich people from getting rich. We need to ban money from influencing policy. Instead, the Supreme Court decided that money is speech and political corruption is protected by the first amendment. We need to undo that. The brain dead part are the people (apparently common on hacker news) who think that stopping people getting rich is a better solution than, for eg., campaign spending limits.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoHere[0] is a recent story of Texas billionaires who can more or less can pick the representatives they want Hours before the Texas House overwhelmingly voted to impeach Ken Paxton in May, a well-funded supporter of the attorney general issued a threat to his fellow Republicans. A vote to impeach Paxton, Jonathan Stickland wrote on Twitter, “is a decision to have a primary.” “Wait till you see my PAC budget,” he later added. Stickland is the leader of Defend Texas Liberty, a political action committee that has donated millions of dollars to far-right candidates in the state. It is a key part of the constellation of political campaigns, institutions and dark-money groups that a trio of West Texas oil tycoons — Tim Dunn and brothers Farris and Dan Wilks — have pumped small fortunes into as part of a long-term crusade to push Texas to the extreme right. [0] https://www.texastribune.org/2023/07/24/ken-paxton-impeachment-dunn-wilks/ https://www.texastribune.org/2023/07/24/ken-paxton-impeachme...
- snapplebobapple 2y agoIt does not accomplish that though. If you want to limit concentration of powrr actually use the antitrust laws and break these oligopolists and monopolists up. If you want to be fairrealizethat a dividend or capital gain was corporate income that was yaxed once already and to keep it equivalent to personal income it needs to be taxed substantially less when it becomes personal income (atleast up here in canada, fairness would involve cutting taxes on capital gains and dividends to makeit equivalent again). if anything, this accomplishes theopposite of what you want because the aspiring rich will het taxed to death and the old money will avoid most of this, calcifying the rich and everyone else divide.