4 ms·
These threads are absolutely cursed. They get vicious quickly. The patterns set up quick as Loctite glue, excluding all but dedicated partisans (and a few weird
by tptacek 3y ago
These threads are absolutely cursed. They get vicious quickly. The patterns set up quick as Loctite glue, excluding all but dedicated partisans (and a few weirdos like me), forming little anaerobic pockets of lactic acid poisoning any bud of curiosity, the core purpose of the site. And the threads go on for-ev-er. We had one run for over a week.
I'm not happy with this outcome. I could enjoy nerding out on the politics and diplomacy of the ICC. I think lots of people here have useful things to say about what's happening here. But I sure as shit flagged this story, because none of that will happen. It'll just be people yelling at each other endlessly.
There are other venues to have this conversation in. Doesn't have to be here.
- akira2501 3y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 3y agoPlease don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents, and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- akira2501 3y agoIt's not an insinuation it's an obvious fact of the world we live in. It's obvious to anyone who has used this site, or any other site, for any period of time. Of course I'm worried about abuse, as this site clearly has the ability to influence people, not just politically, but technically and socially as well. As I stated, just emailing you and hoping for the best is an entirely broken model which leaves users with no ability to detect this and quantify it for themselves or to share that information with the public who uses this site. HN itself offers no reports, no data, and no summaries about these actions or their outcomes. I'm genuinely surprised you thought this was a worthwhile response to the broader problem of user trust on public forums, or would waste a minute pretending that HN uniquely doesn't share in them.
- tptacek 3y agoEmailing me? I'm just some guy.
- akira2501 3y agoWould making that change in wording alter the point in any material way?
- tptacek 3y agoI'm just saying, nobody should be emailing me about shills on HN, because I can't do anything about it.
- loceng 3y agoDoes that mean you don't think shills are a significant-serious problem, or because you don't believe you can do anything about it then it's not important to you? E.g. If you consider it to be a problem, and there were possible solutions to shills on HN (and elsewhere), would you be interested in seeing those solutions implemented and/or tested? I think you're downplaying-minimizing your importance as an individual, and I'm not sure why you'd do that. Does downplaying it enable or justify it to yourself for what could be considered abdicating responsibility, so you can quell stress that otherwise would be felt if you took it seriously as a problem you would take on to help solving? Because it is a very difficult problem to solve for, and to some degree you're right, you as an individual - "just a guy on HN" - can't do much about it; and such conversations are essentially ban-heavily frowned upon on HN, e.g. not talking about downvotes, etc; because that discussion rarely happens in any deep and serious way on - like perhaps an annual topic posted and pinned by dang to get a deep dive to offer a chance to present their deep dive essays and concerns and perhaps proposed solutions, to perhaps help others understand the severity and seriousness of shills gaming our communication systems-channels and their effects on the development of society? And where such a planned annual event may create a beautiful frenzy to help tech people and others refine their understanding and proposed solutions?
- rendang 3y agoThat's fair, but there's a difference between 1) accusing the specific person you're responding to of being a shill or that everyone advocating a given position is a shill and 2) suggesting that HN as a forum in general is likely the target of influence campaigns that impact the quality of discussion
- loceng 3y agodang, I think perhaps a rule should be added for users to not engage in "guilt by association", e.g. tptacek elsewhere made a comment that they flag posts simply because they're afraid there will be low quality comments in them, rather than discerning. Good idea, bad idea, maybe idea?
- tptacek 3y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=users%20flag%20flamewar%20by%3Adang&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- loceng 3y agoCan you state your point along with sharing that link please? I can't read minds - and I lean away from making assumptions.
- tptacek 3y agoIt answers your question, which has come up many times before, directly. If you feel otherwise, email hn@ycombinator.com --- "@dang" (or equivalents) isn't a thing here, even in replies.
- loceng 3y agodang has that username because it's a rarely used word. And no, it doesn't answer my question - you seem to make assumptions a lot that people should be able to interpret things exactly how you expect them to; and you have the polar opposite behaviour as well of assuming what others mean when you're potentially wrongly interpreting. It's quite fascinating - and you'll assume I'm just wrong without caring to put effort into seeing if I have a valid point or not that could lead to growth.
- dj_mc_merlin 3y agoYou can make that claim about Reddit or other social networks but.. just read through this thread? It's pretty clear that this is just random people's uninformed opinions, fears and speculations. I don't see a single good argument besides the very easy to make and modest opinion that we're not sure what's going to happen exactly now, but it sure is interesting.
- Intralexical 3y agoThat's… A good reminder, actually. At best it's just some random guy. At worst it's a three letter agency's botnet. Maybe influence ops would be less realistic of a concern if we all put somewhat less stock in social media.
- feedforward 3y ago[flagged]
- catlikesshrimp 3y agopedantic offtopic: "forming little anaerobic pockets of lactic acid poison" Aerobic metabolism is actually worse than anaerobic metabolism. Anaerobic conditions tend to result in fermentation by fungi and other incomplete metabolism by bacteria. We even recycle lactic acid because it is energy rich. Aerobic metabolism has "toxic" results= CO2, Sulfur gases, Urea, phosphorous compounds. Very energy depleted molecules that only specialized organism can process. For anaerobic bacteria, Bacteroides and Clostridium come to mind. Everything else I can think of CAN thrive in aerobic conditions: Mycobacterium, Staphylococcus, Streptococcus, Escherichia , Salmonella...
- Intralexical 3y agoThe "toxic" metabolites aren't a sustainability problem though as long as the ecosystem forms closed cycles. Presumably it even helps biodiversity. Generally I'd probably judge metabolism mostly based on power density and energy availability. How does anaerobic compare on that front? Though archaea tend to be anaerobic, and we should obviously all strive to be more like archaea, so maybe you have a point…
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoThat's why I flag em. They never lead to fruitful discussion even though I wish it would! I think though it's possible it would require way too much moderation- the juice ain't worth the squeeze.
- loceng 3y agoIt's really interesting you're willing to and do preemptively apply guilt by association to everyone (by flagging) instead of downvoting/flagging specific comments, suppressing the whole conversations. It's Minority Report you're engaging in, no? Have you thought about this before? Do you apply guilt by association in your thinking in other places in your life? I'm seriously curious if you've self-reflected on this - and it's not intended as an attack or putdown of any sort. Why not allow the "lots of people here have useful things to say about what's happening here" and allow the "low quality" comments be suppressed-flagged? One problem though is we have people who apply guilt by association to everyone downvoting anything they interpret however they likely with bias interpret - but you believe you're competent enough to make that judgement call, to be "judge, jury and execution" instead of perhaps just not engaging in threads that bother you too much to filter through?