3 ms·
Will this run locally, or is part of the work outsourced? With "Recall", can law enforcement ask your laptop "Has your user done anything suspicious lately"?
by Animats 2y ago
Will this run locally, or is part of the work outsourced?
With "Recall", can law enforcement ask your laptop "Has your user done anything suspicious lately"?
- Hamuko 2y agoCan I call an AI expert as my witness to explain what "hallucination" is?
- soapdog 2y agoCoverage on Windows Central says it is all local. As for the law enforcement question, it doesn't matter. If they want to get info from your computer, they will and they don't need AI to help.
- mlindner 2y ago> As for the law enforcement question, it doesn't matter. If they want to get info from your computer, they will and they don't need AI to help. This is a poor take. Law enforcement needs a warrant to seize your computer to get your data normally. Law enforcement only needs a compliant and willing corporate person to willingly give over your data to law enforcement. It's about who owns it and where is it located and the protections around it.
- croes 2y agoGetting a warrant isn't that hard either.
- milkshakes 2y agogetting a warrant requires probable cause, and a judge to approve it. maybe that's not hard, maybe it is, but i'd personally prefer more steps being required to access what data i have.
- bitwize 2y agoIndeed. It's the difference between already having substantive reason to believe you committed a crime, and surveilling you willy-nilly looking for a crime to pin on you. The less arbitrary access law enforcement has to your data, the more difficult the latter becomes.
- freedomben 2y agoExactly. There are some judges that will rubber stamp warrants without even looking at them closely, but there are still plenty who don't and there's a paper trail as well that provides some protections. When you just go to where no warrant is required, it won't make a difference when the police want to get a specific person, but it will make a big difference on whether they are able to surveil wide swathes of the population and how easy it all is for them.
- croes 2y agoIn Germany it's the same in theory, in reality even bogus causes are approved by the judges who neither the time and knowledge to really check the inquiry.
- __loam 2y agoIn the United States, protection from unlawful search and seizure has been in our constitution since the very beginning through the fourth amendment. This is a critical component of what we believe are human rights, so we will continue to insist that law enforcement should "get a fuckin warrant" if they want to dig through our personal data, regardless of your opinion on how easily that warrant will be granted.
- matheusmoreira 2y ago> If they want to get info from your computer, they will and they don't need AI to help. They wouldn't be continuously trying to ban encryption worldwide if that was true. There's plenty of things everyone can do to protect themselves.
- EasyMark 2y agoI mean you can encrypt and refuse (forget?) the password in the USA, but there's really not much else. Judges (at least here in Texas) give out warrants like they're America Online (TM) CD's and the state attorney general is a well-known "alleged" grifter. It's looking real bad for the 4th amendment in the USA, it's on the ropes and has been especially since the Patriot Act kicked off a lot of police anti-constitutional actions.
- gigel82 2y agoThey made a big deal of saying how private and secure it is, all running locally. However, nothing prevents that from changing in the future. And for the law enforcement, I presume if they can log into your account, they can likely extract and view everything if you have the feature enabled.
- pompino 2y ago>can law enforcement ask your laptop "Has your user done anything suspicious lately"? The logging already exists. Whether the interface is AI or a command line tool is not so interesting. Besides the "suspicious" stuff has other touch points like Google, ISPs, AWS, etc, etc. Those logs have been easy to get a hold of (with legal backing) - historically speaking.
- nerdjon 2y agoEven if it is run locally, does it sync between your devices? Considering we seem to be putting safety largely out the window, I can see someone saying "yeah I want to be able to ask my other computer what I did on a different computer" or whatever. Thats valuable! Ignoring the risks that involves. Also, even if it is run locally that likely means that some sort of additional logging (possibly screenshots given the mention of "photographic memory") on top of what is already in the system logs to achieve this. Windows 11 LTSC, which will hopefully have these features ripped out, can't come soon enough.
- WillAdams 2y agoWindows 11, if one has OneDrive turned on backs _everything_ up in terms of data/files. I bought a second computer recently which was the same as my Samsung Galaxy Book 3 Pro 360 --- after setting up Windows I found that it had downloaded _all_ of my files onto the new computer, but the wallpaper wasn't the same --- went to my old one, figured out where the file was and copied it to the desktop. While I was trying to figure out how I'd copy the file over, the file appeared on the desktop of my new computer.
- wkat4242 2y agoWell to be fair it's a setting you can choose in the OneDrive app. You don't have to do this.
- MangoCoffee 2y agoLocally, it is supposed to take advantage of the new "NPU" that comes with Intel/AMD
- richdougherty 2y agoA few details here: "Recall leverages your personal semantic index, built and stored entirely on your device. Your snapshots are yours; they stay locally on your PC. You can delete individual snapshots, adjust and delete ranges of time in Settings, or pause at any point right from the icon in the System Tray on your Taskbar. You can also filter apps and websites from ever being saved. You are always in control with privacy you can trust." https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2024/05/20/introducing-copilot-pcs/ https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2024/05/20/introducing-copi...
- J_Shelby_J 2y agoThat didn’t answer the ops question. Are they encrypted? Can Microsoft access them if compelled by law enforcement?