6 ms·
Child Care Is More Expensive Than Rent for the Average American Family
- School-Cotton 3y agoI genuinely have no idea what working single parents with low income do for childcare given how outrageously expensive it seems to be nowadays. Is it subsidized for people with very low family income, or are those people just screwed? And if they are indeed screwed, what, concretely do they do?
- azinman2 3y agoThey rely heavily on family and friends
- secstate 3y agoWhich, if we're being honest, is not inherently a bad thing. I know people who worry about how much they lean on the grandparents for help, but then walking it back two generations, that's kinda, sorta how it always was. It's hard for American's to understand sometimes, but no man is an island, and it's okay to not be fiercely independent and have fuck-you money for everything. Sometimes you're gonna just have to depend on other people to help you.
- azinman2 3y agoIt’s very situational. Not everyone has this option, or this option isn’t reliable or available daily, and often times people end up not working because child care is so expensive.
- xp84 3y agoCompletely screwed, mostly. Unless they come from a culture with very strong extended family and thus have grandparents, uncles and aunties, etc. who help for free. and they specifically make sure to live all close together.
- balls187 3y agoChildcare is just one of the ways low-income people (single or not) are "screwed."
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoThey are screwed. But this isn’t why - even with high enough income it would not be great as a sole parent. Raising children is incredibly difficult - a lot more difficult than people think until they go through it themselves. That’s if you have two parents with high paying jobs. Even if you have the funds to hire help, outsourcing your children isn’t exactly great. Children need their parents, not just a rotating set of random caretakers who don’t have the same skin in the game. In reality, what’s happening is that most parents are letting one aspect or the other go, in order to make it all work. If you are a single parent with low income, you have to let go of a lot of things where it is guaranteed to result in severe neglect of the child. Having a child at all in that situation is honestly something like a crime against the child. Even in the best conditions, it’s not going to be great for them.
- alephnerd 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoWhat is with this phenomenon of services getting more expensive in real terms (health care, tuition, child care, pet care) while also delivering a worse experience? AFAIK, for all of these industries, this has nothing to do with pension obligations. And at least for child care, demand should be going down relative to the population given that less people are having less kids. So it can't be a simple demand thing.
- alephnerd 3y ago> AFAIK, for all of these industries, this has nothing to do with pension obligations. They do, indirectly. All those PE, IB, and VC funds people rail about are overwhelmingly funded by pension funds *, and all the industries mentioned are increasingly consolidating due to regulatory overhead, pushing solo practitioners out (eg. lots of older MD friends selling their practices to consolidated funds because they don't want to deal with paperwork and billing). As more and more Americans retire and have inflated expectations of retirement, funds need to return much more. ------- * State+Local Pension funds in the US have $6 Trillion AUM [0] (it would be the 3rd largest economy in the world on its own). Federal Pension funds is around $1 Trillion AUM [1] (it would be the 20rd largest economy in the world on its own). And all the 401k funds combined would be $7.4 Trillion AUM [2] (it would be the 3rd largest economy in the world on its own). This is just American funds. Other countries pension funds invest in the US as well. [0] - https://www.nasra.org/content.asp?admin=Y&contentid=200 https://www.nasra.org/content.asp?admin=Y&contentid=200 [1] - https://www.opm.gov/about-us/reports-publications/agency-plans/fy-2024-congressional-budget-justification/earned-benefits-trust-funds/ https://www.opm.gov/about-us/reports-publications/agency-pla... [2] - https://www.ici.org/401k https://www.ici.org/401k
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere are multiple reasons. For one, dealing with people and their animals is high liability. It is also generally unpleasant to deal with the general public day in and day out, especially sick and stressed out ones, so the work is undesirable. > demand should be going down relative to the population given that less people are having less kids It is demand for labor relative supply of the labor. If the supply is going down quicker, then the demand going down is not going to make prices go down. Bottom line is that in previous generations, people who took care of infants/toddlers (including older siblings, neighborhood kids, grandparents, etc) either did it under a situation with less liability, or they had less opportunity costs (lower wages than today’s workers), and/or did it at a “lower quality” than legal staffing minimums for daycare businesses.
- CincinnatiMan 3y agoThere aren’t really any ways to make 1 adult caring for 4 babies more efficient. Maybe robots eventually? Also, I really hope legislation doesn’t come about that further encourages outsourced childcare rather than a stay-at-home-parent. Ideally any benefits to parents are equitable regardless of the parents’ choice in their form of childcare.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> There aren’t really any ways to make 1 adult caring for 4 babies more efficient. By definition, efficiency is going down, if real costs are going up, though... That's the problem.
- blackeyeblitzar 3y agoThe article is paywalled so I can’t read more than the intro. Personally, I think there are several factors in child care getting more expensive. For one, parent’s expectations are higher. It’s really hard to take care of many kids at once, and if the ratio of workers to children at a childcare center is too high, some kids end up being ignored or neglected rather than being actively taken care of. Parents are more sensitive to that now. Another factor is urbanization - there are more people living in places with high cost of living, and the childcare businesses simply have more expenses. It’s also difficult to have a lot of consumer choice in these areas. In a suburban or rural area, sure you can easily drive to a childcare business that’s further away. But in a city that travel can take away several hours a week (even if by car) and so you have to go with whatever is located near you. If you rely on transit, forget it - lugging a child and their essentials (think car seat, stroller, diaper bags, etc) is incredibly difficult. Another issue is different social habits and increasing isolation. People don’t live in multi generation homes anymore, so there are no grandparents to rely on. And since the economy is increasingly concentrated in cities, people move away from family for jobs. And people are less willing to inconvenience friends by asking for help watching their kids, even though this was normal only a couple decades back. So the reliance on paid care is much higher now. Finally, we’ve normalized dual income families. Increasing the supply of workers this way hasn’t helped us - since obviously supply of labor pushes down wages and in the end you don’t come out ahead. But it does mean there isn’t someone at home to take care of the kids. I don’t think there is a great fix. On the one hand you could subsidize child care heavily in order to ensure a thriving population, but I also think there is truth to the financial cost being a good filter for those who are in a good position to be a parent and those who aren’t. This doesn’t stop people in a bad position from having kids though, so the question is if it is fair to take away from some parents (through taxes) to help other parents’ kids instead? I think that’s a difficult thing for people to accept.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> Another factor is urbanization - there are more people living in places with high cost of living, and the childcare businesses simply have more expenses. Unless those people are living outside the city and sending their kids to daycare in the city (unlikely) that would be reflected in the rent price (the denominator).
- voakbasda 3y agoI am approaching 50 and never had kids. A decade ago, I lost my entire life savings to a gold digging fraud, and I ended up deep into debt for the first time in my life just to save my farmstead. I am still climbing out of that hole. I had to restart my retirement plans from scratch, but I still have almost nothing saved. That should start to change in another couple of years, but it will be too little and too late to make much of a dent. I may yet lose my farm. A few years ago, I married a younger woman, and we have talked about having kids. While that's something that I have wanted for decades, the costs of having and raising children are now so significant that I would be unable to save anything for retirement. This article only seems to confirm that assessment. Being in tech, I expect to be pushed out of the workforce well before retirement age, before my hypothetical kids even would be ready to go off to college. Of course, I would be unable to afford to save anything to help pay for their school either, putting them at a relative disadvantage. I don't want to disappoint my wife, but I don't believe that we can afford to have even one kid. This has been one of the most painful realizations in my adult life, and it has made me incredibly bitter and resentful.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoSorry to hear about your situation. I don’t know that pain but I know it is painful for people I know that want kids but can’t have them for various reasons. In your case, since it is an economic decision, I do wonder if there are ways to get around it. Could one of you leave your job to take care of kids full time? For many people the net income from working (after taxes after child care etc) is not worth being away from their kids, and often it is even a strictly better financial decision to stay home when you do the math. But if you both are earning enough in your jobs where that would not be the case, I wonder if you’re actually earning enough but overestimating the costs of taking care of a kid? Remember they have ways of getting aid for college and they can also work to put themselves through college - or take cheaper routes like community college before regular college (assuming you’re in the US). I don’t know your whole situation of course, so apologies if this is naive or offensive.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoThe subsidized day care program in Quebec is calculated to have paid for itself. The increased tax revenue from the increase in the number of working women more than paid for the outlays to the day care subsidies. : P. Fortin, L. Godbout and S. St-Cerny, Papers in Political Economy, No. 47, 2013