5 ms·
We are a step closer to taxing the super-rich
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bagels 3y agohttps://archive.ph/XNFug https://archive.ph/XNFug
- croes 3y agoIs this case only seeing is believing. The billionaires will fight with all they have to prevent it.
- nasmorn 3y agoAt least the lawyers get something
- nineplay 3y agoHot take: If I was super rich I'd rather put my money in my own charities where I can control how the money is managed and where it goes. If I hand it over to the Federal government, a lot of it will probably go to programs I fundamentally opposed. Not to say that the super-rich shouldn't pay any more in taxes, I'm not really qualified to say. But these populistic initializes are mostly smoke and mirrors. They aren't going to work, and if they did work they aren't going to make as much difference as people hope.
- xbpx 3y agoCounter take: This hot take is unnecessarily defeatist and smacks of the rote defense for maintaining the current power structure, namely "the world is too complicated maybe we shouldn't try". I'd like to mention that we had significantly higher corporate, inheritance and income taxes in the 40s to 70s and it absolutely did moderate growth of billionaire wealth. If such a thing is implemented in some form by all, or even most, major global national entities it could have a very positive impact on future global development. It won't be perfect but we only need to work to improve. And currently having billionaires control trillions leaves much to improve upon.
- chucksta 3y agoI guess it comes down to how one answers the question - do taxes exist to support the country and its means, or enforce economic distribution with the benefit to social welfare?
- iwontberude 3y agoCold take: If I was super rich, I wouldn't be in any better position to spend it on behalf of other people than the government. Who the fuck am I?
- coffeebeqn 3y agoAnd whose best interest would a random billionaire have at heart ?
- jpn 3y agoBecause people are more careful spending their own money than other people's money.
- iwontberude 2y agoI don't think that is remotely true. I think they are just as irresponsible.
- apatheticonion 3y agoAs someone not super rich, this is already a problem and is fundamental to the operation of a functional democracy. If everyone could allocate their tax dollars as they saw fit, then we would not see funding for issues that don't affect the largest contributors - like universal healthcare, subsidised female sanitary products, public education and transport. For better or for worse, a subscription to a balanced well-managed democratic system requires financial contribution AND political participation. For instance, if you're ultra wealthy and believe in the right for women to seek abortion, vote that way and convince others to do so as well. Charities are often a hidden form of tax evasion rather than a means to allocate funds to causes an individual believes in (though there are certainly exceptions). That said, if we are talking about the USA, that's not an great example of a well functioning democratic system - it's rated internationally as a "flawed democracy" (sharing that rating with South Africa, India, Malaysia). If a super rich US citizen wanted to improve the allocation of their tax contributions, best bang-for-their-buck would be campaigning for electoral reform. ... or just change their tax residency to a country that offers a lower tax rate
- xboxnolifes 3y agoHow is this a hot take? Not wanting to give money to the government is practically the fundamental human condition.
- mhuffman 3y agoWhat is worse is that if you dig deep into current government spending the money has a strange way of ending back up in super-rich people's pockets anyway, just with extra steps.
- adingus 3y agoGreat. The super rich can and should donate their after tax money to the charities of their choosing. The rest of us should work on creating efficient and effective government programs so that tax dollars go to where we vote them to. I'm curious but why do you think you're not qualified to say the rich shouldn't pay more, but still feel qualified to say these programs are diversions that won't do any good?
- throwaway22032 3y agoAs someone who isn't super-rich but is relatively wealthy I already do this. Taxation in my country is almost entirely focused on redistribution of wealth (mostly to cronies, occasionally to proles) whilst the actually meaningful roles of government (as opposed to anarchy) like law and order, defence, border controls etc are neglected. There's always some pet project. Lower in the thread someone is going on about subsidising female sanitary products, a complete boondoggle. Not only is it a trivial expense, the average man eats 10-20% more food so you could just net out the costs and just not move the money. Even having a committee research that sort of thing is a waste, but it's just all over the place.
- rakoo 3y ago> If I was super rich I'd rather put my money in my own charities where I can control how the money is managed and where it goes spoiler alert: this is already what is happening. You don't get and remain rich by putting your money in taxable accounts. > They aren't going to work and if they did work they aren't going to make as much difference as people hope. Considering how many people live paycheck to paycheck, can't properly house themselves, or just enjoy one week off in the year, considering how crappy the train infrastructure in the US is, considering the mountain of problems around, I fail to see how a better redistribution of riches doesn't do anything.
- cosmotic 3y agoIf we are spending money for the good of the people, maybe the people should have a say in what it's spent on.
- martindbp 2y agoI know this is controversial, but here's my take: self made rich people live in reality. Whatever ideas they have about reality will be tested relentlessly, otherwise they wouldn't have succeeded at business. Government bureaucrats however do not live in reality. They live in lala-land where they spend other people's money. Who knows how they got to the point where they can make the choice of how money and resources are spent, but whatever it is, the actions they take is never really checked against reality. There is no competition between government agencies where badly run ones are allowed to fail. For that reason alone, self made rich people are on average much better at spending money wisely, as we've seen with for example the Gates foundation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Gys 3y agoTaxing the super-rich might be admirable from a jealousy point of view. But I do not think it will change any government spending capacity. Some numbers for the US. The richest 400 people owned a total of 4.5 Trillion USD in 2023 [0]. The US federal spending in 2022 was 6.3 T [1]. The CBO projects a federal budget deficit of $1.6 T for 2024. Beware this is only federal level, not including spending and debt of individual states. Government budgets are mind boggling. Even taking all the assets of the richest people in the world (meaning nationalizing most companies) would only temporarily make a noticeable dent in government spending. Taxing them will make no difference. For most other countries these taxes will be even less relevant. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/chasewithorn/2023/10/03/the-2023-forbes-400-list-of-richest-americans-facts-and-figures/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/chasewithorn/2023/10/03/the-202... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stvltvs 3y agoFederal taxes aren't about funding spending, no matter how much politicians and pundits say otherwise. State and local budgets are different, but since the federal government literally prints its own money, its budget isn't limited by how much they take in from taxes. Inflation is the real limit. Taxing the ultra rich makes sense to me with the aim of preventing concentration of wealth though.
- chucksta 3y agoThe US Federal government at best technically, not literally, prints its own money. The Fed is an independent organization with US Federal oversight. It is responsible for the call to issue more money but a government body prints it. https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/041515/why-federal-reserve-independent.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/041515/why-f...
- balderdash 3y agoWhat should the distribution of tax burden look like? People like to bandy about words like “fair share” but does that really mean? I’m not saying that billionaires shouldn’t pay more, but I just don’t understand what the framework is to determine if they should, and how much?
- ninthcat 3y agoFor those who believe that billionaires are a policy failure, the answer is they should be taxed more to the point that there are no more billionaires.
- zrn900 2y agoThis was a no-brainer: In every modern country, there are laws that limit land ownership because if someone owns more than a certain amount of land, that land can amount to a self-sufficient small country and the owner becomes a de facto feudal lord. Moreover, he or she would have the legal right to declare independence or autonomy in many cases. So to protect the principle that sovereignty belongs to the people, we limited land ownership a long time ago. But a loophole was left behind: The former aristocrats and the new capitalists who joined their class could own unlimited amounts of stocks, therefore they could own a majority of the countries' economies among themselves, through the control that they exercise via the ownership of said organizations. And here we are today, a dozen or so people owning more wealth than half of the world, a few thousand more owning even more, and worse, controlling entire economies. Its way past time that such feudal ownership was limited. And it will be good even for those ultra rich: Now they can feel that they attained an actual goal, get celebrated as having 'hit the ceiling', and can move on from that specific activity to another without suffering from obsessive-compulsive hoarding disorder.
- banish-m4 2y agoVenice figured it out eventually: beware when private edifices rival the states'.