4 ms·
That isn't free. For every terabit of bandwidth, you have to physically build out a terabit of network. Not even remotely free. Having already built the network
by immibis 3y ago
That isn't free. For every terabit of bandwidth, you have to physically build out a terabit of network. Not even remotely free. Having already built the network, and being already paying to run it, you can then use it for free, yes.
This is the model for all networks, indeed, most businesses - they pay a big upfront and moderate recurring cost to make a fast network (or restaurant or widget factory) and then sell it in slices with a large freedom to choose a pricing model. Pay per terabyte is a pretty reasonable way to pass on the network's fixed cost to consumers, just like part of the cost of the restaurant meal covers the interior decorations, even though the decorations don't actually cost more the more people eat, until the restaurant gets so busy it needs to expand.
- rahimnathwani 3y ago> For every terabit of bandwidth, you have to physically build out a terabit of network. A lot of the content will be cached at/near the edge. I imagine a lot of time is spent watching popular videos.
- vel0city 3y agoCached with what? The $0 cost hardware you gave to the ISP for free? You expect every ISP is just going to give you free CDN services?
- rahimnathwani 3y agoI didn't say it's free of cost. My point is that a terabit of bandwidth delivered to consumers in a particular geographical area doesn't require a terabit of bandwidth from the center to that area, because much of the content can be cached. So the 'terabit of network' the content provider needs to build need only span a few hundred feet within a single building.
- immibis 3y agoI never said it did. You still have to build whatever you want. A terabit of edge network is a terabit of edge network that has to be physically built. Not all networks are the same. Some have terabit backbones and gigabit edges, some have the reverse. We'd still call both of them, roughly, terabits of network, and you still have to build them. The one with the terabit core might actually be easier because you have less of the expensive really fast equipment.
- rahimnathwani 3y agoOK I don't think we're disagreeing on any factual point. The only point I wanted to make is that the 'terabit of network' doesn't have to be end to end, so it's not as scary as it may sound.
- immibis 2y agoIn some ways it's less scary: no long inter-site fiber runs that I assume are an absolute nightmare, and no renting those same runs at exorbitant rates. All your hands-on work remains in the datacenter, which is set up to make it a breeze. In other ways it's more scary: you have to negotiate with a lot more counterparties and visit a lot more datacenters.