5 ms·
I'm really surprised the iPad Pro isn't the thing people want: a tablet-computer. Honestly, this is the perfect tool for both many people in tech as well as th
by godelski 2y ago
I'm really surprised the iPad Pro isn't the thing people want: a tablet-computer.
Honestly, this is the perfect tool for both many people in tech as well as the average person. I have a macbook air, why not a pro? Because I need a glorified ssh machine that can do word processing, I can carry around light weight, has long battery life, and I can do some basic coding on. Everything else is done upstream on a compute platform. For the average person, they're doing the same non-compute tasks as me: browsing the internet and some word processing or slide making.
So why don't I have a device that I can basically run MacOS on and have a detachable keyboard (yes, I know these are sold). Apple should be able to corner this market, but they continually seem to fall flat on their face. Why did it take so long for the fucking iPad to have a natively supported app to markup PDFs. And why is it still terrible? Isn't that one of the most common use cases? I swear, tablet makers don't seem to actually understand how people use tablets nor laptops and it is really hindering their ability to innovate.
The iPad's greatest weakness is that its developers are trying to stuff a phone into a computer while being neither.
- lemonwaterlime 2y ago> I'm really surprised the iPad Pro isn't the thing people want: a tablet-computer. Because people also want a faster horse, not a car. The iPad has been developing its own identity and language as a product category. Yes, it takes a while to iterate on the features. But Apple clearly sees the iPad as a chance to develop a language for how to interact with a tabula rasa. The easy thing would be to just slap a desktop OS on it. How do we get any better as a species if we do that? The iPad does need something, yes. It does not need a desktop OS.
- Boatfaceing 2y agoDo any better as a species? Jesus fucking christ get a grip.
- talldayo 2y ago> How do we get any better as a species if we do that? By providing people what they want and incentivizing businesses to create something superior to it so that the demand for the prior solution goes away? If the new solution isn't competitive with the old one then we arguably aren't improving as a species anyways.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoCould you steel man what the iPad identity is supposed to be? It feels like mixing idioms of a production (desktop) and a consumption device (mobile) and flailing at both. Not targeting a unique niche.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vundercind 2y agoHow is mobile a “consumption” device?
- talldayo 2y agoAt least the way Apple treats it, mobile operating systems are where user capabilities go to die. You know all the professional software, on your desktop? Avid Pro Tools, Ableton Live, Adobe Premiere, Blender, that stuff? It doesn't run on iPad; not just because the developers are stingy and don't want to make a native version, but because the iPad is fundamentally limited in what it's software can provide relative to Mac. On top of that, you cannot distribute software yourself which relegates you exclusively to using Apple's provided runtime and storefront. It's an insular system that prevents new and exciting features or experiences from getting made without Apple's express approval and profit. Or look at games. The iPad should be giving the Steam Deck a run for it's money; you've got a great GPU, strong single-core CPU performance and a big punchy display up front. Instead of playing Fallout: New Vegas (like any respectable person should be able to do in 2024), you're replaying Monument Valley and Angry Birds HD for the billionth time. Or maybe you just get frustrated trying to set up Delta or UTM and go watch House of Cards in resigned frustration. The Mac is headed the same way, but at least there's a core audience of vocal whistleblowers pushing back against pointless software limitations. Apple is desperate to crush any methods of content creation or consumption that does not directly benefit them. To that end they have avoided adding professional features to their mobile devices to reinforce the content consumption loop and artificially inflate demand for the Mac.
- 2y ago
- ChildOfChaos 2y agoThe Problem is though, iPadOS is basically iOS, there isn't much difference. So it's basically a phone with a bigger screen.
- jadbox 2y agoI prefer desktop, if only for one reason- no app store lock-in. iPadOS will always be second fiddle until the app gatekeeping comes down.
- giancarlostoro 2y agoIf they made a Mini Pro, I'd be lining up for one. I want a sleek, high end 8" or less tablet that is top tier. I guess the last one that matched that spec was the Nvidia Shield, and sadly nobody else made one as insanely brilliant as that tablet.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- foolfoolz 2y agobecause the form factor of a laptop is better for typing. detachable key boards are awkward to carry and set up. also lots of computer tasks require very precise clicks that mice do better with. touchscreens really need another interface and the keyboard only solves some of the issues. a solution here is to carry a stylus.. but if you’re walking around with a ipad, a key board, and a stylus, the laptop is simpler
- godelski 2y ago> because the form factor of a laptop is better for typing. detachable key boards are awkward to carry and set up. I think you miss the setup. The keyboard is for being on the go. If I'm at a desk, I'm using my mechanical keyboard, not my shitty laptop one. Yeah, macs are better than most, but a laptop keyboard is still a laptop keyboard.
- x3sphere 2y agoThey should just unlock the iPad's virtualization capabilities. That would let power users run a desktop OS without them really needing to support it. Also I don't particularly care how any of the touch stuff works in a hypothetical desktop mode as long as I can hook it up to external display with KB+mouse.
- walterbell 2y agoThey can hide the option in Accessibility settings for those who speak CLI.
- weikju 2y agohaha imagine the manufactured outrage when "developer tools access" or "CLI access" is hidden under _Accessibility_ (It's a pretty clever idea though)
- librasteve 2y agothis … vftools is great on a mac … or even just support the mac Docker app
- dansiemens 2y ago> why don't I have a device that I can basically run MacOS on and have a detachable keyboard I think the answer is market cannibalization. Apple would much rather sell you both an iPad and a MacBook Pro rather than just an iPad.
- pama 2y agoIt is not yet a glofiried ssh machine, so that is an 80% no when it comes to work hardware for me. But give me a docking station with my homemade keyboard, fancy monitor, mike, and headphones, and let me use the GNU toolchain locally to get a decent terminal and Emacs and I would be a happy camper. The macbooks managed to hit those points, but the iPad feels totally disconnected from this type of glorified terminal mentality… unfortunately.
- godelski 2y ago> It is not yet a glofiried ssh machine I'm saying that my macbook air is a glorified ssh machine and word processing machine. But clearly it would be better to walk around with a tablet (with detachable keyboard) as a glorified ssh and word processing/slide making machine than a macbook. I want to be able to do some minimal work, walk around with my device and pull up slides (that I can fucking markup with my pencil -- not a glorified pointer), pull up docs, and etc because even though I'm mostly living in the cli I still have to show and communicate my work with others.
- pama 2y agoFully agreed.
- DavideNL 2y ago> "Why did it take so long for the fucking iPad to have a natively supported app to markup PDFs. And why is it still terrible? Isn't that one of the most common use cases? I swear, tablet makers don't seem to actually understand how people use tablets" Because this is how Apple nudges/forces people to spend money on a 3th-party app for a $xx/month subscription (of which even Apple gets 30%), obviously...