4 ms·
Google Is About to Change Everything–and Hopes You Won't Find Out
- medler 2y ago> Per Ray, the changes Google has been making seem to have most affected global websites with lots of inline ads and affiliate revenue links for e-commerce, because those are indicated as being more spammy This part sounds good to me. I’ve been waiting ages for Google to crack down on affiliate spam.
- scotty79 2y agoProbably google ads are excluded from this. And facebook ads and anyone else who could successfully sue them.
- lupire 2y agoIt there a coherently written article about whatever this blog post is rambling about?
- paxys 2y agoTL;DR – Blogspam site is complaining about the fact that Google is going to start penalizing blogspam.
- malux85 2y agoMy usage of Google has dropped dramatically in the last few months, with ChatGPT and Claude answering 80% of my questions with astronomically better answers now that it has context of what I’m doing. Google really really screwed up by missing this, now their clumsy catchup methods reek of desperation and internal chaos. Google is dead, now the decline and wither
- simfree 2y agoGoogle knowingly made their search results shittier and shittier for years in pursuit of improved KPIs, to the point that alternative search engines are better, and so are LLMs that occasionally hallucinate or outright crash.
- _boffin_ 2y agoWhat KPIs in specific?
- j45 2y agoA primary KPI is revenue. Revenue comes from ads. So making paid ad results more relevant for the click, than ensuring high quality organic search. Maybe, the more valuable the paid ads, the worse the organic rankings.
- taskforcegemini 2y agomy guess is they did something to cut costs by making each search less ressource intensive. I would pay to have google search behave as it used to. nowadays it seems to ignore most of what I try to tell it to look for, and instead shows what it "thinks" most other people probably mean.
- zingelshuher 2y ago> Google knowingly made their search results shittier and shittier for years unfortunately this extends to youtube too. now they have a new shitty trick. you click on the link and they randomly give you a completely different video.
- verdverm 2y agoChatGPT and Claude are going to find it difficult to compete with Google, MSFT, and Meta longterm, who are rolling out their AI capabilities to billions of users. The aforementioned started from zero and we know most people will choose the default provided. With MSFT owning half of OpenAI, I suspect it is only a matter of time before ownership officially changes.
- j45 2y agoIt's possible for sure, as the big guys flip too soon into commercializing, while the smaller or open-sized guys are becoming more and more efficient for similar results, they are also targets to be partnered with or acquired. Compute being a huge demand is a part truth, and also part PR. If we look at open source models, are many not improving.. and needing fewer and fewer resources (say compute) for better and better results?
- verdverm 2y agoGoogle Cloud Vertex AI let's you run any of the open source models on Google infra, they even have Claude models available. MSFT likely has similar in their cloud. Where are people going to run their models? I for one will choose the cloud I already use. It has APIs for the big models and simple deployment of both open source and other proprietary models. This is completely separate from providing end users a service. How many people self host or run their own alternatives when there are managed services available? It is unlikely people are going to switch en mass to open source models, especially while there is a price war on SoTA models. It's becoming far cheaper to call a SoTA API than have an always on open source model. From my experience, running a small model locally was both slower (tokens/sec plus overall system slowdown) and had worse results. I switched to cloud based APIs and will likely not consider reversing this decision. Multiple orders of magnitude improvements would need to happen in both performance and quality
- zingelshuher 2y ago> It is unlikely people are going to switch en mass to open source models It depends on the task at hands. For complex tasks no way personal computer can compete with giants data centers. But, as soon as software becomes available, users will gladly switch to local AI for personal data search / classification / summation, etc. This market is potentially huge, for private sensitive there is no other way.
- dzhiurgis 2y agoBing, ddg, brave - all of them have better ui and serve same results minus obnoxious ads. Really no reason to use google search anymore.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- manchmalscott 2y agoI was actually looking for the “web” filter today as I got the generative experience for the first time, and it wasn’t there. Once it does roll out though I’ll be keeping an eye out for a user script that auto switches to that filter. I can’t stand generative AI and I want it out of my damn search.
- dcreater 2y agoJust more reason to stop using Google. I've switched to other search engines for over a year now
- manchmalscott 2y agoCan I asked what you’ve used? I was trying out Kagi for a while but it seems like they’ve been pivoting to focusing on their own GPT and putting GenAI summaries in the search feed. I’m currently defaulting to DDG but the search results are so poor half the time I usually end up banging to Google anyways.
- Zeyka 2y agoBrave search has been really good imo, they do also try to integrate AI but it's not as bad as Google.
- viraptor 2y agoKagi isn't really pushing the generative stuff, or any specific features. If you don't like the summaries, you can turn them off (I think the one you mean is settings, search, more, Summary Box). You can turn off basically all the extras beyond just the titles and links.
- jbaber 2y agoI'm similarly cranky about AI generated search results, but the kagi ones have clickable citations. Those citations are great results.
- dcreater 2y ago
- Havoc 2y agoSlowly migrating away from google search anyway. Phind is working out better - also gen AI but I trust them more than google not to fk with the results
- sixothree 2y agoKagi and Bing Copilot (strangely) are working out great for me.
- barfbagginus 2y agoDDG works about as good as Kagi for me. And I enjoy using GPT4 with the search tool for power assist, since it's better at planning search terms, extracting into, and integrating the search results into a longer conversation and critical analysis.