5 ms·
I'm comparing fusion reactors to fission reactors there. The complexity of a fusion reactor is obviously much higher than that of a fission reactor. So is the
by pfdietz 2y ago
I'm comparing fusion reactors to fission reactors there. The complexity of a fusion reactor is obviously much higher than that of a fission reactor. So is the size, for a given power output.
- Retric 2y agoYou mentioned “Fusion reactors also have strong diseconomies of scale” so that’s what I am referring to. A fusion reactor 2x larger with the same energy flow per m2 of wall could be cheaper per kWh than a more compact reactor. The exact details matter a great deal and not every design works at every scale. Anyway, a fission reactor’s complexity is mostly outside the device. Things like multiply redundant cooling systems, backups for your backup generators, fuel processing, etc that are completely unnecessary or simpler on a fusion reactor. So overall a large fusion power plant could easily be a simpler overall system.
- pfdietz 2y agoThe diseconomy of scale follows thus: The magnetic pressure (and hence density, at given beta and temperature) scales as B^2. The fusion power density scales as density squared, or as B^4. Now, the mass of the support structure scales as volume x B^2. So, power per support structure mass (and hence, per cost of that structure) scales as B^2. However, fusion power density is limited by what the first wall can withstand. Therefore, a large reactor must reduce B (or, reduce beta) to stay within this limit. Reducing B reduces the power/support mass, and hence power/$ of support structure cost. Fusion reactors require equipment outside the reactor as well, probably much more complex than in a fission reactor. Online tritium recovery, robotics equipment for internal maintenance, and space for first wall replacement (since known materials do not survive the life of the reactor, unlike structures in a fission reactor core.) If you look at ITER, there's a large volume around the core where robotic maintenance devices can slide on a track. The ARC concept required volume and machinery for lifting the entire top of the reactor and replacing the vacuum vessel (then disassembling the old, activated vessel.)
- Retric 2y ago> Now, the mass of the support structure scales as volume X B ^2 No it does not, just as an example the fusion blanket is a constant thickness for a given level of neutron flux per m2 and sub linear scaling as flux increases. Same deal with your cooling loop etc. You’re making several other mistakes, but because at a fundamental level the costs relationships are more complex than what you’re modeling. Consider despite being a novel experimental design and having a huge research staff etc, Vogtle Electric Generating Plant still cost more than ITER to build. Sure the scale is an order of magnitude smaller, but fission has been around for a half century at this point is seemingly much simpler and you’d assume there was a great number of efficiency gains to be had. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vogtle_Electric_Generating_Pla...
- pfdietz 2y agoYes, it does. This follows from the fact that structural mass is proportional to stored magnetic energy, just as the mass of a pressure vessel is proportional to volume x pressure (for materials of a given strength). Viewed another way: if we double B, we quadruple the forces on each segment of conductor, and therefore must quadruple the strength of the supports. I explicitly said "support structure", the structure that is resisting the force of the magnets. There are other parts that scale more slowly, but I don't need to show that all components scale poorly to show that overall there are diseconomies of scale. Note that this is NOT like in a fission reactor. In a fission reactor, everything scales just about linearly with power.
- Retric 2y ago> I don't need to show that all components scale poorly to show that overall there are diseconomies of scale. Yes you do. If A represents 0.001% of the cost then increasing it by 20x doesn’t matter and the support structure is cheap. Same deal with a fission reactor there’s several diseconomies of scale for example around the length of control rods passive cooling after an accident etc, most of them just don’t matter much.