3 ms·
The country closing in on zero deaths on its roads
- sdwr 2y ago> "Don't pretend that there are laws that you know everyone will follow," Tingvall says. "That's very unprofessional. You would never do that in aviation or in other areas where you really care for safety." I've heard this as "trust but verify"
- slifin 2y agoThis is the key to all of it for me "Wasn't changing the road layout tantamount to admitting liability for the crash?" We act like road design is not a modifier on these crashes
- alistairSH 2y agoThis seems so obvious to me. How the hell do traffic engineers earn their PEs if they don’t grasp this? Or are they not engineers at all (but perhaps should be)?
- jessekv 2y agoEngineers usually answer to something like a city council who are elected representatives. If the community at large does not support a change, it is unlikely to go anywhere. I know many engineers in these sorts of roles who spend years building up the consensus to push small improvements through. The positive side is once the first scary change is implemented, and the public actually likes it, the political will suddenly emerges to do more.
- ricw 2y agoThe USA has a 5x higher death rate than Sweden [1]. At ~45k deaths per year in the USA, I don’t understand how this isn’t a higher priority on everyone’s mind. Americas roads are terrible, both from a design as a well as from a maintenance perspective. Often worse than a third world country. This could be done quite easily. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic...
- occz 2y agoI've personally observed a wide-spread refusal to admit that there's a problem that can be addressed when seeing the topic online before. Absurd as it may be.
- freitzkriesler2 2y agoCould it be that America has 335 million people living there versus Sweden's 10.4 million ? It's almost like population density changes how many deaths per year happen! Maybe there's a statistical tool that normalizes the population scale between the two so you can compare like for like.
- alistairSH 2y agoAlmost like you didn’t bother to check the source. The US rate is 5-6x worse per 100k residents. And 2.5x worse adjusts for miles driven. The US has failed miserably at road safety.
- freitzkriesler2 2y agoJust because the bad data and the right data tell the same story doesn't preclude the fact that the original post can and does lead to bad assumptions in many other examples. I expect better from the otherwise number accurate crowd here. The level of butthurt in down d00ts and replies is telling.
- alistairSH 2y agoThe post was not incorrect. There were two separate figures cited -the rate and then a gross figure. You wrongly took them to be closely related. Your error, not the OP’s.
- ellen364 2y agoThe stats in the link say that the annual “traffic-related death rate” is 12.9 deaths per 100,000 people in the USA and 2.2 per 100,000 people in Sweden. It’s the death rate that’s (more than) 5x higher in the USA, not the death count. That’s around 45,000 deaths compared to around 225 deaths.
- tialaramex 2y agoBecause it's a British story this does spend more time on mentioning the particular British political push back from drivers than it might. But one example they don't mention I think needs to be mentioned here. Some years ago, British highway authorities tested two interesting ideas. One of these ideas is: Lets put cameras on gantries so that we can see cars in difficulty or stopped in a running lane. Then use the per-lane signage to close that lane, protecting the vehicle and its occupants. The other was: Let's turn the existing "hard" (ie paved) shoulder of multi lane roads into another lane, thus increasing the maximum throughput of the road. The first idea of course reduces deaths and serious injuries. If your car drops dead in a middle lane of a free flowing road, the people immediately behind you will hopefully realise and evade, but now after a few seconds or at worst minutes the lane will be cleared, meaning fewer opportunities to get rear-ended. Hooray. But the second idea increases deaths and serious injuries. Instead of a safe(ish) refuge (the shoulder) now it's all running lanes, if your car fails you can head for the slowest lane and if you make it now anybody who doesn't realise you're stopped might hit you at 60mph rather than 80mph. Previously the shoulder wasn't a running lane so while it was hardly a safe place to be, since it was right next to vehicles travelling at high speed with no barrier, you weren't one moment's inattention from a violent collision at any moment. Under Vision Zero clearly only the first idea can be implemented. But the second idea is very popular with the usual "one more lane! Just add one more lane, that'll fix it" drivers and it's much cheaper than actual road widening. So the British government resolved to do both and claim that if you add them together they're a safety improvement. You know, like if I charge $5 extra, but also give you a $1 discount I'm actually saving you money... Then of course the first idea is sometimes kind awkward and hard to get right - and the "one more lane" people can't tell the difference anyway. So, eh, you can slow walk that and if a bunch of people die you can probably say the really important thing is you added more lanes - yeah, people are dead but those people probably wouldn't have voted for you anyway.
- nunez 2y agoThe lack of attention to safety in driving drives me nuts every time I drive. Speed limits that have absolutely zero enforcement; so much so, that attempting to actually drive at the limit is a road hazard! Road designs that encourage maximum throughput and maximum distraction (forget phones; injury lawyer billboards are distracting by design). I've even seen folks run red lights without impunity here in Houston. Ive seen police here speed WHILE ON THEIR PHONES. Any politician who campaigns on improving driver safety is raked over the coals. Many mayors have gotten roiled over implementing red light or speed cameras or lowering speed limits in cities despite well established evidence that these changes reduce road deaths. Driving is systemically failed, IMO.
- cosmotic 2y agoAny chance you can link to the evidence that the cameras reduce deaths?
- tialaramex 2y agoHere's a study performed in the US, specifically Pennsylvania https://www.iihs.org/topics/bibliography/ref/1820 https://www.iihs.org/topics/bibliography/ref/1820
- cosmotic 2y agoThe executive summary says it reduced the number of people running through the red light, but it doesn't indicate the impact on accidents or safety.
- tialaramex 2y agoThat's correct. The paper assumes that we understand that compliance results in safety. From your response I gather you want to disagree?
- cosmotic 2y ago