3 ms·
Three of your examples (Rome, Barcelona, and Lisbon) aren't in Western Europe, so don't fit the GP's definition of continental Europe. My own experience with A
by closewith 2y ago
Three of your examples (Rome, Barcelona, and Lisbon) aren't in Western Europe, so don't fit the GP's definition of continental Europe.
My own experience with Americans is that Europe could be any number of definitions. I'd be wary of assuming your own is generally accepted.
- simonbarker87 2y agoIsn’t Lisbon the most western capital city in Europe? Not sure how that doesn’t count as Western Europe? As a Brit I maybe have a different view of eastern and Western Europe but to me the dividing line is probably a vertical line through … Prague?
- walthamstow 2y agoTraditionally the dividing line is Vienna, though that doesn't make it any clearer because Prague is west of Vienna
- simonbarker87 2y agoYeh I was going to say Vienna and then saw where Prague is and switched. I guess it’s a fuzzy line.
- closewith 2y agoBoth the areas called Northern Europe and Southern Europe extend more Westerly than Western Europe. More or less no common definition of Western Europe includes the Iberian peninsula.
- simonbarker87 2y agoAt the risk of sounding belligerent - Wikipedia seems to include Spain and Portugal in its definition of Western Europe. Perhaps there are formal economic or historic definitions that don’t count them but I think a more colloquial/informal/layperson definition would include them.
- closewith 2y agoWe may be reading different Wikipedia articles? None of the definitions suggested by Wikipedia includes the Iberian peninsula: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Europe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Europe > think a more colloquial/informal/layperson definition would include them. With respect, I think the opposite is true. I think you might just have discovered a personal blindspot.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> We may be reading different Wikipedia articles? None of the definitions suggested by Wikipedia includes the Iberian peninsula: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Europe https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Europe Or maybe he's reading that article and you aren't? The only definitions in that article that don't include Spain and Portugal in Western Europe are the ones in which Eastern Europe and Western Europe fail to cover all of Europe. And those tend to include Turkey in Europe, which is bizarre.
- closewith 2y ago> The only definitions in that article that don't include Spain and Portugal in Western Europe are the ones in which Eastern Europe and Western Europe fail to cover all of Europe. Which is all of them in common use? I'm honestly not sure if you read the article. Do you have the impression that the terms Western and Eastern Europe cover the entire continent? That is a concept divorced from reality. Edit: Just read your other comment here. Yes, your idea of Eastern and Western Europe is completely divorced from common usage.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> Which is all of them in common use? Well, no, none of those are in common use. In common usage, Western Europe might be countries that are culturally Western (and in Europe), or countries that are clients of the United States (and in Europe), but neither of those would exclude Spain or Portugal. There's not much difference between the two ideas either.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> As a Brit I maybe have a different view of eastern and Western Europe but to me the dividing line is probably a vertical line through … Prague? It shouldn't be a vertical line at all; I assume the typical division between Eastern and Western Europe would be Catholicism vs Eastern Orthodoxy. They're Eastern Europe and Western Europe because Eastern Europe lies to the east of Western Europe, not because every part of Eastern Europe lies to the east of every part of Western Europe.