4 ms·
I know that at least one other human is conscious, otherwise the term would never have been invented. But you have no way to tell if I am as conscious as I cla
by ben_w 3y ago
I know that at least one other human is conscious, otherwise the term would never have been invented.
But you have no way to tell if I am as conscious as I claim to be, or if I'm just a large language model trained by humanity :P
- golf_mike 3y agoCan you provide proof for the first claim?
- ben_w 3y agoWhich part exactly are you seeking proof of, and to what standard? "I know" is unprovable to others, unless you examine the wiring of my brain. (But then, what is "knowledge"?) "at least one other human is conscious, otherwise the term would never have been invented." — it's always possible that I'm a Bolzmann brain and this was just luck. I don't see how the term could have been invented by a mind that didn't actually have it, except with astronomical low probably random events.
- vixen99 3y agoIn thinking about this perennial problem it's worth bearing in mind that human beings pick up and process an immense amount of data on a continuous basis, that is currently unavailable to any LLM.
- elicksaur 3y agoAnd all on an estimated 100 watts!
- ben_w 3y ago20 for the brain, 60-125 for the whole body depending on if you mean "normally" or "metabolic minimum".
- anticensor 2y agoThe "metabolic maximum" is around 1250, though. And a mediocre lifting or running momentarily increases it from 125 to 700.
- elicksaur 3y agoYeah there’s different ways you could slice it. I was including the whole system, since if the GPU’s cooling system breaks, it won’t be useful for long.
- vidarh 3y agoNo, we don't. We don't even know if existence has an extent in time, because our only way of "interfacing" with time is our experience of memory we can't prove is real. For what you know, you're a lone entity confined to an infinitely short period of time, and all else is an illusion. But of course this isn't a useful assumption in most respects.
- ben_w 3y agoAh, I see you're more of an A. J. Ayer fan than a Descartes fan. I think that if an LLM has any consciousness, it would be an experience like this — one where the past was a fiction it invented to fit the prompt, and the "now" was the only moment before the mind was reset. But I'd put that in the same basket as my… ah, nephew comment? Cousin comment? I guess you'd call it that if we have parent comments etc.? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40406398 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40406398 What you say is not wrong in principle, but it's in the same "cognitively unstable" basket as a Boltzmann brain, where to accept it would mean I couldn't trust my own reason to believe it.
- vidarh 3y agoThe reasoning stands entirely on its own. There's nothing you need to "believe". That you don't have a way to disprove it is close enough to proof. The problem with it is that it's not giving us anything useful. OK, so maybe this moment is the only one there is? Now what? Accordingly the only reasonable recourse is for the most part to ignore it, and add an implicit "assuming my memory and senses are roughly trustworthy" to every assumption. This is the same reason I'm a firm materialist even though we could be in a simulation, or brains in vats: absent evidence of either, the only thing giving us useful information is our senses and our introspection, and so the most useful approach is to assume they are valid until proven otherwise.
- ben_w 3y ago> The reasoning stands entirely on its own. There's nothing you need to "believe". That you don't have a way to disprove it is close enough to proof. Not so, for it is like the liar's paradox, except with high probabilities rather than Boolean logic. If you assume it is true, it follows that you can't trust your own state of mind, and that all statements including "I am just a thought" become suspect, as there is nothing leading up to them to give them justification.
- rixed 3y agoOf course, any philosophical zombie could have invented it. Which makes clear for me how loosely consciousness is bound to senses, including that of introspection. It actually makes me feel that this consciousness we can barely describe is but a faint experience of a distant, largely foreign thing. Like we know the experience of matter that we get from our senses is a grossly simplified version of the real thing (that we still don't know exactly of course, but we already know enough to see how far away our immediate mental model is from the truth)