4 ms·
Almost a quarter of kids aged 5-7 have smartphones
- Waterluvian 3y agoIt’s really hard to believe these numbers but I’m not outright saying they’re wrong because I have no data. I wonder though if they’d count my 7 year old who uses a very old iPhone to access YouTube Kids (which shall never be deleted because it cannot be reinstalled again!) for craft-along projects.
- Horffupolde 3y agoWhy can’t it be reinstalled?
- mikestew 3y agoa very old iPhone... Not OP, but I'm guessing the latest version of the app requires iOS version X, and the phone will only run iOS X-1.
- Waterluvian 3y agoYeah. We learned that lesson when I uninstalled YouTube because half the features didn’t work and then it rejected any attempt to install the app again.
- erkt 3y agoExtra phone lines cost almost nothing and free smartphones are a thing again. They practically throw low end iPhones and pixels at you to try for a new contract. I can understand spending $10/mo for peace of mind from the bus stop to school. I have a home phone again (cell phone) because it cost nothing extra. YMMV by country and region.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y ago[flagged]
- robg 3y agoWe’re going to look back and see smartphones as kids smoking cigarettes.
- drewcon 3y agoPretty sure we can do that right now.
- bravetraveler 3y agoCould even practice by watching The Cable Guy I don't say this to make a false equivalence, mainly in jest - I recognize TV is fairly mild and internet is a firehose by comparison. Yet, we keep ignoring parents... and really, personal responsibility and simply the environment/impact that has. He raised himself like many of us do today. This movie was a bit of a warning, then - decades ago. Except now we have phones, schools are even closer to day care/prison, and so on.
- schmidt_fifty 3y agoBringing up personal responsibility always struck me as avoidance of addressing the problem at all. People will always be irresponsible. If you want to address the problem some part of the answer will have to come from society compensating for poor individual decision making. To avoid doing this will just perpetuate the idea that a child is the property of the parent and deserves to be the victim of their failings.
- bravetraveler 3y agoI think I edited since you saw/replied, I added a bit about the environment. We can't control everything, but we can control how we react to it. He's a product of his environment, parents, and choices. That's not to discount disadvantage. I get it. None of this is final or complete, it's a fucking movie metaphor
- baal80spam 3y agoYes, but I believe kids doing drugs is a more apt comparison.
- javajosh 3y agoMy God, it's a psycho-social catastrophe waiting to happen, not unlike the mid-century cigarette health catastrophe. I go out in the world and see not just adults sitting around a table staring at screens and not interacting, but parents and children. Particularly small children put in front of an iPad and then summarily ignored. It's cruel and inhumane and I admit that I judge these parents harshly for their neglect. I have two kids, 5 and 7, and they use screens but sparingly. Mostly they use them to Facetime relatives and create art and animation with KidPix. They mostly color and play in the real world. They are well socialized, smart and I daresay they are and will remain ahead of any other kids who are addicted to screens by their parents. The problem is if screens rot an entire population of minds, the remaining few will be powerless to help the decline. Like the old saw, "Those who don't know history are doomed to repeat it. Those who do know history are doomed to watch others repeat it." Screens need to be regulated like cigarettes, sooner rather than later.
- _heimdall 3y ago> Screens need to be regulated like cigarettes, sooner rather than later. I also would prefer to see the average kid spend a lot less time on screens. Interestingly I have a totally different take on the "how" though. I don't thing regulation will do a damn thing in the long run, nor do I think we should accept the few people in charge making such a fundamental decision for us. We didn't need cigarette regulation, we needed informed consent. People choosing to smoke needed to know what the known risks were. Regulation of cigarettes themselves were a cop out when those in charge failed to hold cigarette companies liable for lying to the public. Had it not taken decades for the truth about what was known, and covered up, by cigarette companies we would have been in a much better spot in my opinion. What's that mean for screens? For starters, I'd say anyone in a leadership position at major tech companies that leverage their wealth and power to shield their own children from the very tech they sell to everyone else's kids should be held criminally liable. If, for example, major tech leaders happen to send their kids to private schools designed specifically to minimize screens and technology in the classroom, they damn well know its a problem and are keeping that from the public.
- gizmo686 3y ago
- icapybara 3y agoWhen I was a kid in the 90s, it was all about how video games and TV would ruin the new generation. Now, it’s smartphones and YouTube. Somehow I think the next generation will be fine.
- medion 3y agoIt’s completely different.
- danbolt 3y agoYeah, video games today have improved a lot compared to the 80s and 90s.
- wizzwizz4 3y agoOn PCs and dedicated machines? Yeah. On smartphones, it's hard to find something that isn't a Gacha game, and nearly impossible to find something that isn't pay-to-win. All the phone games with network multiplayer available to a 7-year-old right now are some variety of pay-to-win (with ads, regardless). It's not going to corrupt the youth, but the kids deserve better.
- gds44 3y agoAgree. Difference being the amount of stuff competing for kids Attention has exponentially increased. Attention Theft is a phrase I read on HN a while back. Felt like a good description of the main dynamic in the Attention Economy.
- lm28469 3y agoYou have to ignore a lot of things to make that comparison.
- diputsmonro 3y agoBoth of those had some kind of enforced content regulation and much easier way for parents to choose what their kids were exposed to. Yeah, precocious kids could find ways around rules sometimes, but those are exceptions. Tiktok and similar apps are completely different.
- jeffbee 3y agoWhen my kids were about 5 I gave them a hella old Android with Cyanogenmod. It wasn't powerful enough to do anything dangerous and they learned a lot about how to use software just from screwing around with it. It had a camera, microphone, and speaker which already is a pretty good start for having a good time. They discovered infinite repetition by making the phone shout "BUTT BUTT BUTT" in the middle of the night.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nlh 3y agoAs a new parent of 4-month-old, I've been thinking about this topic a lot. (I know I have a few years to prepare). Where I'm torn is that I had access to technology early in life and in many ways it shaped who I am today for the better. I had a TI99 at age 4(ish), a C64 soon thereafter, and away I went. I'm a tech guy because of that, and being a tech guy has brought me a ton of opportunity in life. So I want my daughter to have early, positive, deep exposure to tech in the way I did (where she chooses to take that is up to her). But I don't want her to be a screen-addicted drool. The conclusion amongst friends we've come to is that screens are not inherently the problem -- even video games are not really the problem. The problem is Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok. I cannot think of a single positive benefit they offer to kids (or most adults really, with some narrow exceptions). I'll keep her away from them as long as humanly possible, and when not possible, I'll teach her how to use them responsibly (like sugar -- you can't avoid it, but you can manage it.) I hope?
- sircastor 3y agoI don’t think it’s exclusively social (which surely is its own kind of poison). My kid mostly consumes video from our local Plex, or paints on the iPad, and it does something to his brain. Throws him off for the rest of the day. It’s gotten to the point where I am trying to keep him off it altogether because he seems to manage so much better. I also want my kid to be exposed to tech. And in a way that’s not purely consumptive. I wonder if there’s going to be something he can get in at the ground floor on that can provide the edge early computing did for me.
- nlh 3y agoThanks for sharing the experiences. I'm fascinated to hear that painting on the iPad has the same (negative) affects as watching videos from Plex -- it's surprising to me. I'd hoped that a creative process like painting would hit different. But I guess not? > I wonder if there’s going to be something he can get in at the ground floor on that can provide the edge early computing did for me. It's a great point and I wonder the same. Something to keep an eye out for sure!
- Aurornis 3y ago
- junglistguy 3y ago[dead]
- sircastor 3y agoMy kid is 6 and does not have one. I work from home and frequently and one of the easy ways to keep his attention while I’m trying to work is to hand over the iPad. It always seems to have an effect on emotional regulation if he has it for more than about 30 minutes. I cannot imagine what he’d be like when he possesses something like that full time.
- DANmode 3y agoHow else do you keep them from ditching their tracking device?! /s
- junglistguy 3y ago[dead]
- Aurornis 3y agoThis reminds of the study that claimed 15% of 2 years drink coffee: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0890334415570971 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/089033441557097... Given that I’ve never in my entire life met another parent who thinks giving 2-year olds coffee while this study is claiming 1 in 7 do it, I suspect something else is going on in this surveys. For example, parents who let their kids have a sip of a latte occasionally. I wouldn’t be surprised if something similar was going on: I know parents who set aside old smartphones and an extra line for their kids to take on certain travel occasions, but they’re getting included with the parents throwing a smart phone to their kids and hoping for the best. That said, as a parent I do run into a number of other parents who seem unable to resist any pressure from their kids. They have the exact same attitude as the couple interviewed in this article who said they felt “pushed into a corner”. There’s an uncomfortable abdication of responsibilities to vague societal pressures that many people use to justify the avoidance of their own responsibilities.
- samcheng 3y agoIt's interesting, I live in an a stereotypically-affluent and tech-forward Silicon Valley suburb, and very few of the kids in my kids' elementary school (ages 8 and 10) have smartphones. I would say that Apple Watches are more common (but still less than 15% of kids) and that the few kids with phones have them in order to coordinate between divorced parents. Around a third of families have one or both parents working in Big Tech. Maybe they know better!
- LVB 3y agoYet when it comes to kids being able to communicate at a distance, I think we’ve lost something. My son (12) is quite fascinated when I explain how the old landline approach used to work. That there wasn’t really an age limit, that you could find out someone’s number just from a book, that the house had a phone and you might have to ask to talk to someone. He says it’s too complicated now because all his friends have varied access to devices, are on different chat apps, it is awkward to ask someone for their phone number or email, no one want to talk (voice), etc.
- jonas21 3y agoHonest question: why are we not trying to get this number closer to 100%? Like many people on this site, I personally benefitted from having access to computing technology and the internet as a child, starting at age 5 or 6. This gave me opportunities to build a career in tech that was simply not available to those less fortunate. I've heard similar stories from people in a lot of STEM fields.
- Aurornis 3y agoHonest answer from a parent: Because smartphones today are content consumption machines closer to a TV with infinite channels, not like the computer you used in your youth to learn how to do things.
- RhysU 3y agoDo you think that you needed such access at 5 or 6 to have such a career? I bet you would have ended up in the same career starting with such access at age 16. The Knack doesn't require early access--- computers aren't ballet training.
- xyst 3y agoParents today are so lazy. Have even seen some parents mount phones on the walker to distract the child. I only hope it’s not “YT Kids” on repeat/autoplay. Not sure where I heard it, but advertising firms absolutely love to get their ~~~psyops~~~ ads in front of children in their impressionable phase. The idea is that years down the road, maybe when they are old enough. That catchy jingle they heard when they were young will be forever imprinted in their brain. Subconsciously, when presented with the high number of options to them at the supermarket. They will pick the one that just so happened to be advertised to them heavily when they were young.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 3y agoAlso parents of today think of ipad/iphone = videogames and won't purchase a dedicated gaming device. Except that mobile stores are riddled with videogames made on purpose to addict and extract money from the target (child in this case), while a dedicated videogame console with single-player only games delivers a way more healthy playtime. Parents are completely unaware of this (unless they are gamers) and research doesn't help because it bundles everything under screen time and even when it's decoupled into "videogames" it bundles single player and multiplayer games together, even though the latter incentivizes keeping you hooked to keep paying.
- rasz 3y ago>“YT Kids” on repeat/autoplay. how else are nonsense videos get xx-xxx million views on yt/tiktok.
- throwawayyy9237 3y agoI'm honestly amazed that people seriously compare an 8bit machine with no network to a smartphone with Internet and social media. The Internet, amazing as it is, it's also the home to the worst possible content imaginable and believe it, kids always find a way to neutralize parental controls and the like. Also, I don't understand this notion that "tech" (in the most vague definition possible) actually brings any future advantage. It's like teaching kids Excel or Python and hope they will win a Fields medal. If parents teach them critical thinking, reading books and love math and logic, they'll pick up any problem, language or "tech" easily when they're older and run circles around other kids that "know programming".