3 ms·
Sure there is a valid point in there, but I don't think it's one worth pursuing. If you make a fuss out of it then you're not really giving a good impression;
by dasil003 14y ago
Sure there is a valid point in there, but I don't think it's one worth pursuing. If you make a fuss out of it then you're not really giving a good impression; you come off as a difficult person who is focused on the wrong things: in this case, the written requirements rather than end goal of judging if you are right for the company. No matter how demonstrably smart and skilled this kid is, I would walk out of the interview with the impression that all his brilliance is going to be misdirected and he'll be out in the weeds have the time because he doesn't have common sense about what's important.
Instead, just do like everyone else is saying and apply. If they reject you based on HR filtering then there's a good likelihood the culture would be bad for you in the long run anyway, if not then you put your best foot forward and if you're as good as you think you'll be snapped up before long.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoIt's amazing the amount of assumptions and prejudices being leveraged due to the perceived young age of the person inquiring. Especially given that there is nothing to indicate that he was making a fuss of it more than asking on StackOverflow. Shockingly, some do progress at a faster rate than others. I turned in a large project that I wrote during my senior year of high school and received extremely high marks on it for my senior year project in a high(er) level CS course in University. I got positive remarks on architechtural decisions and things that come via experience and having experience with code. I've been doing it since I was in middle school, I finished a project for my first client before I started my senior year of high school. I still kick myself for not doing a partnership with the fellow the following summer; the idea he wanted me to implement became rather popular a few years ago. Some people progress faster than others. It doesn't mean they're necessarily arrogant or full of themselves. It means that ageism and the notion that "more experience = more better" is silly. There is code I see churned out by developers that have resumes twice as long as mine that absolutely terrify me.
- dasil003 14y agoWhat does this have to do with my comment? My point was there is nothing to be gained by calling attention to and arguing about job requirements.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoHow is there not? There's an entire discussion going on about it here, and I don't think the conclusion to be drawn from it anywhere is that it's an entire waste of time. It's just another symptom of how it can be difficult to hire well and how miserably misplaced some efforts are to improve it by cheap metrics that can be both positively and negatively misleading.
- dasil003 14y agoI meant for the job applicant, not in general discussion.