5 ms·
We'll need universal basic income – Geoffrey Hinton
- DilanB 2y ago[dead]
- impossiblefork 2y agoI don't think it'll work. UBI is a dole. The Romans had that-- when they acquired enough slaves so that the farmer class were no longer running many little farms it turned the core the empire-- their capable farmers, into clients. I think however, that UBI may be worse than the Roman bread doles. Those were after all only food, but money are every kind of resource. There was also still a need for the client class, since they were in fact still a source of soldiers of the empire. The change that UBI makes in modern times is that it changes people who are important and who co-operate in order to make things and get them to others are turned into just a cost which never produces anything. Consequently it'll always be appealing to get rid of them. The only way ordinary people can survive is by having power, and UBI is not enough. If you need UBI you should probably have already had a revolution and seized control because the rulers can always end it. Consequently I don't see how UBI can be a solution. It must be something else. I believe a reduction in working hours could work for a while, at least a decade, but won't be enough in the long run and I'm far from certain that there is a solution. Another problem we've had here in Sweden is that people try to fund these things by taxing successful workers instead of capital owners etc., so it's a rebalancing within the working class while the genuinely rich are unaffected. Because any rebalancing of tax from ordinary people to the rich will cause inflation and reduced investment due to the fact that ordinary people spend a larger fraction of their incomes on consumer products it'll always be appealing to make this purely a rebalancing between workers. Thus there isn't just one failure mode, but two.
- coldtea 2y ago>The only way ordinary people can survive is by having power, and UBI is not enough. If you need UBI you should probably have already had a revolution and seized control because the rulers can always end it. The problem is not much that the rulers can end it, but that they'll continue it in perpetuity. Or if you wish, that they will only selectively end it, or threaten to end it, for some - as a punishment of disobedience. UBI's allure from the point of view of those in power is it turns citizens into dependents. So people not working, and not having power, thus turning into "clients", is kind the whole point. So, yeah, the version of UBI that doesn't have that drawback, is UBI in a society where the masses have seized the control and are actively exercizing it too (not eager to give it back).
- lo0dot0 2y agoAll power originates from the people.
- viraptor 2y ago> are turned into just a cost which never produces anything. The whole premise here is incorrect. Every time UBI is tried, this scenario does not happen. You can find study after study that finds the same thing. https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2020/2/19/21112570/universal-basic-income-ubi-map https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2020/2/19/21112570/univer... > Economists found that it doesn’t make them work less. It does lead to improved education and mental health, and decreased addiction and crime.
- DamnYuppie 2y agoThey have never tried on a large scale over a large timeline. Behavior changes will not happen over night.
- rahimnathwani 2y agoNot only that, but behaviour change depends on whether you expect the thing to last forever.
- viraptor 2y agoYou mean like the one across Iran running from 2011? Yeah, I agree at this point we should just run it globally for over a decade to see if the result is in any way different than almost every single test done so far.
- timschmidt 2y ago"This paper has two purposes. First, it documents the historical context of MINCOME, a Canadian guaranteed annual income field experiment (1974 to 1979). Second, it uses routinely collected health administration data and a quasi experimental design to document an 8.5 percent reduction in the hospitalization rate for participants relative to controls, particularly for accidents and injuries and mental health. We also found that participant contacts with physicians declined, especially for mental health, and that more adolescents continued into grade 12. We found no increase in fertility, family dissolution rates, or improved birth out comes. We conclude that a relatively modest GAI can improve population health, suggesting significant health system savings" https://www.utpjournals.press/doi/pdf/10.3138/cpp.37.3.283 https://www.utpjournals.press/doi/pdf/10.3138/cpp.37.3.283 All in about 4 years.
- kzurell 2y agoUBI has already worked. We hunt and forage food and water, but air and gravity are supplied for free, the latter being inescapably mandatory (good luck ending it, rulers). They're not nothing, not "but that's different", there's wattage in all. We talk about tax and money like they're natural theories, when we could easily pursue compatible, interoperable regimes that meet the UBI design brief. If price is value then change in price is a proxy for externalities, so tax transactions based on change in instantaneous price. The power to do so is in divide and conquer, between rentiers who value stability and those who cultivate volatility. The Not-In-My-Back-Office corporate leadership creates gigahertz iPads but never seems to buy their way out of overnight transaction clearing and filing labyrinthine returns for some reason. I hate being livestock in the "incentive" farm. We almost all do. And while I appreciate insights about the Roman Empire as much as any white male...it's less the done thing these days. :)
- petre 2y ago> try to fund these things by taxing successful workers instead of capital owners The capital will just flee to other places if they do that. In fact it already does. But I agree, UBI will never work. It will just generate inflation and drive prices up, like the Biden Administration's America Rescue Plan did by giving away $1400 checks to people.
- timschmidt 2y ago"While labor and nonlabor input costs have played a role in price increases, corporate profits drove 53 percent of inflation during the second and third quarters of 2023 and more than one-third since the start of the pandemic. Comparatively, over the 40 years prior to the pandemic, they drove just 11 percent of price growth." https://groundworkcollaborative.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/24.01.17-GWC-Corporate-Profits-Report.pdf https://groundworkcollaborative.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/...
- impossiblefork 2y agoYes, but I believe that this can be solved if capital comes from wages-- i.e. large-scale mandatory savings as a fraction of wages, set by each country's central bank and raised in times of inflation, lowered in times of deflation.
- slwvx 2y agoI view payments to low-income people as the state "buying low", with the expectation that they will be able to "sell high" when those same people pay taxes later when they gain a higher income. Such payments are investment by the state in its people. Sure, not every investment pays off, but investors still invest in high risk ventures. Societies should similarly invest in low income people. A UBI would go to everyone, but the benefits would accrue largely to low-income people, hence my focus above.
- KptMarchewa 2y agoNot really, it's an insurance against rebellion - just as Bismarck intended with first social programs. If you give people some low levels of safety, but consistent, predictable safety, they will happily hand the billionaire class the real fruits of their labor.
- timschmidt 2y agoIt can be both.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoA better idea is just to more efficiently redistribute economic efficiency gains brought by new technology by a broader part of Society.
- riwsky 2y agoTautological!
- DrNosferatu 2y agoWhat we need is another Bretton Woods - serving the majority of the large population.
- wizzwizz4 2y ago> The concept of a universal basic income amounts to the government paying all individuals a set salary regardless of their means. > Critics say it would be extremely costly and divert funding away from public services, while not necessarily helping to alleviate poverty. I'm not sure why the reporter wrote this. Have there been any failed UBI studies, ever? (https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2020/2/19/21112570/universal-basic-income-ubi-map https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2020/2/19/21112570/univer... purports to list all of them, and doesn't list any failed studies.) The illusion of balance should not come at the expense of truth.
- jncfhnb 2y agoHow about Alaska, using a link from your own article? https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/9/5/20849020/alaska-permanent-fund-universal-basic-income https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/9/5/20849020/alaska-... The fund is running out of money and there have been cuts to public services to keep it going because it’s now a political must have https://alaskabeacon.com/2024/02/19/permanent-fund-corp-board-again-warns-that-the-fund-is-running-out-of-spendable-money/ https://alaskabeacon.com/2024/02/19/permanent-fund-corp-boar...
- rahimnathwani 2y agoAnd that's not even UBI. Unless $2k is enough to pay for a year of food, shelter and heating in Alaska.
- jncfhnb 2y agoIf you’re going to make argument then you’re surely going to disregard every experiment which also fails that criteria, which is all of them, right?
- rahimnathwani 2y agoI haven't read through all of them. Are there any that satisfy the conditions I consider essential, which I explained in my other comment? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40403308 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40403308
- workphone1 2y agoHas anyone ever explained how UBI would be funded? The US has 300 million people so at, say $500 monthly per person, it’ll cost $1.8 trillion annually just for this one program.
- slater 2y agoImplementing UBI doesn't mean everyone gets money. Those with jobs, for example, or those with millions in the bank, won't. But you likely know this already.
- tpmoney 2y agoIf it doesn't go to everyone, it fails the first descriptor "Universal". Never mind cutting off "those with jobs" would introduce all sorts of problems like we see with similar "benefit cliffs" for just basic welfare systems.
- sowbug 2y agoPart of the promise of UBI is lower administrative costs and reduced political pork. Adding in conditions like the ones you propose would be expensive and arbitrary.
- operationlllll 2y agoThe clear implication is not everyone nets money.
- brunoarueira 2y agoIn Brazil, many benefits occurs like that by age, gender, low-income or other discriminatory rule and multiple times to drive this group to vote into specific parties, perpetuating the low-income and maintain as maneuver mass or a ventriloquist dummy.
- timschmidt 2y agoCouldn't do worse than the way fractional lending or quantitative easing are currently funded.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoIt does seem inevitable that there would be a UBI as there is continued centralization of wealth and power (see tech giants for example), increased automation (in factories now but soon in other things), and reduced need for human labor. We either find a way to make those people live good lives (not just bare minimum lives) or we can except destabilization in our societies - as in either people revolt or the country turns authoritarian. I’m not sure where all this leads - like do people have the “right” to keep having children that may not contribute economically but do create an economic cost? But I think we’ll need UBI before we confront those bigger questions.
- throwaway22032 2y agoThe entire system as it stands exists because you are necessary to those with power. When you're not, you will either revolt or die. To think otherwise is rank naivety.
- pedalpete 2y agoI quite like Sam Altman's recent take on UBI being given a resource which has value rather than being given dollars directly. He was suggesting the people could be given "compute" which they then decide how to use. Though I don't deny this could be a loop-hole to create value in something like WorldCoin, my hope is that it would change the considerations of the people who have it. When we think of UBI, we don't often think of money as the resource, but rather as the thing people use to buy things. If that conversation changed to providing a resource which the person could use to earn, does that make the recipient more of a farmer or fisherman, rather than just being given a fish. We rarely think of UBI as cash payment as something that the recipient would use as an allocation to create something for themselves. Though I don't think this is a simple answer, I'd like us to think in these terms more, and Sam Altman has recently opened this window to my thinking.
- bick_nyers 2y agoThe issue I take with that is that it's another layer of abstraction that can be warped /inflated/etc. Similarly, mobile games often have a "game currency" that you purchase to obfuscate the true cost of a purchase. It's easier to splurge with a card than it is with cash because it feels more abstract, particularly if it's credit.
- lesuorac 2y ago> If that conversation changed to providing a resource which the person could use to earn, does that make the recipient more of a farmer or fisherman, rather than just being given a fish. Tieing UBI to working pretty much is counter to the word Universal. Existing schemes which aren't UBI but are tied to working have caused a lot of problems where an individual is unable to work for some reason (possibly dealing with keeping access to the scheme) lose the benefits from the scheme and not cannot work as they needed those benefits. Although I think the larger issue is that whatever resource you need to have enough of it and fungible enough to distribute. Distributing just one fish to 300 million Americans is actually nearly impossible. There's a reason the stimulus checks were done through the IRS; it's pretty hard to do things at this scale.
- 2y ago
- stubish 2y agoI was thinking about UBI the other day, and was unable to reconcile how it could work given people have different needs. For example, 'the poverty line' here is just under $24,000/yr. But someone on disability support may well be getting $70,000/yr or more to pay for special needs (real example of MS sufferer). With a 'proper' UBI, other forms of welfare would disappear to help pay for it, which would require giving everyone $70,000/yr (or leaving the disabled to their fate). And at triple the current poverty line UBI, getting the in-home help necessary to survive independently would likely be impossible as care industry workers are already in short supply. So we would need to retain at least disability support, and have a much lower UBI, probably below the poverty line. And we would likely still need everyone not on disability support to work, to drag their income up to at least the poverty line so they can survive with some dignity. So without full employment, we would need unemployment benefits as well. In which case, what has the UBI given us? Maybe we just need less wasteful and more compassionate unemployment, disability and aged care support? Or maybe things change when we consider hereditary wealth? With a below poverty line UBI, middle and upper classes could survive and maybe live quite comfortably with the income boost from investments, with the lower classes having to work to earn enough to pay their landlords.
- mistrial9 2y agono this is unconstructive as it gets even worse than your example with special medical needs .. the way this evens out in that case is to expand the capacity of medical treatment such that they can provide acceptable intervention and monitoring for the special needs person.. A different angle is that somehow, in the West, the family unit has been morphed into something in the background.. many places in the world with dense populations rely on extended and long term family definitions to accommodate basic needs and special circumstances for individuals
- stubish 2y agoSo keep disability and aged care support, but drop all other welfare in favor of a UBI at around the poverty line or higher if budget allows? I can now see that working, and needing to pay care workers much more to get enough willing participants is probably a good thing. I don't think we can rely on family or extended family any more. Even in countries with strong extended family and community support structures, people get left behind. And usually the people who need the most support, with mental illness or addiction or social problems driving others away.
- mcswell 2y agoAs usual, the science fiction authors have thought about this lots. Here's one example from before most of you were born: https://www.baen.com/Chapters/9781481483063/9781481483063___2.htm https://www.baen.com/Chapters/9781481483063/9781481483063___... Of course you don't need to agree with the conclusion!
- binary132 2y agoI’m not commenting on this way or another, but if we went to UBI, what would the incentive be for me to work, presuming a basic income is suitable to raise my family on in safe, clean housing, and also presuming that the resources to implement a UBI will be extracted from people like me whose labor is more valuable?
- DGCA 2y agoWanting more than the bare minimum, I imagine.
- euroderf 2y agoWhile we're at it, how 'bout vending machines for sufficient free food ? Insert an ID and get a day's supply of fortified biscuits, not guaranteed to be particularly tasty, resale/arbitrage value is low, manufacturing cost is low. In less dense areas, an autonomous bot shows up like a bookmobile or the ice cream truck.
- tyronee 2y ago[dead]