7 ms·
OpenProject – open-source project management software
- otachack 3y agoEnticing, I'm always open to trying new management tooling.
- schmidt_fifty 3y agoThe source code is here: https://github.com/opf https://github.com/opf Seems to be a rails app on top of Postgres.
- dotancohen 3y agoIt's a Redmine fork, which is a well-known Rails application. It's also my preferred bug tracker, far better than Jira or Bugzilla.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoI'm curious what the BIM addon entails?
- wielinde 2y agoThe BIM addon entails quite some features: - It allows you to share your construction 3D models as IFC models (a standard of openBIM) with the rest of your team. Everyone on a project suddenly has access without having to pay crazy license fees to Autodesk etc. You simply view the models right in the browser. - Everyone can create and comment on issues within the 3D models. Issues can be imported and exported via the BCF format, another openBIM standard. - There is add-in for Autodesk Revit, so that you can fix issues reported in OpenProject browser based IFC viewer straight away in the 3D model authoring tool.
- ImHereToVote 2y agoThank you.
- candiddevmike 3y agoInteresting lineage, RedMine -> ChiliProject -> OpenProject. Here is a (biased) overview on how the product compares to RedMine: https://www.openproject.org/blog/openproject-an-alternative-to-redmine/ https://www.openproject.org/blog/openproject-an-alternative-...
- Narretz 3y agoIt's interesting that when they forked in 2011 they switched from a RoR app to an SPA (angularjs then angular) + REST api to be able to get better UI interactivity. Now it's 2024 and after we've had SSR and hydration, JS frameworks are moving to even tighter integration between client and server (for example React Server components).
- wielinde 2y agoYes, we are moving away from the SPA approach. If you follow our latest feature developments you will see that we now try to adopt the HOTwire approach in combination with GitHub's Primer ViewComponents. And it is fun!
- TkTech 3y agoReading this, I had a little laugh after reading the entire spiel about increasing intuitivness and the first point is renaming issues (universally understood) to "work packages" (what?). Maybe it's just me :) overall it looks like quite the overhaul from its redmine roots. A lot of what I had to hunt for in paid redmine plug-ins years ago is just a core feature in OpenProject.
- joshvm 3y ago"Work package" is a pretty universal term in non-software project management, though a single WP could contain multiple todo items. I'm not sure whether it was coined by one of the frameworks like PRINCE2, but a lot of large/governmental systems use it (certainly the UK/Innovate, NASA and ESA, etc). I would interpret "issue" as more of a general "thing that needs doing" whereas work package has a fairly specific meaning. I wouldn't want to use the phrase work packages as items in a bug tracker, for example. See: - https://prince2.wiki/management-products/work-package/ https://prince2.wiki/management-products/work-package/ - https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/nasa-work-breakdown-structure-handbook.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/nasa-work-br... (pdf)
- dan-allen 3y agoProject management actually seems like a good candidate for open-source. It seems like companies often need customizations. I could imagine forks for different industries.
- j45 3y agoOpenProject is generally open source. Some key features exist outside of the open source license. Their hosted options though, seem reasonably priced.
- input_sh 3y agoI think every open source projects that has ever aimed to have >10 employees has taken that same route at some point: GitLab, Matomo, WordPress, Redis, MySQL, nginx, HAProxy... all incredibly useful for in most use cases completely free, but if you try to really rely on them (on a large enough scale), you will hit that paywall at some point and feel forced to pay up. If the goal is to have <10 employees working on an open source project, then I think it's a completely different story, offering just cloud hosting with no extra features is within the realm of possibility. Keep in mind that while one sysadmin is not cheap, a company relying on multiple cloud-hosted open source tools will at some point find that one sysadmin very cheap in comparison. He'll even have time to do some other things as well. That might be a completely viable route for some "simple" open source project (Plausible and SeaTable immediately come to mind), but some open source projects are just aiming to be complex enough to need more than 10 people. In summary, I personally believe everyone should be pragmatic enough to be fine with the "open core" model. Otherwise, there's no chance in hell we'd have so many cool, open sourced (to an extent), self-hosted tools at our disposal.
- j45 3y agoEvery is pretty broad. The pragmatism of self-hosting is key parts of the software will be missing and you may not get a comparable experience. The issue is not charging. The issue is where key, and actually core, functionality is sitting on the paid side. The idea that "at some point" you hit a paywall is generally not true. It can border on crippleware, and might as well be shareware (still great to support small development teams). Evolving licensing and revenue generation is key. The reality is we wouldn't have the world we have today without open-source software, as in the totally free kind, and at some point it does need to be maintained, unless some of the few packages reach some sort of maturity. Your point about sysadmins not being cheap is fair. I would offer a counter-balance and ask how many more things than need to be are made to be far more complex than they need to be. After all, open-source is also a place of learning, experimentation, and breakthrough, and technical debt. Still, other projects get so much done with so little support. Restricted core features pretty much tunes out a lot of users to get over the value inertia. It's hard to call it open-source, when it's not quite open source anymore. One license I've seen is requiring companies over a certain revenue or headcount to have to license. Even JIRA had some of it figured out with their lowest license offering, but for a ton of functionality) AGPL is helping with some of this - the more projects evolve to partner (for example if someone wants to license the tech to be part of an unrelated project) Maybe the product managers should be the development team. It's far easier to financially support fully open source software even though it might not happen as much as it should. I've recently come across an excellent loom alternative in Screenity and the developer only has a few sponsors. Packaging open source for supporting the development of the software can come in many forms.
- nodesocket 3y agoI typically prefer the simplicity of GitHub issues, mixed with Markdown documentation in the source tree. What are some advantages of using a product like OpenProject?
- j45 3y agoIt's much better suited at project management than Github. Think of it as a higher level, more encompassing approach to project management that can include both the technical and non-technical work. You can create hierarchies of tasks, connect them, assign them, and they are not only for software development like GitHub. It can also tie in with Gitlab/Github It's worth watching a Youtube video or two to see if anything resonates than asking strangers blindly on the internet to give us the perfect explanation :)
- thayne 3y agoAbility to organize issues in various ways, more powerful search and filtering capabilities, easier to track work done and plan work that needs to be done, etc. For a small project it's probably overkill, but when you need to manage a large number of tasks and/or a large number of workers (including product managers, QA, etc.) you need more than a simple text box with some labels.
- input_sh 3y agotl;dr: HR is never gonna use GitHub. Project management tools are just a necessary skill even for non-devs, which leaves any large enough project with only two options: 1. Have the devs and non-devs use completely different systems. 2. Have both use the exact same tool, even if that absolutely sucks for the devs. The second one is bad, the first one is worse. It by definition creates an unnecessary complication in the flow of information, requiring serious effort to overcome. That's why most of us have horror stories about Jira, Asana, and the likes. The hatred of that one particular tool we happen to be using right now unites us all. Whichever tool you're currently using is always the worst one, right until the moment you're forced into using a different one. So, you as an individual might want to put up with one of these horrible options you're already familiar with, or you might use something you actually enjoy. But beware: if you go down the more enjoyable path, you are perpetually gonna be reminded it's not the "real deal". GitHub can't do everything a proper tool can, and you're gonna miss having those "advanced" options at some point, even if you hate to admit that to yourself. Then again, I might just be projecting.
- not_your_mentat 3y agoI'm still waiting for an open-source self hostable alternative to Basecamp. Simple lists and hill charts. Has anyone run across something like this?
- simantel 3y agoDo any of these fit the bill? Plane: https://plane.so/ https://plane.so/ Kanboard: https://kanboard.org/ https://kanboard.org/ Taiga: https://taiga.io/ https://taiga.io/ Redmine (which OpenProject is a fork of): https://www.redmine.org/ https://www.redmine.org/ Teambox: https://www.teambox.com/ https://www.teambox.com/ GitLab (more than just issues): https://about.gitlab.com/ https://about.gitlab.com/
- 3abiton 3y agoWhich one would be best fitting a replacement for Azure DevOps?
- bebop 3y agoI have been building this on and off for a number of years. Mostly focused on the document management side of things: https://github.com/bgroff/kala-app https://github.com/bgroff/kala-app
- nisten 3y agoGetting the wrong vibes from the dark patterns on this site. I click on github.. it doesn't open github... had to look in the comments here. I find repo here... the front end is some ancient angular app with 3 year old security vulnerabilities. I try to find some kind of demo of the product.. and end up in a sales funnel to pay 500$ As a first impression this does not look like a trustworthy opensomething .org product, even though it's probably fine. Just my opinion
- neilv 3y agoAgreed. In traditional terms, they're using a .org domain as a .com. The old rules aren't enforced, but they still hold some meaning. It sounds like they want to do a "community edition", so they could just do it from a .com, and set expectations appropriately. If they instead wanted to have a community-developed open source project, but also sell derived/layered products, they might set up a community governance structure and home it on the .org, at arm's length from their .com where they do sales and other company-specific stuff. (BTW, sympathy on the challenges of building a sustainable business on open source, especially given some of the poor taste we sometimes see from freeloading commercial competitors.)
- eddd-ddde 3y agoI had no idea TLDs had any form of "semantics". TIL dot com is apparently a "commercial" site.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoThey used to. .gov for government,.edu for education, etc. Certainly I would not expect a purely commercial entity on a ".org" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_top-level_domain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_top-level_domain P.s. You're making me feel old :-)
- neilv 3y agoYep, earlier on, the non-country-code ones had rules about who could use them, and the registrar for some of those was expected to be a custodian. Then they seemed to focus more on making money from registrations, than from the custodian aspect. Then ICANN created an industry of middleperson (maybe because there shouldn't just be one rent-seeker, but competing ones), and also seemed to bless a market of landgrabbing squatters. (And much more recently, some ICANN-connected people seemed to be scheming to grab a popular TLD for themselves, like a PE firm.) With most of the good and even bad domain names taken by squatters, there was demand for all sorts of new TLDs (which someone was happy to middleperson). As well as the risky practice of building your company atop a 2-letter country code TLD, where there's a significant chance of a change in government policy would break a lot of your links, URLs embedded in software, email addresses, and Googlejuice. Or simply have you over a barrel with exorbitant renewal fees (or bribes). (Historically, some of these ccTLDs were small islands, where there was one sysadmin person running the "ISP" for the island, including domain name authority, and the government didn't necessarily even know/understand.)
- preezer 3y agoI think redmine is wayyyy better. Btw: Open project is a fork of redmine.
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- hammyhavoc 3y agoCan you elaborate?
- 5e92cb50239222b 3y agoThis project was picked up (and forked) by Rosatom for its internal Jira replacement after they got cut off from Jira in spring of 2022. No idea how many changes they introduced, but I guess OpenProject should be powerful enough (or at least provide a powerful enough base to build upon) to handle giant projects at their scale. The fork is not publicly accessible, although they do conform to the GPL and provide the source code to their clients. https://habr.com/ru/companies/greenatom/articles/814589 https://habr.com/ru/companies/greenatom/articles/814589
- wielinde 2y agoThank you for the intersting link. If you checkout our GitHub repository you see that there are 2.2k forks. We don't keep track on all of them. And yes, it is true that OpenProject is used as an alternative to Jira. Mainly for two reasons: OpenProject is made with data sovereignty in mind. And Atlassion pulled Jira's self hosted option off their shelves. And the other reason is pricing, I guess.
- Yotsugi 3y ago>Start free trial Into the trash it goes. Even if I was a big corporation, I wouldn't depend on something that was only made to make money off of it to manage anything.
- nobrains 3y agoSo, we have got the following project management software (including openproject.org) on HN main page in the last 48 hours: - https://worklenz.com/ https://worklenz.com/ - https://plane.so/ https://plane.so/ - https://www.openproject.org/ https://www.openproject.org/