4 ms·
What doesn't make sense to me is why the major ad networks don't just have a setting for advertising on NSFW sites, or for that matter on NSFW pages. They're j
by AnthonyMouse 2y ago
What doesn't make sense to me is why the major ad networks don't just have a setting for advertising on NSFW sites, or for that matter on NSFW pages.
They're just leaving money on the table. Ads are sold at auction, so the auction price on NSFW pages would be lower, but because it would be lower then some advertisers would want the discount. The alternative is that the ad network bans them and gets nothing, the advertiser loses out on cheap impressions and the site goes bankrupt.
Sites like Deviant Art could have a policy to the effect of "NSFW content is allowed but you have to mark it" and then advertisers who don't want to be seen next to NSFW content, aren't. Hypothetically some user could post something NSFW without marking it, but the same is true on sites that ban NSFW content entirely.
Then the site itself gets the full payment on the majority of pages that are safe for work, still gets something from the ones that aren't, and doesn't have to deal with shady malware-laden ad networks.
- rchaud 2y ago> What doesn't make sense to me is why the major ad networks don't just have a setting for advertising on NSFW sites, or for that matter on NSFW pages. Two main reasons: - Websites cannot accurately classify content a lot of the time without human review. Ads are served dynamically, so they could appear on a NSFW post faster than a human can review it. It's less work to simply optimize for as little NSFW as possible. - NSFW content consumers aren't valuable to advertisers or ad network operators because they don't sell products that could be placed as a 'contextual' ad. Ad platforms need insurance brokers, banks and CPG brands to make up the fat tail of revenue. That stuff can be placed next to posts about pretty much anything. NSFW content on the other hand doesn't work the same way, which is why ads on porn sites are for scam dating sites and unregulated erection pills.
- echelon 2y agoThe first "kosher" brand that advertises on NSFW contexts can take my money.
- rchaud 2y agoIt still wouldn't work in the way you think it might. Advertising is about keeping something "top of mind", companies won't want to link their brand in someone's mind to when they're pounding off. This is doubly so considering the use of remarketing cookies. While you're watching something that's bound to fill you with regret moments after the fact, you won't want to see an ad showing the Amazon products you were browsing previously.
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> Websites cannot accurately classify content a lot of the time without human review. This is the same whether NSFW content is banned or not. "It's banned but somebody posted it anyway" has no apparent solutions different than the problem of "the user is required to mark it but they didn't." As an obvious example, adult content is nominally banned on sites like TikTok, and yet there are thousands of TikTok accounts that serve as the funnel for OnlyFans, with the creators dancing on the line of the site's policy (and often crossing it), only to create a new account and carry on if they get banned. > NSFW content consumers aren't valuable to advertisers or ad network operators because they don't sell products that could be placed as a 'contextual' ad. Which is fine because the ad slots are sold at auction. The ad network's choices are to get something or get nothing.
- 20after4 2y agoAllowing adult content puts your site in the same category as every porn site on the internet. Maybe it doesn't make much sense but that's just how they play it. It's not literally seeing your ad directly next to a NSFW image, brands don't even want to be on the same domain as homoerotic sonic the hedgehog fan art. edit: sibling comment has a better explanation which I think is probably 100% on the nose for this one.
- creer 2y agoThey are leaving money on the table. More than that, they have funded deliberate efforts to find out the non-conforming site and kick them out of their network and that's not free. It's a deliberate, active decision and its cost. That's policy. Prioritized over cost and profit. In the US, there is often concern that the more valuable clients or end-users might otherwise boycot their product, or get them regulated even further. A concern that their are under pressure to do that, or else face even more costly consequences. (And they are. It's a very vocal part of society that's puritan.)