3 ms·

>A standardized HTML specification for email There is no reason why this couldn't exist in the current e-mail technology. In fact, as someone who has written H

>A standardized HTML specification for email There is no reason why this couldn't exist in the current e-mail technology. In fact, as someone who has written HTML, I'd rather not have HTML anywhere if possible! It's a terrible, nonsensical technology. A simple XML format for display text/images would be much easier to deal with, and also easy to transpile to a HTML/CSS subset. I'd like to hope that e-mail will last longer than HTML! I think the biggest problem with e-mail is that the lack of inter-provider communication protocols, something that distributed social media (the fediverse) has. For example, there is no way for a provider to know whether or not an e-mail sent was opened, so EVERYONE uses tracking pixels! Like, just put this into a protocol already! The problems you're talking about with HTML support are simply because there is no way for a provider to announce what HTML it supports, partly because this depends on the client that opens the e-mail, not the server that stores the e-mail. But even then, seriously, this should really just be a setting per account and if you use Thunderbird it announces to everyone "hey this dude uses Thunderbird, so don't use fancy HTML!" and if you switched to something else you would just start getting different e-mails. You can see why this wouldn't work with HTML, since HTML is a terrible language that has no actual support for being displayed in a zillion different clients despite what it claims.

ndriscoll 2y ago
Return receipts are already a thing aren't they? But most people don't actually want to be tracked, so the correct thing to do there is not allow any external resources to be loaded from an email, and to make user tracking illegal/codify that stalking millions of people doesn't make it okay; it makes it millions of counts of stalking and harassment. HTML already gracefully degrades. If you don't support a feature, you just ignore it and continue. It works just fine unless you're shooting for exactly matching some figma design on all clients, which is exactly what HTML is not supposed to do.

ndriscoll 2y ago

Return receipts are already a thing aren't they? But most people don't actually want to be tracked, so the correct thing to do there is not allow any external resources to be loaded from an email, and to make user tracking illegal/codify that stalking millions of people doesn't make it okay; it makes it millions of counts of stalking and harassment. HTML already gracefully degrades. If you don't support a feature, you just ignore it and continue. It works just fine unless you're shooting for exactly matching some figma design on all clients, which is exactly what HTML is not supposed to do.