3 ms·
>if you refuse to build it, someone with less scruples will. Pretty lame excuse. If I don't sell drugs, some else will. If you're doing it, you are already th
by croes 3y ago
>if you refuse to build it, someone with less scruples will.
Pretty lame excuse.
If I don't sell drugs, some else will.
If you're doing it, you are already the one with less scruples.
Do you think the victims care about the scruples of the perpetrator?
- octopoc 3y agoYeah it's really just an excuse to be evil while feeling righteous and conflicted about it, and saying "You don't understand" to anyone who objects to your behavior.
- alan-hn 3y agoNo the ones with less scruples are cutting the drug supply with harmful stuff including but not limited to xylazine and fentanyl/nitazene analogs
- croes 3y agoBecause it much better to die from clean overdose? That's like saying, I kill people with a clean knife, I don't want them to get an infection from a dirty blade.
- alan-hn 2y agoOverdose is less likely to happen with an unadulterated product because the dosage can actually be measured. You can't measure a dose with a product of unknown concentration. The dose response curves and ED50s are known for all of these substances but people keep dying because they don't actually know how much they're taking
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rysertio 3y agoyou're less likely to die from a fentanyl shot that you know the exact concentration of, than injecting adulterated white powder with nothing to base the dosage on.
- zamadatix 3y agoI think the comparison is more along the lines "might as well supply clean syringes instead of let things go their inevitable course otherwise". The point isn't about the victims then loving you and thinking you're such a stand up person, it's about why you might as well be the one that's hated but at least you know it was done better than it would have. Importantly, this is only said to apply when you are convinced there is some inevitable humanity destroying technology and you think you can deliver it in a less destroying way than it will be otherwise. It doesn't apply to things that are already present, like selling drugs. That said, I don't think most of what Palantir actually delivers on fits this mold. They're just generally cruddy.
- legohead 3y agoI think it's more lame to disregard this ideology. What if Germany had the nuke first? "oh well, at least we held to our morals" There's this ideal human sociology, and then there's the reality of what we really are. It takes a unique person to accept it, and do the wrong thing for the right reason, and also be able to steer things in the eventual right direction.
- asah 3y agointeresting example because we defeated Germany without nukes...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> we defeated Germany without nukes In part by firebombing them indiscriminately. The way we won WWII would later be technically outlawed by the Geneva Conventions.
- dunekid 2y agoAs if dropping the bombs on Japanese civilian population would be allowed by Geneva convention.
- kazinator 2y agoDid you misread outlawed as allowed?
- dunekid 2y agoI didn't. But reading the whole thread again, I think the parent was saying even though Germany wasn't captured by nukes, it still was pretty gruelling to the civilian population. In that case my comment is not really adding to it. But I wanted to point that nukes were pretty bad too and even worse in many ways. There was a minisicule military objective in the use of those, but it was more of a threat to the whole world.
- 2y ago
- dalore 3y agoIs that not a good excuse for drug legalisation? If drugs are illegal then we get poor-quality or adulterated drugs, leading to deaths, and funding illicit activities. If we legalise it, we get quality control and tax.
- legitster 3y agoThat's not the point I was trying to make. If anything, it's the opposite. We need moralistic people to take on amoral/uncomfortable problems. If you refuse to deal with drug addiction, you shouldn't be surprised when drug dealers do.