5 ms·
Army soldiers not impressed with Strykers outfitted with 50-kilowatt lasers
- gumby 3y ago> that’s what you need to burn through a quarter inch steel plate?” Do you really need to burn through steel plate? Seems like something like this is for shooting down cheap drones. Though I've always wondered about laser weapons -- I'd think the obvious defense is cladding the device in a mirror surface.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chris_va 3y agoOr just something that gets smoky when it burns, then the energy is deposited entirely into the smoke boundary layer (and might even make a nice reflective plasma).
- ssl-3 3y agoIt would need to be a neutral-density-ish smoke, wouldn't it? If my dealings with (much, much) smaller lasers are an indication, "regular" smoke from laser-heated things is generally buoyant in air, and would tend to just float up and away from a presumably-horizontal beam. It seems like this would limit the smoke's abilities to diffuse and absorb the energy.
- chris_va 3y agoYes it would ablate at some rate, based on the drag, convective buoyancy, etc. If the smoke is optically thick at all, even if it pushed away almost immediately, the wall ablation rate would probably be a couple orders of magnitude lower than if the laser hit the wall directly... If you want a fun read, the Galileo probe wall ablation paper is fun, the re-entry power density (at the wall!) was ~10kW/cm^2.
- gpm 3y agoI'd be sort of surprised if the buoyancy mattered much in the face of the amount of air something needs to move to fly. On the time frames that buoyancy acts in I imagine (without data) it's no longer around the drone anyways.
- Retric 3y agoAs I understand it defenses depend greatly on pulse duration. Rotation dramatically increases effective armor thickness if energy is delivered over a long time frame etc. But drop to the nanosecond range and a cloud of plasma which used to be the armor is going to between the laser and what’s left of the armor. That said, you don’t need to drill through a target, a jet of ablated material means an equal and opposite force is going in the other direction. Really though the biggest limitation of a laser defense system is pure kinetic kill weapons. Big thing moving Mach 2+ is deadly even without pinpoint accuracy or being filled with high explosives.
- ortusdux 3y agoIntumescent paint would do the trick. Intumescent paints are considered the lightest form of passive fire protection. An intumescent is a coating that, when exposed to heat, is rapidly transformed through sublimation, and expands many times its original thickness (up to 100 times), to form a stable, carbonaceous char. The resultant char reduces the conduction of heat from the fire to the substrate, delaying the time it takes to reach structural failure. I'm considering getting some for my kitchen remodel. https://www.nullifire.com/en-gb/expert-insights/expert-advice/the-different-types-of-intumescent-coatings-their-benefits/ https://www.nullifire.com/en-gb/expert-insights/expert-advic...
- aerostable_slug 3y agoC-RAM: counter rocket, artillery & mortar. You have to be able to get into the incoming rounds, through the metal bodies of artillery shells, rocket warheads, etc.
- jareklupinski 3y ago> Do you really need to burn through steel plate? not if you're accurate enough to hit its sensors
- spartanatreyu 3y agoWhat if the sensors are on the inside? It's possible to have a pre-programmed map, objective destination and accelerometers to judge distance.
- jareklupinski 3y agoif the payload is just ballistic and its trajectory is known, the target can just move out of its way and let it hit dirt those things usually have some sort of heat/EM/something seeking sensor to make it accurate to the last meter, and those still can't "see" through metal (yet (that we know about))
- metal_am 3y agoJust because something is reflective in the visible light spectrum doesn’t mean it’s reflective for the laser’s wavelength.
- nuccy 3y agoMetal coating (Al, Ag, Au) is reflective in very wide range of wavelengths - from far IR to EUV [1]. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflectance https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflectance
- jandrewrogers 3y agoYes, this is for highly maneuverable soft targets. A mirror will not work. At the power levels involved, any mirrors must be precisely tuned to the exact wavelength of the laser (e.g. dielectric mirrors) and they must be immaculately clean. That level of cleanliness is impractical in a military environment. Furthermore, the US has developed "white" laser weapons, which will defeat any tuned dielectric mirror like it wasn't there since the lasers have a broad spectrum of wavelengths.
- ein0p 3y agoNah, it’ll totally work. For one thing, you won’t be able to precisely track the spot at which energy is focused. For another, most rocket shaped targets can be made to spin (and some already do spin and rely on rotation to scan for targets), thus defeating your “directed energy” entirely. It’s a boondoggle and a waste of taxpayer money, easily defeated from a couple of miles away with a 50bmg rifle or a salvo of cheap unguided mines.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoWhat if mounted on an airframe a la pave-low ?
- some_random 3y agoHow are you going to defeat a drone swarm with a 50bmg rifle or dumb mines?
- ein0p 3y agoNot “drone swarm”, this laser can be easily defeated with cheap as dirt weaponry that’s been in use on the battlefield since WW1. In general anything that’s high tech and expensive makes an excellent target. Doubly so if it emits any electromagnetic radiation, and doesn’t shoot very far.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoYour intuition about the properties and effects of high-power lasers is failing you. The original design targets for US military lasers several decades ago were specifically selected because there are no practical countermeasures. These design targets were ambitious; it took several decades to develop practical lasers that could start to meet them. There are fundamental limits to material physics. Spinning doesn't help because there are always fixed points by definition. There are both materials science and engineering limits to spin rates, so you can precisely design your laser power levels to be reliably effective at the upper bound spin rates. All of this was fully modeled out and calculated half a century ago. Other countermeasures, like dielectric mirrors, would be very expensive to use on cheap weapons, and the US already developed a counter-countermeasure anyway with the invention of lasers that emit "white" light. The scientists and engineers that did R&D on this over the last several decades weren't idiots. Everything "obvious" that armchair weapons experts might come up with were accounted for a long time ago.
- bilsbie 3y agoHow close are we to the laser from short circuit?
- Terr_ 3y agoAt that size, effectiveness, and implied number of shots? Very far away.
- EA-3167 3y agoThe hardest parts are still power source, bloom on target (burning stuff kicks up dust into the air and disperses the laser), and adaptive optic focusing to get through all sorts of atmospheric conditions. It must be said that the last two are in the realm of things the US military might plausibly be decades ahead on, in secret. The power source on the other hand is far more likely to emerge from the public or academic sector.
- ggm 3y agoWhat's their impact on drones and as UAV defence which may be a mostly static site function? Mobility to deployment, then defended asset which in turn offers perimeter defence against unmanned subsonic directed or non ballistic weapons. (I'm guessing supersonic and ballistic bring different problems) [Edit: I wouldn't for a minute discount the complaints from boots on the ground. Lots of amazing tech turns out to be useless in the field, has to be redeployed fit to purpose]
- tamimio 3y agoNext: Drones are equipped with mirrors now. Your move!
- ortusdux 3y agoSpinning the drone also helps disperse the energy over a larger area. https://youtu.be/7JH1_ZKV7t4?si=QrvdFFipckU9fd_X&t=337 https://youtu.be/7JH1_ZKV7t4?si=QrvdFFipckU9fd_X&t=337
- tamimio 3y agoCool concept! Probably not that useful for most payloads though like cameras or anything similar. Unless the base where the payload is attached to, is separate from the airframe.
- XorNot 3y agoMirrors are not a defense against high power lasers. The mirror is not 100% efficient, and as soon as it warps or discolors, it absorbs more energy and promptly burns through. And yes, this is a problem for laser optics too: which is why these designs tend to use focused arrays of beams, cooling systems and/or parabolic mirrors (which also helps with divergence).
- tamimio 3y ago> The mirror is not 100% efficient That’s correct, but it will definitely require more time, which practically speaking, you won’t have, after all the mirror is made of thin sheet of metal, which requires an extremely high temperature to melt. I think beryllium -which is used already in military- make a good choice, plus the spinning drone as mentioned above would disperse the energy, making it harder to take down.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> it will definitely require more time No, it won’t. Occlusive ablation and spinning make more sense, though that comes with other trade-offs.
- aynyc 3y agoWhat do they use for targeting? Radar?
- jandrewrogers 3y agoCould be a radar or IRST-style [0] system, both are used for that kind of thing. I imagine there might be some design complications with something like IRST to the extent they have to keep laser reflections from hitting the imager. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infrared_search_and_track https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infrared_search_and_track
- pants2 3y agoI imagine such a laser could blind an enemy soldier nearly instantly from miles away. Is that against international law?
- hyperific 3y agoMost definitely but it's complicated. "The Protocol does not prohibit attacks against binoculars, periscopes, telescopes, and other optical equipment because it was unknown whether laser attacks on such devices could cause permanent blindness." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_on_Blinding_Laser_Weapons https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_on_Blinding_Laser_W...
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoSigned by both Russia and the US, FWIW.
- polotics 3y agoWell Russia also signed that they would guarantee the security of Ukraine in exchange for getting Ukraine to give up its nuclear weapons...
- GaryNumanVevo 3y agoWe contain multitudes I suppose
- petermcneeley 3y agoA very small filament of tungsten can radiate away 100 Watts. Imagine how much power a plate of tungsten could radiate.
- mcphage 3y agoIsn’t that also related to surface area? Light bulb filaments are highly coiled, like DNA. That gives a lot more surface area than a plate would.
- petermcneeley 3y agoThe coil is for resistance. You want the voltage drop to be across the filament. The coil of thin wire gives it significant length.