4 ms·
[stub for offtopicness]
by dang 3y ago
[stub for offtopicness]
- IncreasePosts 3y agoI don't think you need to lead with your age. It's a cool project and you should be proud of it regardless of your age.
- megraf 3y agoAs a 30 something, I completely agree.
- smith7018 3y agoTotally unrelated to the content of your post but labeling posts with "I'm [a teenager] and X" has always irked me. It either serves to undermine the content (older people immediately questioning the authority of a teenager) or people respond with meaningless praise ("Wow, great job! I was playing video games when I was your age!"). It also harkens back to the 2000s and 2010s when the industry was obsessed with "teenage savants" for some reason. So much money was wasted by being thrown at teens due to tech's obsession with youth and the errant belief in its ability to drive innovation. Your post could have been titled "Show HN: I wrote a guide to help teens learn how to build their own programming language." I dunno, maybe I just need my coffee and I'm being grouchy
- stephencoyner 3y agoThere’s been a concerning trend of less and less young, successful founders. Where is the modern Zuck, Gates or Patrick Collison? I say good on OP for putting themselves out there and keep pushing. We need young people to come up with great ideas and if that comes with them pointing out how young they are, I’m totally fine with it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Zambyte 3y agoI think there have been fewer young technology founders because I think technology has become less and less accessible. There is so much more to sift through to get from an idea to a project or product than there was 10-20 years ago. I'm saying this as someone who is relatively young, so keep that in mind.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dheatov 3y agoFor some parts of the landscape like mobile app development, yes. Its hard to say if they are doing it with hidden intention, or if they sincerely believe enforcing their "best practices" on everyone yields greater good. Probably a bit of both. The part where you build a demo/prototype showcasing if an idea works, I believe it should be much easier than before as long as you postpone understanding/deciphering the implementation. In those major ecosystems there are huge collections of single-purpose libraries doing a subset of what you want to do, all you need might just be a reasonable amount of python to string them together. However, ensuring the correctness and actually deploying them for planet-scale mandates following a reasonable subset of "best practices" which is very overwhelming, but doable. People doesn't usually build planet-scale product 10-20 years ago.
- Zambyte 3y ago> However, ensuring the correctness and actually deploying them for planet-scale [...] I think this is specifically a big part of the problem. Not everything needs to be planet scale to be good. People didn't focus on being planet scale 10 years ago. 20 or so years Mark was worried about getting The Facebook available at one or two schools. Worrying about getting things working for the world has made it way harder for us to get things working for indoviduals or small groups.
- dang 3y agoThis comes up every time someone posts like this, and it's not really very helpful.
- smusamashah 3y agoWhat are HN's guidlines on young people mentioning their age in a Show HN like this post here? Should we take it graciously, admit they are young and encourage them for what they did or should we point out not to mention their age? IMO, if we take the age out, some of show HN's might not look very interesting. Same goes for a Show HN where someone mentions they are not a programmer and yet built a thing.
- hunter2_ 3y agoFor whether age should be mentioned: Does there need to be a guideline? There are plenty of things that have no specific guideline, things which are fine to do or not do. For whether there should be comments about age being mentioned: existing guidelines already denounce low value commenting especially at the root level.
- dang 3y agoThere's no official guideline (we try to keep that list minimal), but I think it's harmless and the main thing commenters should do is not complain about it. These complaints are always the same, always offtopic, and usually balloon in size to the point where the offtopicness drowns everything else. That's a terrible outcome for a thread like this. Even if you dislike "I'm $X years old and I $Y" posts, it's not helpful to give a kid a grumpy patronizing response. We want HN to be a helpful community, not some weird age competition.
- umvi 3y agoI guess the point is that saying you are a teenager in the title can seem like an unfair way to game your post ranking by garnering awe/sympathy. Lots of middle aged people build cool things too, but they can't pull the age card to boost their rank on the front page (at least, not until they are at the other extreme - like 80 or 90 years old)
- lizardking 3y agoAndy Rooney, is that you?
- ramon156 3y agoWhile I want to agree, your comment just sounds salty
- xandrius 3y agoTotally agree on every point and I'm not being negative, the thing is that stating the age is something most people wouldn't even think (I like to believe we all still see ourselves as kids in our minds), so if someone puts it there themselves (as opposed to being a news article written by someone else) then they are doing it for marketing purposes. I did lots of cool stuff "for being made by a 17yo" but in retrospect it was not objectively great.
- jimvdv 3y agoHN is so full of negative comments like these. OP I’m very impressed you learned all of this at 17! I started coding when I was a teenager but still haven’t released something like this 10 years later.
- pm 3y agoI don't think there's an issue. Discourse on HN can be daunting for anyone. Sometimes it helps to know there are people your own age doing cool things. It makes it more accessible, which is a good thing.
- alex_lav 3y agoDefinitely just grouchy.
- Minor49er 3y agoKids and especially teens seem to do this implicitly whenever they are doing things that they feel is advanced for their age
- Levitating 3y agoThat's survivor bias.
- Minor49er 3y agoNo it isn't
- Levitating 3y agoOf course it is. If a project doesn't state that it was made by a teenager you wouldn't know. I never stated my age on my projects when I was younger. Neither did any of my developer friends.
- Minor49er 3y agoThe observation was on kids declaring their ages around projects that they feel are advanced for them. It is not survivorship bias and has nothing to do with that term. The term doesn't even apply to your own example anyways
- thefaux 3y agoThanks for absorbing the downvotes. Helpful or not, I mostly agree with your reaction. Let the work stand on its own without injecting identity into it.
- kstrauser 3y agoI think it guides responses to it. If a teenager writes a guide that says O(n) algorithms are always faster than O(n^2), I'm likely to tell them that I see what their thinking is, but here are some counterexamples that make it more nuanced than that. If a friend with a PhD in compsci said that, I might tease them more... assertively. In this conversation I see people discussing the requirements for being Turing complete. Because OP is a teen, everyone so far seems pretty nice about gently pointing out inaccuracies. I doubt they would be, or should be, as easy on me if I made similar misstatements. And that's the value I see in "as a teenager..." here. It's not so much about their age as that they don't have decades of education and experience under their belts. Another person posting "as a professional dog groomer..." might get similar responses: hey, that's pretty neat coming from someone who hasn't been doing this for a living for many years!
- unglaublich 3y ago[flagged]
- lionkor 3y agoThe primary reason it should not be listed is that it entirely distracts from the content, as one can see by there being few comments (as of right now) that talk about the contents. Only comments about age.
- kunley 3y agoThen why don't you make it irrelevant in a civilised way by ignoring it...
- unglaublich 3y agoIgnoring what someone puts on a stage would be uncivil.
- kunley 3y agosmart answer, but I think you know what I meant: ignoring the thing about age and let her enjoy what she wrote more
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rvz 3y agoWell done! Ignore the grumpy haters in this thread and keep going.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- darig 3y ago[dead]
- GiorgioG 3y agoThis seems like nothing more than an ad for hack club.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sneed_chucker 3y agoHonestly, very cool good for you. Side note, I'd discourage leaning on your age/precociousness when doing stuff like this. It's a strategy with a limited shelf life, and sooner or later your work will have to stand on its own merit anyway.
- storyinmemo 3y agoYup, that's a piece of advice I'd give to younger me.