4 ms·
Directed energy weapon replaces million-dollar missiles at 13 cents a shot
- ajuc 3y agoCost per shot is only one of the relevant metrics for comparing actual cost-effectiveness. For one example - surface-to-air missiles usually have ranges of 20-100 km. This device has range of 1 km. So each shot can be orders of magnitued cheaper, but to cover the same ground you'd need 20^2=400 to 100^2=10 000 times the number of these devices compared to the number of missile launchers you need today. And you still would't be able to hit drones that fly too high. Basically it's only a replacement for point-defence AA artillery (which is already pretty cheap to fire), possibly for MANPADS that have 4-5 times the range of this, not for long-range expansive surface-to-air missiles like Patriot, Sea Viper or CAMM.
- verdverm 3y agoIt's a component in a layered air defense network. Different tools for different problems, working in concert. This may be good for defending FOBs and important infrastructure against shahed drones and similar
- ajuc 3y agoWell, yes, but it's advertised as "replacing million-dollar missiles" which is just false.
- verdverm 3y agoWho's advertising this? The military or the journalist?
- riku_iki 3y ago> Well, yes, but it's advertised as "replacing million-dollar missiles" which is just false. it could replace in that specific scenarios: fighting against cheap but slow drones.
- ajuc 3y agoIf you're shooting at a cheap drone with a million-dollar-missile - it's because you don't have anything more appropriate at the right place to defend a high-value target. The appropriate solution right now is AA artillery (Gepard or ZS-23-2 or -4, etc.) or electronic jammers. You don't have them near the high-value target right now because it's simply too expansive to build enough of these to cover all the thousands of kms of frontline and thousands of high-value targets all over the country. So you put them where they are most needed and cover the rest with long-range missiles. I'm pretty sure AA cannon is cheaper to build than this RFDEW device. If you can't build enough AA to defend against drones now - you won't be able to build enough RFDEW either. Yes operating costs will be lower, but initial cost will be higher, so you still won't have enough of them. So you'd still need to use the long-range missiles to deal with the drones that slipped through the gaps. BTW I do hope they can improve the range, but as is it's not going to replace long-range missiles.
- riku_iki 3y ago> I'm pretty sure AA cannon is cheaper to build than this RFDEW device I suspect AA cannon may suffer in accuracy on such ranges trying to target small moving target, because too much physics is involved (wind, bullet drop), from another hand those beaming devices will have near 100% accuracy.
- verdverm 3y agoyup, they need to be highly mobile for an environment like Ukraine, where they put flak AA on technicals and use phones on 6' polls to locate shaheds This seems like a good, ship mounted, close range AA option
- verdverm 3y ago
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago> see, for example, the US$1.3-2.5 million Sea Viper missile used to take out a US$20,000 drone
- verdverm 3y agoThat is an example of a $1M+ missile But where is the connection to that this missile is the one intended to be replaced? Where is the military saying this? I suspect they talk more in terms of expanding the available types of fires they can use depending on the circumstance
- saltcured 3y agoWhether this phrase bothers you or not seems entirely to depend on whether you think replacement means not having to have such missiles on hand at all, versus not having to waste them on specific tasks and therefore not have to manufacture replacements as frequently...?
- gus_massa 3y agoIs it enough to destroy drones?
- verdverm 3y agoThat's what it's for, depending on how you define "destroy" It fries on board electronics, so could be used against missiles as well, really anything within the effective range / frequency
- _DeadFred_ 3y agoI'd rather a beam of light be fired over a city than a constant stream of projectiles that have to come down somewhere.
- alimw 3y agoI think you are unjustified in squaring those numbers. A system that protects the borders protects the whole territory—so the relationship will surely be more linear than quadratic.
- ajuc 3y agoit won't because drones can go higher than 1 km
- renecito 3y ago+ tax + service fee + tip
- constantcrying 3y ago>The RFDEW is a self-contained energy weapon that can be operated by one person, and can detect, track, and engage multiple threats at a range of up to a kilometer (0.62 miles). So it obviously can not replace the million-dollar missile systems, which can, with a few installations, cover an entire country. Not that it can't be used effectively. It certainly isn't a replacement, but a new tool in the arsenal to offer higher protection to more vulnerable areas like military installations.
- theolivenbaum 3y agoAlso very useful for ships, including commercial transporters
- constantcrying 3y agoNo doubt, if you have something relatively small to defend this might absolutely be effective. For a ship I think you have to worry about energy consumption though and design for that.
- Log_out_ 3y agoAnd are easily countered with tinfoil layers containing vape fluid or bad weather.
- DarmokJalad1701 3y agoHow do you put bad weather inside tinfoil layers?
- jszymborski 3y agoYou don't really need to, just attack on days with bad weather.