5 ms·
Remember the last two-wheeled, gyro-stabilized future of transportation? The one that was largely a commercial flop, and which the company president (http://en.
by TylerE 14y ago
Remember the last two-wheeled, gyro-stabilized future of transportation? The one that was largely a commercial flop, and which the company president (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Heselden http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Heselden) _drove off a cliff_.
- amalag 14y agoThe segway does what it's supposed to do. I think it has it's useful niche. It was marketed as a replacement for all transportation, but that is silly because only because of the cost.
- untog 14y agoWell, no- it was supposed to revolutionise personal transportation. At least, that's what they said when it launched. And the "future of transportation" sounds eerily similar.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoSpeaking of cost, this vehicle will start for ~$24,000. I mean, I'd buy it for... maybe $5000ish, if I were feeling particularly spendy?
- WiseWeasel 14y agoThey did mention that rev two would be around $16,000, assuming they're still in business. That's getting closer to a realistic price relative to competing products. Keep in mind that this is competing with commuter cars, not motorcycles. You can also deduct the cost of fuel over the vehicle's lifetime. For someone commuting one hour each way to work five days a week, the cost of gas for a big car can exceed $200/month, $2400/year, or $12,000 over the course of five years. That makes the up-front price seem quite a bit more competitive with gas-powered alternatives.
- TylerE 14y agoYou need to factor in the medical bills, though. With a loaded weight of under 1000lbs, in any sort of collision, this thing will lose. Doesn't really matter how strong the frame is, it's just simple physics. Similar situation with the "Smart" car. The passenger cell can take a 60mph impact into a barrier just fine. The passengers - not so much, the g-forces inflicted are much higher than a traditional vehicle. Even 12-18 inches of crumple zone would make a BIG difference.
- WiseWeasel 14y agoUnless the person you crash into is also driving one of these, in which case you both win, relatively speaking. Safety does remain a very important consideration here, and I'm also wondering how safe those heavy gyroscopes under your seat are in a collision. They had better be extremely well-shielded from the passenger compartment.
- excuse-me 14y agoThat's the arms race - on the road the more massive vehicle in a collision wins. So if you care about your dear little children you have to buy the M1 Abrahams tank. A mere $4.3M for the peace of mind of knowing your little ones are protected in a collision with an Escalade. (ps the 120mm cannon is also useful against Volvos)
- TylerE 14y agoEven hitting another one of these or a similar super-light vehicle, you both still lose. For survivability there is absolutely no replacement for deformable structure aka crumple zones.
- morsch 14y agoWell, you're still paying for fuel/energy unless you recharge at work. ;) Of course it's a much more efficient vehicle than a car, due to it's weight, the higher efficiency of electrical motors[1] and regenerative braking. One figure in the article is 220 miles on an 8kWh battery. I think I pay something like €0.25 per kWh, most of you probably spend less. So about 100 miles/€, and about €2 to recharge the whole battery. [1] Not that they're readily comparable, since "regular" motors convert a primary fuel into motion, while electrical motors convert electrical energy. Which itself is often generated from a primary fuel, introducing significant inefficiency.
- untog 14y agoWorth clarifying that he didn't drive off a cliff in an act of suicide- it was an accident.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- slavak 14y agoThis was what I thought they were talking about when I saw the headline. I assumed this was an amused look back on the good ol' days. I never did understand why anyone ever thought the Segway would revolutionize anything. I don't see the big advantage, and - frankly - you look downright ridiculous riding it. And yes - I did get to ride it. It's kind of cool for the novelty factor, but I fail to see any incredible advantage over the more traditional alternatives.
- jakejake 14y agoOne place I've seen them where I thought they really made sense were in large parks where security guards ride around on them, able to cover a lot of ground using the walking paths.
- CognitiveLens 14y agoCovering more ground in a way that was more effective at stopping ne'er-do-wells than riding a bicycle? Electric-assisted bicycle if it is hilly? Segways are not off-road vehicles, nor are they fast or maneuverable enough to be an effective security vehicle.
- jakejake 14y agoI would actually like to see a high-speed segway chase!
- jackalope 14y agoOr Buckminster Fuller's Dymaxion car? It suffered a similar tragedy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dymaxion_car#World.27s_Fair_accident http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dymaxion_car#World.27s_Fair_acc... The first picture in the Wired article shows the driver's unhelmeted head poking out of the roof above the rollbar. Prototype or not, how could the CEO even let a photo be taken of such an obvious safety flaw, let alone allow a journalist to take it for a test drive? Demonstrating a lax attitude towards safety is enough to scare off investors.
- BHSPitMonkey 14y agoIt's obviously designed to administer as much force as possible directly to the brain in the case of a collision.
- dandrews 14y agoYes, I remember the Segway. I've owned a pair for five years and have 13,000 miles between them. It didn't take over the world, but it fits my use case perfectly.
- sien 14y agoWhy don't you use a bike? I've done that sort of distance on my pushbike. It cost $AU 750 and it kept me fit.
- dandrews 14y agoNo shower at the office, otherwise I'd have given up the Volvo for my Raleigh a long time ago. I agree with you about the fitness aspect of bicycle riding, and used to do distance stuff (no racing) until I wore the cartilage down in my left knee. Nowadays I treat that knee with respect. Bicycle goodness notwithstanding, the Segway is a hoot to ride, and five years in I haven't tired of it.